Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is a treatment modality that is frequently used as salvage therapy for small nodular recurrent high-grade gliomas (HGG). Due to the infiltrative nature of HGG, it is unclear if this highly focused technique provides a durable local control benefit. To determine how demographic or clinical factors influence the pattern of failure following SRS for recurrent high-grade gliomas. We retrospectively reviewed clinical, radiographic, and follow-up information for 47 consecutive patients receiving SRS for recurrent HGG at our institution between June 2006 and July 2016. All patients initially presented with an HGG (WHO grade III and IV). Following SRS for recurrence, all patients experienced treatment failure, and we evaluated patterns of local, regional, and distant failure in relation to the SRS 50% isodose line. Most patients with recurrent HGG developed "in-field" treatment failure following SRS (n=40; 85%). Higher SRS doses were associated with longer time to failure (hazards ratio=0.80 per 1 Gy increase; 95% confidence interval 0.67-0.96; P=.016). There was a statistically significant increase in distant versus in-field failure among older patients (P=.035). This effect was independent of bevacizumab use (odds ratio=0.54, P=1.0). Based on our experience, the majority of treatment failures after SRS for recurrent HGG were "in-field." Older patients, however, presented with more distant failures. Our results indicate that higher SRS doses delivered to a larger area as fractioned or unfractioned regimen may prolong time to failure, especially in the older population.