Simulations of musculoskeletal models are useful for estimating internal muscle and joint forces. However, predicted forces rely on optimization and modeling formulations. Geometric detail is important to predict muscle forces, and greater geometric complexity is required for muscles that have broad attachments or span many joints, as in the torso. However, the extent to which optimized muscle force recruitment is sensitive to these geometry choices is unclear. We developed level, uphill and downhill sloped walking simulations using a standard (uniformly weighted, “fatigue-like”) cost function with lower limb and full-body musculoskeletal models to evaluate hip muscle recruitment with different geometric representations of the psoas muscle under walking conditions with varying hip moment demands. We also tested a novel cost function formulation where muscle activations were weighted according to the modeled geometric detail in the full-body model. Total psoas force was less and iliacus, rectus femoris, and other hip flexors’ force was greater when psoas was modeled with greater geometric detail compared to other hip muscles for all slopes. The proposed weighting scheme restored hip muscle force recruitment without sacrificing detailed psoas geometry. In addition, we found that lumbar, but not hip, joint contact forces were influenced by psoas force recruitment. Our results demonstrate that static optimization dependent simulations using models comprised of muscles with different amounts of geometric detail bias force recruitment toward muscles with less geometric detail. Muscle activation weighting that accounts for differences in geometric complexity across muscles corrects for this recruitment bias.
Read full abstract