The concerns for selenium (Se) toxicity problems became a major issue to the coal mining industry in the western United States during the 1970s. Problems with Se toxicity in aquatic ecosystems led to a great amount of speculation with regard to Se levels found in backfill and soil materials at surface coal mines. Regulatory agencies quickly established standards to deal with the potential calamity based on limited databases which were conservative in the context of today's knowledge of the Se toxicity issue. The economic impact of these standards has been substantial as a result of regulatory mitigation requirements. Analysis of data collected in the western United States demonstrates that Se levels corresponding to near maximum threshold limits do not usually result in toxic levels of Se in the vetation. For example, at the San Juan Mine, New Mexico, the mean hot-water soluble Se for backfill materials was 0.122 ppm which is above the suitability limit of 0.10 ppm previously used as the maximum by the New Mexico Mining and Minerals Division. Corresponding levels of Se found in four wing saltbush were about 0.84 ppm Se. Therefore, near maximum threshold levels of hot-water soluble Se found in the backfill material results in Se levels of four wing saltbush that are much lower than the 5.0 ppm chronic toxicity level for vegetation. At the Navajo Mine, cattle grazing reclaimed lands exhibited a deficiency in blood Se levels as opposed to a toxicity. There is clear evidence that chronic Se toxicity to limestock and wildlife is unlikely on grazing rangeland or reclaimed mine land and is only problematic on three sites that provide limited alternatives to high Se vegetation. 41 refs., 2 figs., 1 tab.
Read full abstract