J. D. Peacock, M. Armstrong, M. A. E. Browne, N. R. Golledge & M. S. Stoker write: We are unable to support the view of McCabe et al . (2007) that there were significant readvances of the Scottish Ice-sheet at Lunan Bay and near Perth. The authors provide no criteria for readvances of glaciers such as terminal moraines, a second till and/or deforming bed, and rafting and overriding of marine sediments. However, we believe that the four new 14C dates in their table 1 are useful additions to knowledge. The supposed Perth Readvance in the type area . We agree that the till at the base of the Almondbank was produced by advancing ice. However, because such till is widespread in eastern Scotland, its occurrence does not of itself support the concept of a readvance, and none of the criteria noted above are satisfied. Indeed, the only indication of a possible very local readvance in the Perth area is near Moneydie, where a section formerly exposed two tills and highly deformed lacustrine silts (Paterson 1974). This we could attribute to the expected readjustment of ice-streams during retreat. Menzies & Van Der Meer (1998) concluded that the evidence here did not support a major readvance, but rather represented ‘a single winter event’. The package of sediments was described as ‘part of a tectonised, sub-glacial, deforming bed sequence’. In the upper Forth Estuary, near Grangemouth, Sissons & Smith (1965) showed that the Main Perth Shoreline is associated with the eastern limit of a stillstand or readvance of ice, which they correlated with the ‘Perth Readvance’. However, in the Tay–Earn area, the marine limit above the Main Perth Shoreline can be followed almost to Crieff, some 25 km west of Perth, where there are fluvial terraces relating to a sea level at …