In forest ecosystems, changes in the expression of tree absorptive root traits following management interventions are expected to influence post-thinning forest structure and function. Fine root traits are expected to be especially responsive to forest thinning—one of the most common forest management interventions and the focus of our research here—influencing tree-level responses to environmental change, and thereby contributing to post-thinning stand-level dynamics and ecosystem processes. However, there remains limited understanding surrounding whether or not forest thinning influences the expression of root morphological, chemical, and physiological traits associated with belowground resource acquisition. We conducted a global meta-analysis to evaluate the response of 13 fine root traits to forest thinning. Our study included analysis of 769 paired observations of root traits values pre- and post-thinning, derived from 89 peer-reviewed publications. Our meta-analysis found that forest thinning leads to a decrease in fine root biomass by 11.7% on average, while other root traits including fine root length, root C and N concentrations, root lifespan, and root respiration rates, are largely unresponsive to thinning treatments. Thinning tended to reduce fine root biomass at early stand recovery stages, with increases in fine root biomass being detected at later seral stages, especially in heavy thinning experiments. The effect of thinning on fine root biomass was most pronounced in deeper soil horizons. The influence of thinning on fine root trait expression was not affected by ecosystem or stand type, with the exception of biomass which decreased in temperate and coniferous forests. Our results demonstrate variations of fine root traits to forest management, as well as the importance of stand recovery time and thinning intensity in regulating fine root trait expression in retention trees. These patterns may have strong implications for governing soil carbon stocks in managed forests associated with decreased root inputs into deeper soils. Overall, our findings can enhance our comprehension of how forest management affects fine root trait expression, and relationship between managed forests and belowground ecosystem structure and function.
Read full abstract