Random Mutagenesis Method Research Articles

Random Mutagenesis Methods for In Vitro Directed Enzyme Evolution

Random mutagenesis is a powerful tool for generating enzymes, proteins, entire metabolic pathways, or even entire genomes with desired or improved properties. This technology is used to evolve genes in vitro through an iterative process consisting of recombinant generation. Coupled with the development of powerful high-throughput screening or selection methods, this technique has been successfully used to solve problems in protein engineering. There are many methods to generate genetic diversity by random mutagenesis and to create combinatorial libraries. This can be achieved by treating DNA or whole bacteria with various chemical mutagens, by passing cloned genes through mutator strains, by "error-prone" PCR mutagenesis, by rolling circle error-prone PCR, or by saturation mutagenesis. The next sections of this review article focus on recent advances in techniques and methods used for in vitro directed evolution of enzymes using random mutagenesis. Selected examples, highlighting successful applications of these methods, are also presented and discussed.

Random Mutagenesis Methods for In Vitro Directed Enzyme Evolution

Random Mutagenesis Methods for In Vitro Directed Enzyme Evolution

Generation of an Arginine Auxotrophic Mutant of Colletotrichum acutatum as a Recipient Host for Insertional Mutagenesis

Colletotrichum acutatum was the main cause of the recent outbreaks of anthracnose on pepper fruit in Korea. To facilitate molecular analysis of C. acutatum, we generated an arginine auxotrophic mutant of the C acutatum strain JC24 using a targeted gene replacement strategy. A 3.3-kb genomic region carrying an ortholog (designated CaARG2) of the fungal gene encoding N-acetylglutamate synthase, the first enzyme of arginine biosynthesis in fungi, was deleted from the fungal genome. The mutant exhibited normal growth only when arginine was exogenously supplied into the culture medium. Transformation of the arginine auxotrophic mutant with a plasmid DNA carrying an intact copy of CaARG2, which was smaller than the deleted region in the mutant, not only caused random vector insertions in the fungal genome, but also recovered both hyphal growth and pathogenicity of the mutant to the wild-type level. Using this new selection system, we have successfully developed a restriction enzyme-mediated integration procedure, which would provide an economically efficient random mutagenesis method in C. acutatum.

Changing the DNA Recognition Specificity of the EcoDam DNA-(Adenine-N6)-Methyltransferase by Directed Evolution

EcoDam is an adenine-N6 DNA methyltransferase that methylates the GATC sites in the Escherichia coli genome. We have changed the target specificity of EcoDam from GATC to GATT by directed evolution, combining different random mutagenesis methods with restriction protection at GATT sites for selection and screening. By co-evolution of an enzyme library and a substrate library, we identified GATT as the best non-GATC site and discover a double mutation, R124S/P134S, as the first step to increase enzyme activity at GATT sites. After four generations of mutagenesis and selection, we obtained enzyme variants with new specificity for GATT. While the wild-type EcoDam shows no detectable activity at GATT sites in E. coli cells, some variants prefer methylation at GATT over GATC sites by about 10-fold in cells. In vitro DNA methylation kinetics carried out under single-turnover conditions using a hemimethylated GATC and a GATT oligonucleotide substrate confirmed that the evolved proteins prefer methylation of GATT sites to a similar degree. They show up to 1600-fold change in specificity in vitro and methylate the new GATT target site with 20% of the rate of GATC methylation by the wild-type enzyme, indicating good activity. We conclude that the new methyltransferases are fully functional in vivo and in vitro but show a new target-site specificity.

A frequency-controlled random mutagenesis method for GC-rich genes

A novel random mutagenesis strategy was developed by combining sodium bisulfite modification with polymerase chain reaction (PCR). This method introduced the predominant substitution of GC to AT, meaning that it was more suitable for mutagenesis of GC-rich genes and helped to decrease the GC content of target DNA. Mutation efficiency correlated with modification time and different mutation frequency could easily be obtained by controlling modification time. The results indicated that this method could yield a desired and adequate frequency of random mutation to the DNA of interest, especially GC-rich genes, and provided a powerful tool for directed molecular evolution.

Critical evaluation of random mutagenesis by error-prone polymerase chain reaction protocols, Escherichia coli mutator strain, and hydroxylamine treatment

Random mutagenesis methods constitute a valuable protein modification toolbox with applications ranging from protein engineering to directed protein evolution studies. Although a variety of techniques are currently available, the field is lacking studies that would directly compare the performance parameters and operational range of different methods. In this study, we have scrutinized several of the most commonly used random mutagenesis techniques by critically evaluating popular error-prone polymerase chain reaction (PCR) protocols as well as hydroxylamine and a mutator Escherichia coli strain mutagenesis methods. Relative mutation frequencies were analyzed using a reporter plasmid that allowed direct comparison of the methods. Error-prone PCR methods yielded the highest mutation rates and the widest operational ranges, whereas the chemical and biological methods generated a low level of mutations and exhibited a narrow range of operation. The repertoire of transitions versus transversions varied among the methods, suggesting the use of a combination of methods for high-diversity full-scale mutagenesis. Using the parameters defined in this study, the evaluated mutagenesis methods can be used for controlled mutagenesis, where the intended average frequency of induced mutations can be adjusted to a desirable level.

Selection of an Effective Red-Pigment ProducingMonascus pilosusby Efficient Transformation with Aurintricarboxylic Acid

The filamentous fungus Monascus pilosus was genetically transformed with a reporter plasmid, pMS-1.5hp, by aurintricarboxylic acid (ATA) treatment to obtain an efficient red-pigment producing mutant. The transformation efficiency of Monascus pilosus was higher with the ATA-treatment than with either a non-restriction-enzyme-mediated integration (REMI) or a REMI method. This valid and convenient random mutagenesis method shows that ATA can be applied in fungi for efficient genetic transformation.

Combinatorial engineering to enhance thermostability of amylosucrase

Amylosucrase is a transglucosidase that catalyzes amylose-like polymer synthesis from sucrose substrate. About 60,000 amylosucrase variants from two libraries generated by the MutaGen random mutagenesis method were submitted to an in vivo selection procedure leading to the isolation of more than 7000 active variants. These clones were then screened for increased thermostability using an automated screening process. This experiment yielded three improved variants (two double mutants and one single mutant) showing 3.5- to 10-fold increased half-lives at 50 degrees C compared to the wild-type enzyme. Structural analysis revealed that the main differences between wild-type amylosucrase and the most improved variant (R20C/A451T) might reside in the reorganization of salt bridges involving the surface residue R20 and the introduction of a hydrogen-bonding interaction between T451 of the B' domain and D488 of flexible loop 8. This double mutant is the most thermostable amylosucrase known to date and the only one usable at 50 degrees C. At this temperature, amylose synthesis by this variant using high sucrose concentration (600 mM) led to the production of amylose chains twice as long as those obtained by the wild-type enzyme at 30 degrees C.

A novel random mutagenesis approach using human mutagenic DNA polymerases to generate enzyme variant libraries

The in vitro MutaGen procedure is a new random mutagenesis method based on the use of low-fidelity DNA polymerases. In the present study, this technique was applied on a 2 kb gene encoding amylosucrase, an attractive enzyme for the industrial synthesis of amylose-like polymers. Mutations were first introduced during a single replicating step performed by mutagenic polymerases pol beta and pol eta. Three large libraries (>10(5) independent clones) were generated (one with pol beta and two with pol eta). The sequence analysis of randomly chosen clones confirmed the potential of this strategy for the generation of diversity. Variants generated by pol beta were 4-7-fold less mutated than those created with pol eta, indicating that our approach enables mutation rate control following the DNA polymerase employed for mutagenesis. Moreover, pol beta and pol eta provide different and complementary mutation spectra, allowing a wider sequence space exploration than error-prone PCR protocols employing Taq polymerase. Interestingly, some of the variants generated by pol eta displayed unusual modifications, including combinations of base substitutions and codon deletions which are rarely generated using other methods. By taking advantage of the mutation bias of naturally highly error-prone DNA polymerases, MutaGen thus appears as a very useful tool for gene and protein randomisation.

Transversion‐enriched sequence saturation mutagenesis (SeSaM‐Tv+): A random mutagenesis method with consecutive nucleotide exchanges that complements the bias of error‐prone PCR

The sequence saturation mutagenesis (SeSaM) method has been advanced to a random mutagenesis method with adjustable mutational biases. SeSaM offers, for example, a bias that is complementary to error-prone (ep) PCR and is enriched in transversions (SeSaM-Tv(+)). dNTP alpha S and three degenerate bases (P, K and I) are used to control mutational bias flexibly. After quantifying incorporation rates of dPTP, dKTP and dITP by terminal transferase using a luciferase-based assay and investigating the read and/or write activities of eight DNA polymerases, a transversion-enriched protocol has been developed. In a mutant library generated using dGTP alpha S and dPTP, transversion frequencies of 16.22-22.58% (G-->T) and 6.38-9.69% (G-->C) were achieved. These mutational spectra are complementary and occur twice as frequently in comparison to standard epPCR methods employing Taq DNA polymerase. For generating more complex mutant libraries, the occurrence of consecutive nucleotide exchanges was increased by 10(5)-10(6)-fold compared to epPCR. Finally, 16.7% of all sequenced mutants contained consecutive nucleotide exchanges composed mainly of a transversion followed by a transition.

Next issue (January 2008): Methods and Advances in Biotech

AbstractEdited by Dr. Barbara Janssens, Managing Editor– Recombinant therapeutic proteins– Technical aspects of biocatalysis– Advances in safe and efficient DNA therapy– SeSaM‐Tv: A random mutagenesis method– Bioinformatics: Identifying interacting residues using boolean learning and support vector machines– 3D imaging flow cytometry– Flow cytometry technology responding to HIV‐tuberculosis coinfections– Stem cell cultures: Technical aspectsMany of these exciting articles are already available online under “Early View”!A sneak preview of other content can be found under “News”.

Constitutively Active Mutants of the Histamine H1 Receptor Suggest a Conserved Hydrophobic Asparagine-Cage That Constrains the Activation of Class A G Protein-Coupled Receptors

The aim of this study was to create and characterize constitutively active mutant (CAM) histamine H(1) receptors (H(1)R) using random mutagenesis methods to further investigate the activation process of the rhodopsin-like family of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). This approach identified position 6.40 in TM 6 as a "hot spot" because mutation of Ile6.40(420) either to Glu, Gly, Ala, Arg, Lys, or Ser resulted in highly active CAM H(1)Rs, for which almost no histamine-induced receptor activation response could be detected. The highly conserved hydrophobic amino acid at position 6.40 defines, in a computational model of the H(1)R, the asparagine cage motif that restrains the side chain of Asn7.49 of the NPxxY motif toward transmembrane domain (TM 6) in the inactive state of the receptor. Mutation of the asparagine cage into Ala or Gly, removing the interfering bulky constraints, increases the constitutive activity of the receptor. The fact that the Ile6.40(420)Arg/Lys/Glu mutant receptors are highly active CAM H(1)Rs leads us to suggest that a positively charged residue, presumably the highly conserved Arg3.50 from the DRY motif, interacts in a direct or an indirect (through other side chains or/and internal water molecules) manner with the acidic Asp2.50..Asn7.49 pair for receptor activation.

Know thy fly

The generation and analysis of mutants is central to studies of gene function in model organisms. Methods for random mutagenesis in Drosophila melanogaster have been available for many years, but an alternative approach--targeted mutagenesis using homologous recombination--has only recently been developed. This approach has the advantage of specificity, because genes of interest can be altered. One might expect with a gene-targeting approach that the frequency of background mutations would be minimal. Unfortunately, we have found that this is not the case. Although the possibility of background mutations arising during homologous-recombination-based gene targeting has been raised in the literature, it is not routinely taken into account when using this technique. Our experience suggests that it can be a considerable problem but that it has a relatively simple solution.

A novel random mutagenesis method and the incorporation of an isotopic label into a protein

There are limitations on the current methods used to diversify protein sequences, such as the inability to scan mutations throughout an entire protein. We have developed a novel method, “Codon Scanning Mutagenesis”, which allows for rapid and complete scanning of a protein sequence with the use of elementary molecular biology techniques. This method is made possible by a modified transposon mutagenesis approach that randomly targets DNA sequences. This transposon allows for random insertion of a NotI restriction site, which is unique to the DNA sequence to be mutated. The randomized insertion of this restriction site thus allows for the insertion of a linker with strategically placed type II restriction sites. The properties of the type II restriction sites allow for a codon to be replaced with a new codon. We are specifically interested in the random insertion of TAG stop codons which code for unnatural amino acids carrying photoaffinity labels that can be used to probe protein-protein interactions. Finally, we show that the detection of photo-crosslinked protein-protein interactions can easily be done by mass spectrometry studies when the deuterated p-benzoylphenylalanine is incorporated as an isotopic label. This method will allow for obtaining structural information on multi-component protein complexes, provide insight into the active site residues, or even trap receptor ligands at the cell surface.

Improvement of the activity of arylmalonate decarboxylase by random mutagenesis

Arylmalonate decarboxylase (EC 4.1.1.76) catalyzes enantioselective decarboxylation of alpha-aryl-alpha-methylmalonates to give optically pure alpha-arylpropionates. Recently, we have succeeded in creating a double mutant enzyme that gave opposite enantionmer as the product. Unfortunately, however, the activity of the mutant decreased far lower than that of the native enzyme. Thus, we performed the directed evolution of the mutant via the random mutagenesis method employing the mutator strain Escherichia coli XL1-Red. About 50,000 mutants were screened on color assay plate, and one mutant with higher activity was obtained. Gene analysis of this mutant indicated that the obtained enzyme had an S36N mutation in addition to its original G74C/C188S mutations. The activity of the triple mutant enzyme was tenfold higher than that of the starting doubly mutated enzyme.

The Diversity Challenge in Directed Protein Evolution

Over the past decade, we have witnessed a bloom in the field of evolutive protein engineering which is fueled by advances in molecular biology techniques and high-throughput screening technology. Directed protein evolution is a powerful algorithm using iterative cycles of random mutagenesis and screening for tailoring protein properties to our needs in industrial applications and for elucidating proteins' structure function relationships. This review summarizes, categorizes and discusses advantages and disadvantages of random mutagenesis methods used for generating genetic diversity. These random mutagenesis methods have been classified into four main categories depending on the method employed for nucleotide substitutions: enzyme based methods (Category I), synthetic chemistry based methods (Category II), whole cell methods (Category III) and combined methods (Category I-II, I-III and II-III). The basic principle of each method is discussed and varied mutagenic conditions are summarized in Tables and compared (benchmarked) to each other in terms of: mutational bias, controllable mutation frequency, ability to generate consecutive nucleotide substitutions and subset diversity, dependency on gene length, technical simplicity/robustness and cost-effectiveness. The latter comparison shows how highly-biased and limited current diversity creating methods are. Based on these limitations, strategies for generating diverse mutant libraries are proposed and discussed (RaMuS-Flowchart; KISS principle). We hope that this review provides, especially for researchers just entering the field of directed evolution, a guide for developing successful directed evolution strategies by selecting complementary methods for generating diverse mutant libraries.

A Statistical Analysis of Random Mutagenesis Methods Used for Directed Protein Evolution

We have developed a statistical method named MAP (mutagenesis assistant program) to equip protein engineers with a tool to develop promising directed evolution strategies by comparing 19 mutagenesis methods. Instead of conventional transition/transversion bias indicators as benchmarks for comparison, we propose to use three indicators based on the subset of amino acid substitutions generated on the protein level: (1) protein structure indicator; (2) amino acid diversity indicator with a codon diversity coefficient; and (3) chemical diversity indicator. A MAP analysis for a single nucleotide substitution was performed for four genes: (1) heme domain of cytochrome P450 BM-3 from Bacillus megaterium (EC 1.14.14.1); (2) glucose oxidase from Aspergillus niger (EC 1.1.3.4); (3) arylesterase from Pseudomonas fluorescens (EC 3.1.1.2); and (4) alcohol dehydrogenase from Saccharomyces cerevisiae (EC 1.1.1.1). Based on the MAP analysis of these four genes, 19 mutagenesis methods have been evaluated and criteria for an ideal mutagenesis method have been proposed. The statistical analysis showed that existing gene mutagenesis methods are limited and highly biased. An average amino acid substitution per residue of only 3.15-7.4 can be achieved with current random mutagenesis methods. For the four investigated gene sequences, an average fraction of amino acid substitutions of 0.5-7% results in stop codons and 4.5-23.9% in glycine or proline residues. An average fraction of 16.2-44.2% of the amino acid substitutions are preserved, and 45.6% (epPCR method) are chemically different. The diversity remains low even when applying a non-biased method: an average of seven amino acid substitutions per residue, 2.9-4.7% stop codons, 11.1-16% glycine/proline residues, 21-25.8% preserved amino acids, and 55.5% are amino acids with chemically different side-chains. Statistical information for each mutagenesis method can further be used to investigate the mutational spectra in protein regions regarded as important for the property of interest.

Improving enzyme properties: when are closer mutations better?

Study of mutations that improve enzyme properties reveals that in many, but not all, cases closer mutations are more effective than distant ones. For enantioselectivity, substrate selectivity and new catalytic activity (catalytic promiscuity) closer mutations improved enzymes more effectively than distant ones. However, both close and distant mutations can improve activity, thermal stability and also probably stability toward organic solvents. Typical random mutagenesis methods, such as error-prone PCR, create greater numbers of distant mutations than close mutations because enzymes contain more amino acids distant from the active site than close to the active site. This suggests that instead of mutating the entire enzyme, focusing mutations near the substrate-binding site might dramatically increase the success rate in many directed evolution experiments.

One-step random mutagenesis by error-prone rolling circle amplification

In vitro random mutagenesis is a powerful tool for altering properties of enzymes. We describe here a novel random mutagenesis method using rolling circle amplification, named error-prone RCA. This method consists of only one DNA amplification step followed by transformation of the host strain, without treatment with any restriction enzymes or DNA ligases, and results in a randomly mutated plasmid library with 3-4 mutations per kilobase. Specific primers or special equipment, such as a thermal-cycler, are not required. This method permits rapid preparation of randomly mutated plasmid libraries, enabling random mutagenesis to become a more commonly used technique.

Engineered enzymes for improved organic synthesis.

Recent developments to modify enzymes for use in organic synthesis have targeted several areas. These include altering the reaction mechanism of the enzyme to catalyse new reactions, switching substrate specificity, expanding substrate specificity, and improving substrate specificity, such as enantioselectivity in kinetic resolutions. Such modifications can be achieved either by rational redesign, which requires knowledge of the enzyme structure, or by random mutagenesis methods followed by screening. Both strategies of enzyme engineering can be successful and are very useful for improving the utility of enzymes for applied catalysis. Several examples illustrating these concepts in a variety of enzyme classes have appeared recently.