Scullin became Prime Minister1 after a landslide victory to Labor on 12 October 1929. Only twenty-seven months later, Scullin led the party to humiliating defeat, Labor membership of the House having declined from forty-seven to thirteen. Almost from the time he became Prime Minister, Scullin's record was largely one of failure: failure to counter the worsening depression, failure to honour an election promise that the New South Wales northern coalfields, closed for months by a lockout, would be opened on the men's terms. The received opinion among historians is that he was 'weak', unfitted to the demands of 1930 and 1931 and, as well, perhaps unequal to the job of Prime Minister. Moreover, certain of Scullin's actions seemed to be so little in keeping with the philosophy of the party he led that an impression has been created of a man who forgot Labor principles while in office. In fact, a close study of his prime ministership seems to show that, faced with a series of crises, Scullin responded with a set of decisions which were, with some exceptions, perfectly reasonable?even though on occasions the arguments for and against a particular course of action were finely balanced. His apparent rejection of some traditional Labor principles sprang from a conviction that compromise was necessary in order to preserve workers and pensioners from even worse hardships. Three quarters of a loaf, he reckoned, was better than half. The son of a Victorian railway worker, J. H. Scullin joined the Labor Party at twenty-seven?rather older than did some other Labor leaders. Seven years later, in 1910, he began a three-year term as the Federal member for Corangamite, a rural electorate in Victoria's Western District. Corangamite was lost in the swing against Labor in 1913, and for almost a decade after that Scullin was editor of a Labor newspaper, the Ballarat Evening Echo. Although now outside Parliament, Scullin attracted considerable attention in the Labor movement, most notably for his fierce opposition to Hughes' attempt in 1916 to introduce con scription for overseas military service. When Tudor, leader of the Labor Party and member for Yarra, died in January 1922, Scullin secured party endorsement for the vacant electorate from a big field. Yarra was one of Australia's safest Labor seats, and a few months after his election to Parliament, Scullin went to live there, in the inner Melbourne suburb of Richmond. His activities in a Caucus which lacked the great names of Fisher's era, combined with his skill and