Chamberlain, G. Victor Bonney. The Gynaecological Surgeon of the Twentieth Century. 140 pages, figures. New York, London : The Parthenon Publishing Group , 2000 . Price GBP 19.95, USD 29.95 . We tend to forget or neglect the giants on whose shoulders we stand. Before reading the present biography about Victor Bonney, my only link to the name was through Bonney’s test in examination for stress incontinence, which never raised my curiosity enough to search for the man behind the name. Geoffrey Chamberlain has put the matter straight by giving a painstaking account of Bonney’s life and accomplishments, from his birth in Chelsea in 1872 until he died in 1953. Robert Shaw states in the Foreword that Bonney was indeed a leading, if not the fore most, gynecological surgeon of the first half of the twentieth century. As a young doctor he entered into gynecological surgery at Chelsea Hospital by coincidence, in 1899. The next year he trained in obstetrics at Queen Charlotte’s Hospital, and from there went steadily up the ladder, specializing in gynecological surgery and becoming a Hunterian professor at the Royal College of Surgeons at the age of 35. In 1905 Ernst Wertheim visited the United Kingdom and demonstrated his radical hysterectomy for cancer of the cervix, unfortunately with a fatal result, as the patient died of peritonitis three days later. In those days, before radium treatment for advanced stages of the disease was established, radical surgery remained the patients’ only hope of survival. Bonney took up the challenge and performed a series of radical hysterectomies with favorable results. Before the advent of modern anesthetics, antibiotics and blood transfusions, radical operations demanded much more surgical skill than today. He also became a proponent for conservative management of the myomatous uterus, doing myomectomies instead of removing the whole organ. His record was the removal of 234 fibroids from one uterus. This may have been an effect of his wife’s experience. Shortly after their wedding in 1905, she had a hysterectomy because of heavy bleeding, rendering the Bonney’s childless. Bonney deservedly achieved great fame as a gynecological surgeon, but ironically had the same experience as Wertheim had had in London, when a patient died on the operating table when he demonstrated his skills to colleagues on a tour to New Zealand in 1927. The moral of the story is left to the reader. Chamberlain gives a vivid account of Bonney’s private life: his obsession with motor cars in the early years of the twentieth century, devotion to opera, fondness of dancing, painting, friendship with others high and mighty like Rudyard Kipling, and his chain smoking, preferably of cigars. He wrote textbooks. The most famous of these, A Textbook of Gynaecological Surgery, appeared in 1911, and the 6th edition appeared in 1952. Bonney’s affiliation with the Royal College of Surgeons and his opposition to the foundation of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists is a recurring theme. He was clearly a man of conservative attitudes, who held his ground to the last minute and a bit beyond. The chapters are in chronological order, following world events. During the Second World War Bonney, who turned seventy in 1942, took on a locum gynecological post in Cheltenham for the duration of the war. He was then described as ‘a dapper little man, beautifully but quietly dressed with a double gold Albert across his waistcoat and carrying a gold-headed cane’. He charmed all the women (patients and nurses alike) by calling them ‘Darling’. Those of you who are curious to learn how the speciality of obstetrics and gynecology evolved and how surgery in the early years was its mainstay, will enjoy reading this book. It primarily addresses British readers, but as medicine is universal, it will appeal to all. It contains a set of photographs, mainly of the family album type. The binding of my copy was poor, pages loosened too easily.
Read full abstract