Reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA) requiring extensive reaming to address severe glenoid bone loss increases the risk of glenoid medialization and baseplate failure. We hypothesized that i) metal augmented baseplate prevents the medialization of the joint line and preserves glenoid bone stock similarly to BIO-RSA; ii) bone graft viability and healing in BIO-RSA patients become compromised over time. Eighty-one patients (83 shoulders) underwent glenoid lateralization with bone (BIO-RSA group, 44) or metal augmented baseplate (MIO-RSA group, 39) and a minimum follow-up of 24 months were included. The orientation and direction of glenoid erosion was identified and recorded using computerized 3D planning. Active range of motion, and the Western Ontario Osteoarthritis of the Shoulder (WOOS) index were assessed before arthroplasty and at the last follow-up visits. Radiographic changes around the glenoid and humeral components were assessed. Healing and thickness of bone graft were evaluated by predefined criteria. Postoperative global glenoid inclination (β angle) and retroversion were also measured. Delta scores of active anterior elevation were higher in the MIO-RSA group (p= 0.027). The differences in the other planes of shoulder motion and in WOOS index scores between the groups were not significant. Preoperative glenoid retroversion was higher in BIO-RSA patients, glenoid inclination was similar in both groups. Type B2 and B3 glenoids had a posterior-central (91%) and posterior-superior (90%) erosion with a mean posterior humeral head subluxation of 76% and 78%, respectively. The direction of erosion in Type E2 and E3 glenoids was posterior-superior, with a mean posterior humeral head subluxation of 74%. The rate of high position of the glenosphere was higher in the BIO-RSA group (p = 0.022), while the values of β angle and postoperative retroversion were similar in the two groups. BIO-RSA group showed radiolucent lines < 2mm around the bone graft in 16 patients (36.4%) and decreased thickness in 15 (34.1%). Incomplete baseplate seating was found in 4 MIO-RSA patients (10%). We found higher rate of humerus condensation lines in MIO-RSA patients (p= 0.01) and higher rate of cortical thinning and tuberosity resorption in the BIO-RSA group (p= 0.027 and p = 0.004, respectively). Metal augmented glenoid is a suitable alternative to BIO-RSA to preserve bone and prevent the medialization of the joint line in arthritic glenoid with multiplanar glenoid deformity. Bone and metal augmentation provided satisfactory clinical outcomes. Bone graft resorption in BIO-RSA patient raise concern about the risk of baseplate loosening and requires further long term studies.
Read full abstract