Racemic Crystals Research Articles

Proton Conduction in Chiral Molecular Assemblies of Azolium-Camphorsulfonate Salts.

Chiral molecular assemblies have attracted considerable attention because of their interesting physical properties, such as spin-selective electron transport. Cation-anion salts of three azolium cations, imidazolium (HIm+), triazolium (HTrz+), and thiazolium (HThz+), in combination with a chiral camphorsulfonate (1S-CS-) and their racemic compounds (rac-CS-) were prepared and compared in terms of phase transitions, crystal structures, dynamics of constituent molecules, dielectric responses, and proton conductivities. The cation-anion crystals containing HIm+ showed no significant difference in proton conductivity between the homochiral and racemic crystals, whereas the HTrz+-containing crystals showed higher proton conductivity and lower activation energy in the homochiral form than in the racemic form. A two-dimensional hydrogen-bonding network consisting of HTrz+ and -SO3- groups and similar in-plane rotational motion was observed in both crystals; however, the HTrz+ cation in the homochiral crystal exhibited the rotational motion modulated with translational motion, whereas the HTrz+ cation in the racemic crystal exhibited almost steady in-plane rotational motion. The different motional degrees of freedom were confirmed by crystal structure analyses and temperature- and frequency-dependent dielectric constants. In contrast, steady in-plane rotational motion with the thermally activated fluctuating motion of CS- was observed both in homochiral and racemic crystals containing HIm+, which averaged the motional space of protons resulting in similar dielectric responses and proton conductivities. The control of motional degrees of freedom in homochiral crystals affects the proton conductivity and is useful for the design of molecular proton conductors.

Helicenes on Surfaces: Stereospecific On-Surface Chemistry, Single Enantiomorphism, and Electron Spin Selectivity.

Helicenes represent an important class of chiral organic material with promising optoelectronic properties. Hence, functionalization of surfaces with helicenes is a key step towards new organic material devices. This review presents different aspects of adsorption and modification of metal surfaces with different helicene species. Topics addressed are chiral crystallization, that is, 2D conglomerate versus racemate crystallization, breaking of mirror-symmetry in racemates, chirality-induced spin selectivity, and stereoselective on-surface chemistry.

Assembly of Y(III)-containing antimonotungstates induced by malic acid with catalytic activity for the synthesis of imidazoles

A dimeric Y(III)-containing antimonotungstate [Y4(H2O)8(mal)2(OAc)O(Sb2WV2WVI19O72)2]21− (Y4mal2, H3mal = dl-malic acid), resembling a “handshake” configuration, was synthesized and characterized. The polyanion of Y4mal2 consists of two Dawson-derived {Y2Sb2W21} moieties that are further linked by two mal ligands and one μ2-bridging acetate to form an asymmetric polyanion. Notably, the chiral configuration induced by the d- or l-configuration of the mal ligand results in both {Y2Sb2W21} moieties within one polyanion exhibiting identical chirality, leading to the racemate crystallization of Y4mal2. Moreover, Y4mal2 exhibits excellent Lewis acid catalytic activity for environmentally friendly synthesis of imidazoles.

Benzocoumarin‐Fused Triskelions Exhibit AIEE Due to Inhibited Molecular Inversion

AbstractDeveloping aggregation‐induced emission luminogens (AIEgens) is a unique strategy for alleviating concentration quenching of π‐conjugated organic compounds. This AIE behaviour can be induced not only in organic dyes with rotors but also in invertible π‐conjugated systems. Herein, intramolecular Ullmann coupling was used to synthesize π‐twisted triskelion‐shaped AIEgens (2F, 2G, and 2H), in which benzo[f], [g], and [h] coumarins were fused into the benzene core to form a helical propeller shape. These structural isomers had unique molecular thicknesses and planarities depending on the fusion mode of the benzocoumarin. The racemic crystals, PPP and MMM, had different overlapping molecular configurations because of their twisted molecular frameworks. Compounds 2F, 2G and 2H demonstrated weak fluorescence emission in diluted solutions resulting from molecular motions caused by the isomerization process during molecular inversion. By comparison, aggregates exhibited enhanced emission intensity. These π‐twisted triskelions exhibited the characteristics of AIEgens.

Influence of Controlled Chirality on the Crystallization of Maleimide-Functionalized 3,4-Ethylenedioxythiophene (EDOT-MA) Monomers.

Conjugated poly(alkoxythiophenes) such as poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) (PEDOT) have attracted considerable interest for use in a variety of applications such as biomedical devices, energy storage, and chemical sensing. Functionalized versions of the 3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene (EDOT) monomer make it possible to create polymers with properties tailored for specific applications. The maleimide functional group shows particular promise due to the wide variety of chemical modifications that it can undergo. Here, we examine the role that control of the chirality of the maleimide (MA) substituent has on the crystal structure and crystallization of the EDOT-MA monomer. We describe a method for the synthesis of a homochiral (S) variant of EDOT-MA and compare its crystallography, morphology, and thermal properties to that of the (R,S) EDOT-MA racemic compound. The conformation of the EDOT-MA molecule was substantially different, with the molecules adopting an "L" shape in the homochiral crystal, while in the racemic crystals, they were more colinear. The thermal stability of the homochiral crystals (Tm = 128.6 °C) was slightly higher than the racemic ones (Tm = 102.8 °C). We expect these results to be important in better understanding the solid-state assembly of the corresponding polymers prepared from these monomers.

Catalytic Enantioselective Synthesis of Axially Chiral Imidazoles by Cation-Directed Desymmetrization.

Axially chiral five-membered heterobiaryls synthesized by enantioselective catalysis typically feature large ortho-substituents or a heteroatom in the chiral axis to maintain a stable configuration. Herein we report a cation-directed catalytic enantioselective desymmetrization method that enables rapid access to axially chiral imidazoles with the basic nitrogen at the ortho position and efficiently integrates π-stacking moieties to ensure a stable axial configuration for further applications. The process is operationally simple, is highly enantioselective, and can be performed on the gram scale. The majority of the products are obtained in >90% ee, but interestingly even those with only moderate ee can readily be enriched to near optical purity by selective racemate crystallization. Together with a mild phosphine oxide reduction method, axially chiral imidazoles such as StackPhos and its derivatives are readily prepared in high yield and excellent enantioselectivity on the gram scale. The method also enables the preparation of new chiral non-phosphine-bearing imidazoles.

Negative Nonlinear CD-ee Dependence in Polycrystalline BINOL Thin Films.

Generally, the relationship between the observed circular dichroism and the enantiomeric excess in chiral systems (CD-ee dependence) is linear. While positive nonlinear behavior has often been reported in the past, examples of negative nonlinear (NN) behavior in CD-ee dependence are rare and not well understood. Here, we present a strong NN CD-ee dependence within polycrystalline thin films of BINOL by using second-harmonic-generation circular dichroism (SHG-CD) and commercial CD spectroscopy studies. Theoretical calculations, microscopy, and FTIR studies are employed to further clarify the underlying cause of this observation. This behavior is attributed to the changing supramolecular chirality of the system. Systems exhibiting NN CD-ee dependence hold promise for highly accurate enantiomeric excess characterization, which is essential for the refinement of enantio-separating and -purifying processes in pharmaceuticals, asymmetric catalysis, and chiral sensing. Our findings suggest that a whole class of single-species systems, i.e., racemate crystals, might possess NN CD-ee dependence and thus provide us a vast playground to better understand and exploit this phenomenon.

Unraveling the Structural and Property Differences between Highly Similar Chiral and Racemic Crystals Composed of Analogous Molecules

The structural differences between chiral and racemic crystals of enantiomers have piqued interest, as exemplified by classical Wallach’s rule. However, the mechanical and thermal disparities between these materials have not been thoroughly investigated. This study reports the structural and mechanical differences between chiral and racemic crystals of two analogous molecules. The similarity of molecular and crystal structures between the two analogues was validated through comparison with known chiral–racemic crystal pairs. Young’s moduli of the four crystals revealed larger values for racemic crystals than their chiral counterparts, consistent with the intermolecular interaction energies projected along the loading direction. The thermal response of crystals plays a significant role in their elastic behavior, and the temperature dependence of interaction energies along the [001] direction was found to agree with the temperature dependence of lattice dynamics for all four crystals.

Conglomerate, Racemate, and Achiral Crystals of Polymetallic Europium(III) Compounds of Bis- or Tris-β-diketonate Ligands and Circularly Polarized Luminescence Study.

This work reports (a) conglomerate and racemic crystal structures of [(Δ,Δ,Δ,Δ,Δ,Δ)- or/and (Λ,Λ,Λ,Λ,Λ,Λ)-EuIII 6(TTP)8(OH2)6Na4] n coordination polymers, (b) racemic crystal structures of (Δ,Δ,Δ,Δ)-/(Λ,Λ,Λ,Λ)-EuIII 4(TTP)4(bipy)4(MEK)2(OH2)2 tetrahedral clusters, and (c) the achiral crystal structure of the [EuIII 2(BTP)4(OH2)2Na2] n coordination polymer (where BTP = dianionic bis-β-diketonate, TTP = trianionic tris-β-diketonate, and bipy = 2,2'-bipyridine). The screw coordination arrangement of the TTP ligand has led to the formation of homoconfigurational racemic EuIII products. The conglomerate crystallization of [EuIII 6(TTP)8(OH2)6Na4] n appears to be caused by the presence of the sodium, Na+ counterions, and interactions between oxygen atoms and the trifluoromethyl unit of the TTP ligand and Na+ ions. All the EuIII compounds exhibit characteristic red luminescence (5D0 → 7FJ, J = 0-4) in solution or in the solid crystalline state. Circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) was observed in the chiral EuIII 6(TTP)8(OH2)6Na4] n species, displaying a |g lum| value in the range of 0.15 to 0.68 at the 5D0 → 7F1 emission band. Subtle changes of the [EuIII 6(TTP)8(OH2)6Na4] n structure which may be due to selection of twinned crystals or crystals that do not correspond to a perfect spontaneous resolution, are considered to be responsible for the variation in the observed CPL values.

Selective Crystallization of Racemic Polymorph via Native Enantiomer Inhibition: dl-Methionine

Crystallization of chiral compounds is dictated by chiral recognition and molecular self-assembly in solution. However, their interplay remains elusive. The reason for the considerably reduced polymorphism in chiral molecules than that of nonchiral molecules remains unclear. Herein, we use a combination of experimental and computational techniques to show that excessive enantiomer functioning, as a native crystallization inhibitor, selectively suppresses the crystallization of racemic polymorphs, affording preferential crystallization of the metastable α polymorph of dl-methionine. Bulk crystallization assays show concomitant crystallization of the α and β polymorphs of racemic dl-methionine in the solution with no enantiomeric excess. However, when the solution contains excessive d-/l-methionine enantiomer, only the metastable α form can be crystallized. Crystal growth experiments, fluoresce confocal microscopy, and atomic force microscope surface topology measurements reveal the growth inhibition of both polymorphs with preferential suppression of the β form by excess native enantiomer. Binding energy calculations and molecular dynamic simulations further demonstrate the preferential adsorption of excessive enantiomers on the (0 0 2) facet of the β form over the α form. Overall, our results uncover a unique chiral self-positioning mechanism where the excess enantiomer solutes serve as a native growth inhibitor to disrupt the kinetics of racemic polymorphic crystallization, affording selective crystallization of only one polymorph of dl-methionine. Our results highlight the important effect of excess enantiomer in a solution on the polymorph occurrence of chiral molecules.

Structural and mechanistic studies of excitation- and temperature-tunable multicolor luminescence of triarylborane

Racemate (rac-1) and conglomerate (cong-1) crystals show different phosphorescence behaviour.Rac-1 is a strong excitation-wavelength-tunable photoluminescent material; cong-1 exhibits white-light emission upon temperature change with a CIE 1931 coordinate of (0.33, 0.31).

Chirality Transfer from an Innately Chiral Nanocrystal Core to a Nematic Liquid Crystal 2: Lyotropic Chromonic Liquid Crystals.

The importance of and the difference between molecular versus structural core chirality of substances that form nanomaterials, and their ability to transmit and amplify their chirality to and within a surrounding condensed medium is yet to be exactly understood. Here we demonstrate that neat as well as disodium cromoglycate (DSCG) surface-modified cellulose nanocrystals (CNCs) with both molecular and morphological core chirality can induce homochirality in racemic nematic lyotropic chromonic liquid crystal (rac-N-LCLC) tactoids. In comparison to the parent chiral organic building blocks, D-glucose, endowed only with molecular chirality, both CNCs showed a superior chirality transfer ability. Here, particularly the structurally compatible DSCG-modified CNCs prove to be highly effective since the surface DSCG moieties can insert into the DSCG stacks that constitute the racemic tactoids. Overall, this presents a highly efficient pathway for chiral induction in an aqueous medium and thus for understanding the origins of biological homochirality in a suitable experimental system.

Intermolecular Hydrogen Bonding in Alpha-Hydroxy Carboxylic Acids Crystals: Connectivity, Synthons, Supramolecular Motifs

Synthon theory underlies the analysis and empirical prediction of the crystal structure. Supramolecular synthons (SMSs) formed by intermolecular hydrogen bonds, such as carboxylic R22(8) and C11(4) and alcoholic C11(2) ones, are among the most popular. The subject of this publication is the identification of specific synthons in alpha-hydroxycarboxylic acids (AHAs) crystals, in which carboxyl and alcohol fragments are present simultaneously. A series of 11 single-enantiomeric and racemic crystals of substituted lactic acids, the simplest chiral AHA family, were prepared and studied by the single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SC-XRD) method. Advanced analysis of our own and published (Cambridge Structural Database) data on the 33 crystal structures of lactic and achiral AHAs of diverse structures revealed that their supramolecular organization differs significantly from that of simple carboxylic acids. We found that in AHA crystals, hydrogen bonds RC(O)O−H···O(H)−C(R′R′′)C(O)OH (in our notation HB 12) and O=C(OH)C(R′R′′)−O−H···O=C(OH)R′ (HB 23) predominate. The frequency of intermolecular hydrogen bonds is interconnected with the frequency of SMSs. Thus, the synthons mentioned above occur but do not dominate in AHA crystals. Linear synthons C22(6):12/23 and cyclic synthons R22(10):23/23 and R33(11):12/23/23 are most often implemented. An essential role in the choice of cyclic synthons is played by the chiral characteristics of the sample.

Crystal Prediction via Genetic Algorithms in a Model Chiral System.

Chiral crystals and their constituent molecules play a prominent role in theories about the origin of biological homochirality and in drug discovery, design, and stability. Although the prediction and identification of stable chiral crystal structures is crucial for numerous technologies, including separation processes and polymorph selection and control, predictive ability is often complicated by a combination of many-body interactions and molecular complexity and handedness. In this work, we address these challenges by applying genetic algorithms to predict the ground-state crystal lattices formed by a chiral tetramer molecular model, which we have previously shown to exhibit complex fluid-phase behavior. Using this approach, we explore the relative stability and structures of the model's conglomerate and racemic crystals, and present a structural phase diagram for the stable Bravais crystal types in the zero-temperature limit.

Toward the Controlled Synthesis of Highly Dispersed Metal Clusters Enabled by Downsizing Crystalline Porous Organic Cage Supports.

The controlled synthesis of subnanometer-sized metal clusters (MCs) presents a fascinating prospect for the research of size-dependent properties. In this study, a facile approach by employing porous racemic organic cage crystals as supports for immobilizing a broad range of noble MCs (e.g., Ru, Ir, Rh) is reported. Downsizing the support to the nanoscale leads to resultant MCs with precisely controlled sizes <0.7nm. Such enhanced stabilization ability is a result of enhanced metal-support interactions as well as the nanoconfinement of organic cages in controlling the growth of MCs. Moreover, the obtained MCs display excellent catalytic performance in a series of liquid-phase reactions owing to a decrease in the diffusion resistance from the substrate to MCs immobilized by the nano-sized cage support.

Metallo‐Supramolecular Octahedral Cages with Three Types of Chirality towards Spontaneous Resolution

Chirality is one of the most important intrinsic properties of (supra)molecules. In this study, we obtained enantiomeric metallo-supramolecular octahedra without using any chiral sources. Such cages were self-assembled by prochiral trispyridine ligand L based on a C3h truxene core and CuII salts. Crystallization of the cages with BF4 - as counterions afforded racemate crystals; while crystallizations of cages with ClO4 - and OTf- as counterions resulted in conglomerates with spontaneous resolution. Three types of chirality were observed in each cage, including planar chirality of the truxene core, axial chirality from the pyridyl and truxene moieties, and propeller chirality of the pyridyl-CuII coordination sites. The cages reported here are among the largest discrete synthetic metallo-supramolecules ever reported with chiral self-sorting behavior. Remarkably, the chiral cages exhibited very slow racemization even at low concentrations, suggesting their high stability in solution.

Metallo‐Supramolecular Octahedral Cages with Three Types of Chirality towards Spontaneous Resolution

AbstractChirality is one of the most important intrinsic properties of (supra)molecules. In this study, we obtained enantiomeric metallo‐supramolecular octahedra without using any chiral sources. Such cages were self‐assembled by prochiral trispyridine ligand L based on a C3h truxene core and CuII salts. Crystallization of the cages with BF4− as counterions afforded racemate crystals; while crystallizations of cages with ClO4− and OTf− as counterions resulted in conglomerates with spontaneous resolution. Three types of chirality were observed in each cage, including planar chirality of the truxene core, axial chirality from the pyridyl and truxene moieties, and propeller chirality of the pyridyl‐CuII coordination sites. The cages reported here are among the largest discrete synthetic metallo‐supramolecules ever reported with chiral self‐sorting behavior. Remarkably, the chiral cages exhibited very slow racemization even at low concentrations, suggesting their high stability in solution.

Racemic crystal structures of A-DNA duplexes.

The ease with which racemic mixtures crystallize compared with the equivalent chiral systems is routinely taken advantage of to produce crystals of small molecules. However, biological macromolecules such as DNA and proteins are naturally chiral, and thus the limited range of chiral space groups available hampers the crystallization of such molecules. Inspiring work over the past 15 years has shown that racemic mixtures of proteins, which were made possible by impressive advances in protein chemical synthesis, can indeed improve the success rate of protein crystallization experiments. More recently, the racemic crystallization approach was extended to include nucleic acids as a possible aid in the determination of enantiopure DNA crystal structures. Here, findings are reported that suggest that the benefits may extend beyond this. Two racemic crystal structures of the DNA sequence d(CCCGGG) are described which were found to fold into A-form DNA. This form differs from the Z-form DNA conformation adopted by the chiral equivalent in the solid state, suggesting that the use of racemates may also favour the emergence of new conformations. Importantly, the racemic mixture forms interactions in the solid state that differ from the chiral equivalent (including the formation of racemic pseudo-helices), suggesting that the use of racemic DNA mixtures could provide new possibilities for the design of precise self-assembled nanomaterials and nanostructures.

Intermolecular Halogen Bond Detected in Racemic and Optically Pure N-C Axially Chiral 3-(2-Halophenyl)quinazoline-4-thione Derivatives.

The halogen bond has been widely used as an important supramolecular tool in various research areas. However, there are relatively few studies on halogen bonding related to molecular chirality. 3-(2-Halophenyl)quinazoline-4-thione derivatives have stable atropisomeric structures due to the rotational restriction around an N-C single bond. In X-ray single crystal structures of the racemic and optically pure N-C axially chiral quinazoline-4-thiones, we found that different types of intermolecular halogen bonds (C=S⋯X) are formed. That is, in the racemic crystals, the intermolecular halogen bond between the ortho-halogen atom and sulfur atom was found to be oriented in a periplanar conformation toward the thiocarbonyl plane, leading to a syndiotactic zig-zag array. On the other hand, the halogen bond in the enantiomerically pure crystals was oriented orthogonally toward the thiocarbonyl plane, resulting in the formation of a homochiral dimer. These results indicate that the corresponding racemic and optically pure forms in chiral molecules are expected to display different halogen bonding properties, respectively, and should be separately studied as different chemical entities.

Additive-assisted preferential crystallization of racemic component: A case of norvaline

Herein, we report a successful resolution of L-norvaline, a racemic compound system, performed near the eutectic composition by coupling preferential crystallization with tailor-made additives. The structures of enantiomer and racemate were characterized by PXRD, DSC, and the enantiomeric purity were measured by Chiral HPLC. The preferential crystallization process was designed and established from binary melting phase diagram and ternary solution phase diagram. The effects of supersaturation, solution enantiomer composition, and seed quantity on the preferential crystallization process were investigated. However, the significant improvements of enantiomeric purity and product yield were demonstrated by additive-assisted preferential crystallization approach using tailor-made additives. These additives bearing similar structure motifs to norvaline a highly selective binding to the racemate rather than enantiomer and remarkably suppress nucleation of DL-norvaline, the key factor determining the resultant enantiomer purity and separation efficiency. The underly inhibition principle was revealed due to the centrosymmetric packing of the racemate while the polarity of enantiomer leads to only partial or slight crystallization suppression. The interesting inhibition mode by tailor-made additives is also believed to be applicable for other racemic crystallization systems. Our established additive-assisted preferential crystallization has showed great potential in the development of separation technology and resolution of enantiomer from racemic compounds.