Reviews 163 believe) that Walker met Carson in Independence in 1826 and thereafter “took an avuncular interest” in him. Gilbert defends Walker for having ordered his men to fire upon the Digger Indians in 1833, when these Indians had never seen guns before. Thirty-nine of them were killed. All the trappers believed in and acted upon the principle of retaliation, but only Walker acted on the principle of “the preventive strike” and most people then and now find this principle hard to justify. It is not true that Lucien Fontenelle committed suicide at Fort Laramie in 1838 while drunk, nor that Gantt and Blackwell went broke in 1831, and it is distressing to find these old mistakes repeated here, as well as to find Marcellin St. Vrain’s name changed to Marcellus. The author located Bent’s Old Fort “near the present Kansas-Colorado line” (p. 10) and “on the head waters of the Arkansas River” (p. 156). Neither is anywhere close to the correct location. Tecumseh did not go “down to his final defeat in Michigan” nor did this “shatter his coalition” (p. 53), which had been shattered by the battle of Tippecanoe. St. Clair’s defeat occurred on the Wabash River, not the Maumee, and the battle lasted three or four hours instead of two days (p. 35). General Pope did not command the Union Army at the battle of Antietam (p. 242). These errors arise from dragging in material that has no connection with the life of Joseph Walker. Readers will find almost everything that is known about Walker between the covers of this book and a good deal more besides. It is all presented in a readable but rather tendentious style. Readers should be alert for special pleading and overstatement. HARVEY L. CARTER, Colorado College An Account of a Voyage to the North West Coast of America in 1785 and 1786. By Alexander Walker. Edited by Robin Fisher and J. M. Bumsted. (Vancouver/Toronto: Douglas & McIntyre, and Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1983. 319 pages, $24.95.) In 1785 Ensign Alexander Walker, in service with the East India Com pany, accompanied the fur-trading expedition of C. J. S. Strange, “Senior Merchant of the Madras Establishment.” The expedition spent most of its time in the Nootka Sound region of the central west coast of Vancouver Island and made some exploration of the Queen Charlotte Strait area. Walker’s “Account” is his reconstruction of the observations he made of the Indians, the geography, and the flora and fauna of the regions visited. His original manuscript was lost but Walker had made extensive notes and sketches, and when he retired from government service in 1812 he pre pared his account for publication. Until now it remained, unpublished, among his papers. The fact that his account was not written until almost twenty years after the expedition is fortunate. Walker was an intelligent observer and his immediate observations were enhanced by what he later 164 Western American Literature learned in observing and writing about the “Hindoos” and by the other com parative culture studies which he read. His is the first account of the North west Indians composed in the context of early nineteenth-century studies of the culture of India. Thus his account is not simply a narrative of a voyage, although Walker does recount the voyage the ship made in a chapter written “for those who might be interested in such things.” The purpose of the account is to describe the land and its resources and its people and to make proposals for trade. In separate chapters he describes geography and climate, the trees, shrubs, plants, birds, animals and fish of each region; the language and customs of the peoples; other explorations; the problems of trading. In style and content it is an example of that combination of scientific curiosity and practicality that one often finds in the writings of late eighteenth-century citizens of the world. The detail and the accuracy of his observations are amazing. At the same time the narratives are the observations of a man limited by ideas about the nature of savagery and civilization, however advanced, and by the time he had...