Quantum Hall Plateau Transition Research Articles

Impurity effects on the zeroth pseudo-Landau level in twisted bilayer graphene

We theoretically study the impurity effects on the zeroth pseudo-Landau level (PLL) representation of the flat band in a twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) system. Our research investigates the impact of both short-range and long-range charged impurities on the PLL using the self-consistent Born approximation and random phase approximation. Our findings indicate that short-range impurities have a significant effect on the broadening of the flat band due to impurity scattering. In contrast, the impact of long-range charged impurities on the broadening of the flat band is relatively weak, and the primary impact of the Coulomb interaction is the splitting of the PLL degeneracy when a certain purity condition is satisfied. As a result, spontaneous ferromagnetic flat bands with nonzero Chern numbers emerge. Our work sheds light on the effect of impurities on the quantum Hall plateau transition in TBG systems.

Superuniversality of dimerized SU(N+M) spin chains

We explore the physics of the quantum Hall effect using the Haldane mapping of dimerised $SU(N+M)$ spin chains, the large $N$ expansion and the density matrix renormalization group technique. We show that while the transition is first order for $N+M >2$, the system at zero temperature nevertheless displays a continuously diverging length scale $\xi$ (correlation length). The numerical results for $(M, N) = (1,3), ~ (2, 2),~(1, 5)$ and $(1, 7)$ indicate that $\xi$ is a directly observable physical quantity, namely the spatial width of the edge states. We relate the physical observables of the quantum spin chain to those of the quantum Hall system (and, hence, the $\vartheta$ vacuum concept in quantum field theory). Our numerical investigations provide strong evidence for the conjecture of super universality which says the dimerised spin chain quite generally displays all the basic features of the quantum Hall effect, independent of the specific values of $M$ and $N$. For the cases at hand we show that the singularity structure of the quantum Hall plateau transitions involves a universal function with two scale parameters that may in general depend on $M$ and $N$. This includes not only the Hall conductance but also the ground state energy as well as the correlation length $\xi$ with varying values of $\vartheta \sim \pi$.

Reprint of: Marginal CFT perturbations at the integer quantum Hall transition

According to recent arguments by the author, the conformal field theory (CFT) describing the scaling limit of the integer quantum Hall plateau transition is a deformed level-4 Wess–Zumino–Novikov–Witten model with Riemannian target space inside a complex Lie supergroup GL. After a summary of that proposal and some of its predictions, the leading irrelevant and relevant perturbations of the proposed CFT are discussed. Argued to be marginal, these result in a non-standard renormalization group (RG) flow near criticality, which calls for modified finite-size scaling analysis and may explain the long-standing inability of numerical work to reach agreement on the values of critical exponents. The technique of operator product expansion is used to compute the RG-beta functions up to cubic order in the couplings. The mean value of the dissipative conductance at the RG-fixed point is calculated for a cylinder geometry with any aspect ratio.

Composite fermion nonlinear sigma models

We study the integer quantum Hall plateau transition using composite fermion mean-field theory. We show that the topological $\theta = \pi$ term in the associated nonlinear sigma model [P. Kumar et al., Phys. Rev. B 100, 235124 (2019)] is stable against a certain particle-hole symmetry violating perturbation, parameterized by the composite fermion effective mass. This result, which applies to both the Halperin, Lee, and Read and Dirac composite fermion theories, represents an emergent particle-hole symmetry. For a disorder ensemble without particle-hole symmetry, we find that $\theta$ can vary continuously within the diffusive regime. Our results call for further study of the universality of the plateau transition.

Marginal CFT perturbations at the integer quantum Hall transition

According to recent arguments by the author, the conformal field theory (CFT) describing the scaling limit of the integer quantum Hall plateau transition is a deformed level-4 Wess–Zumino–Novikov–Witten model with Riemannian target space inside a complex Lie supergroup GL. After a summary of that proposal and some of its predictions, the leading irrelevant and relevant perturbations of the proposed CFT are discussed. Argued to be marginal, these result in a non-standard renormalization group (RG) flow near criticality, which calls for modified finite-size scaling analysis and may explain the long-standing inability of numerical work to reach agreement on the values of critical exponents. The technique of operator product expansion is used to compute the RG-beta functions up to cubic order in the couplings. The mean value of the dissipative conductance at the RG-fixed point is calculated for a cylinder geometry with any aspect ratio.

Doping the chiral spin liquid: Topological superconductor or chiral metal

We point out that there are two different chiral spin liquid states on the triangular lattice and discuss the conducting states that are expected on doping them. These states labeled CS1 and CS2 are associated with two distinct topological orders with different edge states, although they both spontaneously break time reversal symmetry and exhibit the same quantized spin Hall conductance. While CSL1 is related to the Kalmeyer-Laughlin state, CSL2 is the $\nu =4$ member of Kitaev's 16 fold way classification. Both states are described within the Abrikosov fermion representation of spins, and the effect of doping can be accessed by introducing charged holons. On doping CSL2, condensation of charged holons leads to a topological d+id superconductor. However on doping CSL1 , in sharp contrast , two different scenarios can arise: first, if holons condense, a chiral metal with doubled unit cell and finite Hall conductivity is obtained. However, in a second novel scenario, the internal magnetic flux adjusts with doping and holons form a bosonic integer quantum Hall (BIQH) state. Remarkably, the latter phase is identical to a $d+id$ superconductor. In this case the Mott insulator to superconductor transition is associated with a bosonic variant of the integer quantum Hall plateau transition for the holon. We connect the above two scenarios to two recent numerical studies of doped chiral spin liquids on triangular lattice. Our work clarifies the complex relation between topological superconductors, chiral spin liquids and quantum criticality .

How spectrum-wide quantum criticality protects surface states of topological superconductors from Anderson localization: Quantum Hall plateau transitions (almost) all the way down

We review recent numerical studies of two-dimensional (2D) Dirac fermion theories that exhibit an unusual mechanism of topological protection against Anderson localization. These describe surface-state quasiparticles of time-reversal invariant, three-dimensional (3D) topological superconductors (TSCs), subject to the effects of quenched disorder. Numerics reveal a surprising connection between 3D TSCs in classes AIII, CI, and DIII, and 2D quantum Hall effects in classes A, C, and D. Conventional arguments derived from the non-linear σ-model picture imply that most TSC surface states should Anderson localize for arbitrarily weak disorder (CI, AIII), or exhibit weak antilocalizing behavior (DIII). The numerical studies reviewed here instead indicate spectrum-wide surface quantum criticality, characterized by robust eigenstate multifractality throughout the surface-state energy spectrum. In other words, there is an “energy stack” of critical wave functions. For class AIII, multifractal eigenstate and conductance analysis reveals identical statistics for states throughout the stack, consistent with the class A integer quantum-Hall plateau transition (QHPT). Class CI TSCs exhibit surface stacks of class C spin QHPT states. Critical stacking of a third kind, possibly associated to the class D thermal QHPT, is identified for nematic velocity disorder of a single Majorana cone in class DIII. The Dirac theories studied here can be represented as perturbed 2D Wess–Zumino–Novikov–Witten sigma models; the numerical results link these to Pruisken models with the topological angle ϑ=π. Beyond applications to TSCs, all three stacked Dirac theories (CI, AIII, DIII) naturally arise in the effective description of dirty d-wave quasiparticles, relevant to the high-Tc cuprates.

Geometry of random potentials: Induction of two-dimensional gravity in quantum Hall plateau transitions

In the context of the Integer Quantum Hall plateau transitions, we formulate a specific map from random landscape potentials onto 2D discrete random surfaces. Critical points of the potential, namely maxima, minima and saddle points uniquely define a discrete surface $S$ and its dual $S^*$ made of quadrangular and $n-$gonal faces, respectively, thereby linking the geometry of the potential with the geometry of discrete surfaces. The map is parameter-dependent on the Fermi level. Edge states of Fermi lakes moving along equipotential contours between neighbour saddle points form a network of scatterings, which define the geometric basis, in the fermionic model, for the plateau transitions. The replacement probability characterizing the network model with geometric disorder recently proposed by Gruzberg, Kl\"umper, Nuding and Sedrakyan, is physically interpreted within the current framework as a parameter connected with the Fermi level.

Classification of Topological Phase Transitions and van Hove Singularity Steering Mechanism in Graphene Superlattices

We study quantum phase transitions in graphene superlattices in external magnetic fields, where a framework is presented to classify multiflavor Dirac fermion critical points describing hopping-tuned topological phase transitions of integer and fractional Hofstadter-Chern insulators. We argue and provide numerical support for the existence of transitions that can be explained by a nontrivial interplay of Chern bands and van Hove singularities near charge neutrality. This work provides a route to critical phenomena beyond conventional quantum Hall plateau transitions.

Spectrum-Wide Quantum Criticality at the Surface of Class AIII Topological Phases: An “Energy Stack” of Integer Quantum Hall Plateau Transitions

In the absence of spin-orbit coupling, the conventional dogma of Anderson localization asserts that all states localize in two dimensions, with a glaring exception: the quantum Hall plateau transition (QHPT). In that case, the localization length diverges and interference-induced quantum-critical spatial fluctuations appear at all length scales. Normally QHPT states occur only at isolated energies; accessing them therefore requires fine-tuning of the electron density or magnetic field. In this paper we show that QHPT states can be realized throughout an energy continuum, i.e. as an "energy stack" of critical states wherein each state in the stack exhibits QHPT phenomenology. The stacking occurs without fine-tuning at the surface of a class AIII topological phase, where it is protected by U(1) and (anomalous) chiral or time-reversal symmetries. Spectrum-wide criticality is diagnosed by comparing numerics to universal results for the longitudinal Landauer conductance and wave function multifractality at the QHPT. Results are obtained from an effective 2D surface field theory and from a bulk 3D lattice model. We demonstrate that the stacking of quantum-critical QHPT states is a robust phenomenon that occurs for AIII topological phases with both odd and even winding numbers. The latter conclusion may have important implications for the still poorly-understood logarithmic conformal field theory believed to describe the QHPT.

Dimensional Crossover of the Integer Quantum Hall Plateau Transition and Disordered Topological Pumping

We study the quantum Hall plateau transition on rectangular tori. As the aspect ratio of the torus is increased, the two-dimensional critical behavior, characterized by a subthermodynamic number of topological states in a vanishing energy window around a critical energy, changes drastically. In the thin-torus limit, the entire spectrum is Anderson localized; however, an extensive number of states retain a Chern number C≠0. We resolve this apparent paradox by mapping the thin-torus quantum Hall system onto a disordered Thouless pump, where the Chern number corresponds to the winding number of an electron's path in real space during a pump cycle. We then characterize quantitatively the crossover between the one- and two-dimensional regimes for finite torus thickness, where the average Thouless conductance also shows anomalous scaling.

In-plane magnetic-field-induced quantum anomalous Hall plateau transition

Axion insulator is a new state of quantum matter with a vanishing Chern number but a quantized topological axion response. We study the critical properties of the magnetic-field-induced quantum phase transition in axion insulators. Take the even septuple layer film ${\mathrm{MnBi}}_{2}{\mathrm{Te}}_{4}$ as a concrete example, We find the mirror symmetry breaking from in-plane magnetic field could induce an axion insulator to quantum anomalous Hall (QAH) insulator transition, which belongs to the generic integer quantum Hall plateau transition. The microscopic model proposed here explains the out-of-plane magnetic-field-induced QAH plateau transition observed in this system experimentally. The chiral Majorana fermion does not necessarily emerge at the QAH plateau transition in ${\mathrm{MnBi}}_{2}{\mathrm{Te}}_{4}$ due to strong exchange field, but may be quite feasible in its descendent materials ${\mathrm{MnBi}}_{4}{\mathrm{Te}}_{7}$ and ${\mathrm{MnBi}}_{6}{\mathrm{Te}}_{10}$.

The integer quantum Hall plateau transition is a current algebra after all

The scaling behavior near the transition between plateaus of the Integer Quantum Hall Effect (IQHE) has traditionally been interpreted on the basis of a two-parameter renormalization group (RG) flow conjectured from Pruisken's non-linear sigma model (NLσM). Yet, the conformal field theory (CFT) describing the critical point remained elusive, and only fragments of a quantitative analytical understanding existed up to now. In the present paper we carry out a detailed analysis of the current-current correlation function for the conductivity tensor, initially in the Chalker-Coddington network model for the IQHE plateau transition and then in its exact reformulation as a supersymmetric vertex model. We develop a heuristic argument for the continuum limit of the non-local conductivity response function at criticality and thus identify a non-Abelian current algebra at level n=4. Based on precise lattice expressions for the CFT primary fields we predict the multifractal scaling exponents of critical wavefunctions to be Δq=q(1−q)/4. The Lagrangian of the RG-fixed point theory for r retarded and r advanced replicas is proposed to be the GL(r|r)n=4 Wess-Zumino-Witten model deformed by a truly marginal perturbation. The latter emerges from the NLσM by a natural scenario of spontaneous symmetry breaking.

Extracting critical exponents by finite-size scaling with convolutional neural networks

Machine learning has been successfully applied to identify phases and phase transitions in condensed matter systems. However, quantitative characterization of the critical fluctuations near phase transitions is lacking. In this study we propose a finite-size scaling approach based on a convolutional neural network and analyze the critical behavior of a quantum Hall plateau transition. The localization length critical exponent learned by the neural network is consistent with the value obtained by conventional approaches. We show that the general-purposed method can be used to extract critical exponents in models with drastically different physics and input data, such as the two-dimensional Ising model and 4-state Potts model.

Localization-length exponent in two models of quantum Hall plateau transitions

Motivated by the recent numerical studies on the Chalker-Coddington network model that found a larger-than-expected critical exponent of the localization length characterizing the integer quantum Hall plateau transitions, we revisited the exponent calculation in the continuum model and in the lattice model, both projected to the lowest Landau level or subband. Combining scaling results with or without the corrections of an irrelevant length scale, we obtain $\nu = 2.48 \pm 0.02$, which is larger but still consistent with the earlier results in the two models, unlike what was found recently in the network model. The scaling of the total number of conducting states, as determined by the Chern number calculation, is accompanied by an effective irrelevant length scale exponent $y = 4.3$ in the lattice model, indicating that the irrelevant perturbations are insignificant in the topology number calculation.

Critical Percolation without Fine-Tuning on the Surface of a Topological Superconductor.

We present numerical evidence that most two-dimensional surface states of a bulk topological superconductor (TSC) sit at an integer quantum Hall plateau transition. We study TSC surface states in class CI with quenched disorder. Low-energy (finite-energy) surface states were expected to be critically delocalized (Anderson localized). We confirm the low-energy picture, but find instead that finite-energy states are also delocalized, with universal statistics that are independent of the TSC winding number, and consistent with the spin quantum Hall plateau transition (percolation).

Non-Abelian fermionization and fractional quantum Hall transitions

There has been a recent surge of interest in dualities relating theories of Chern-Simons gauge fields coupled to either bosons or fermions within the condensed matter community, particularly in the context of topological insulators and the half-filled Landau level. Here, we study the application of one such duality to the long-standing problem of quantum Hall inter-plateaux transitions. The key motivating experimental observations are the anomalously large value of the correlation length exponent $\nu \approx 2.3$ and that $\nu$ is observed to be super-universal, i.e., the same in the vicinity of distinct critical points. Duality motivates effective descriptions for a fractional quantum Hall plateau transition involving a Chern-Simons field with $U(N_c)$ gauge group coupled to $N_f = 1$ fermion. We study one class of theories in a controlled limit where $N_f \gg N_c$ and calculate $\nu$ to leading non-trivial order in the absence of disorder. Although these theories do not yield an anomalously large exponent $\nu$ within the large $N_f \gg N_c$ expansion, they do offer a new parameter space of theories that is apparently different from prior works involving abelian Chern-Simons gauge fields.

Geometrically disordered network models, quenched quantum gravity, and critical behavior at quantum Hall plateau transitions

Recent high-precision results for the critical exponent of the localization length at the integer quantum Hall (IQH) transition differ considerably between experimental ($\nu_\text{exp} \approx 2.38$) and numerical ($\nu_\text{CC} \approx 2.6$) values obtained in simulations of the Chalker-Coddington (CC) network model. We revisit the arguments leading to the CC model and consider a more general network with geometric (structural) disorder. Numerical simulations of this new model lead to the value $\nu \approx 2.37$ in very close agreement with experiments. We argue that in a continuum limit the geometrically disordered model maps to the free Dirac fermion coupled to various random potentials (similar to the CC model) but also to quenched two-dimensional quantum gravity. This explains the possible reason for the considerable difference between critical exponents for the CC model and the geometrically disordered model and may shed more light on the analytical theory of the IQH transition. We extend our results to network models in other symmetry classes.

Particle-vortex symmetric liquid

We introduce an effective theory with manifest particle-vortex symmetry for disordered thin films undergoing a magnetic field-tuned superconductor-insulator transition. The theory may enable one to access both the critical properties of the strong-disorder limit, which has recently been confirmed by Breznay et al. [PNAS 113, 280 (2016)] to exhibit particle-vortex symmetric electrical response, and the nearby metallic phase discovered earlier by Mason and Kapitulnik [Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 5341 (1999)] in less disordered samples. Within the effective theory, the Cooper-pair and field-induced vortex degrees of freedom are simultaneously incorporated into an electrically-neutral Dirac fermion minimally coupled to an (emergent) Chern-Simons gauge field. A derivation of the theory follows upon mapping the superconductor-insulator transition to the integer quantum Hall plateau transition and the subsequent use of Son's particle-hole symmetric composite Fermi liquid. Remarkably, particle-vortex symmetric response does not require the introduction of disorder; rather, it results when the Dirac fermions exhibit vanishing Hall effect. The theory predicts approximately equal (diagonal) thermopower and Nernst signal with a deviation parameterized by the measured electrical Hall response at the symmetric point.

Probe of local impurity states by bend resistance measurements in graphene cross junctions

We report on low-temperature transport measurements on four-terminal cross junction devices fabricated from high-quality graphene grown by chemical vapor deposition. At high magnetic fields, the bend resistance reveals pronounced peak structures at the quantum Hall plateau transition, which can be attributed to the edge state transport through the junctions. We further demonstrate that the bend resistance is drastically affected by the presence of local impurity states in the junction regions, and exhibits an unusual asymmetric behavior with respect to the magnetic field direction. The observations can be understood in a model taking into account the combination of the edge transport and an asymmetric scatterer. Our results demonstrate that a graphene cross junction may serve as a sensitive probe of local impurity states in graphene at the nanoscale.