AbstractSynthesis of intermetallic crystals by electrodeposition of Ag from alkaline aqueous electrolytes containing AgCN onto liquid metal electrodes via an electrochemical liquid‐liquid‐solid (ec‐LLS) process has been performed. X‐ray diffraction, scanning electron microscopy, and transmission electron microscopy were performed to identify crystalline products. Ec‐LLS experiments performed with pure liquid Hg and Ga electrodes resulted in the formation of polycrystalline Ag2Ga and Ag2Hg3. Experiments performed with In‐containing liquid metals preferentially yielded Ag9In4 and AgIn2 products with liquid Hg0.35In0.65 and Ga0.86In0.14, respectively. The product distribution with liquid Hg0.35In0.65 depended on the level of Ag supersaturation during the electrodeposition. A mechanism that accounts for the aforementioned observations is presented and discussed. This work described the formation of Ag−In intermetallic phases by the isothermal electroreduction of Ag into different liquid metal solvents via ec‐LLS. Electrodeposition of Ag into a pure Ga or pure Hg liquid metal pool yielded precisely the compounds predicted from isothermal cross‐sections of the respective binary phase diagrams. These compounds were not found when using liquid Hg or Ga containing appreciable In. The smaller enthalpy of formation for AgIn2 was consistent with its synthesis in Ga0.86In0.14. However, the observed product of Ag9In4 in Hg‐containing liquid metals could not be rationalized solely from thermodynamic factors. Instead, this observation was consistent with a kinetic pathway based on the lability of Hg‐metal bonds and nearly identical crystal structures of Ag9In4 and Ag2Hg3. Site exchange of Hg for In is consistent with our prior observations[23] of In exchange into Hg−Pd structures during Pd electrodeposition. This mechanism is not based on any direct role of electrochemistry other than aspects that dictate the operative supersaturation of the metal solute.