Pump Rhodopsin Research Articles

Heterologous expression and cell membrane localization of dinoflagellate opsins (rhodopsin proteins) in mammalian cells

Rhodopsins are now found in all domains of life, and are classified into two large groups: type II, found in animals and type I found in microbes including Bacteria, Archaea, and Eukarya. While type II rhodopsin functions in many photodependent signaling processes including vision, type I among others contains rhodopsins that function as a light-driven proton pump to convert light into ATP as in proteobacteria (named proteorhodopsin). Proteorhodopsin homologs have been documented in dinoflagellates, but their subcellular localizations and functions are still poorly understood. Even though sequence analyses suggest that it is a membrane protein, experimental evidence that dinoflagellate rhodopsins are localized on the plasma membrane or endomembranes is still lacking. As no robust dinoflagellate gene transformation tool was available, we used HEK 293T cells to construct a mammalian expression system for two dinoflagellate rhodopsin genes. The success of expressing these genes in the system shows that this mammalian cell type is suitable for expressing dinoflagellate genes. Immunofluorescence of the expressed protein locates these dinoflagellate rhodopsins on the cell membrane. This result indicates that the protein codons and membrane targeting signal of the dinoflagellate genes are compatible with the mammalian cells, and the proteins’ subcellular localization is consistent with proton pump rhodopsins.

Infrared spectroscopic analysis on structural changes around the protonated Schiff base upon retinal isomerization in light-driven sodium pump KR2

Krokinobacter rhodopsin 2 (KR2) was discovered as the first light-driven sodium pumping rhodopsin (NaR) in 2013, which contains unique amino acid residues on C-helix (N112, D116, and Q123), referred to as an NDQ motif. Based on the recent X-ray crystal structures of KR2, the sodium transport pathway has been investigated by various methods. However, due to complicated structural information around the protonated Schiff base (PRSB) region in the dark state and lack of structural information in the intermediates with sodium bound in KR2, detailed sodium pump mechanism is still unclear. Here we applied comprehensive low-temperature light-induced difference FTIR spectroscopy on isotopically labeled KR2 WT and site-directed mutant proteins (N112A, D116E, R109A, and R109K). We assigned the N-D stretching vibration of the PRSB at 2095 cm−1 and elucidate the hydrogen bonding interaction with D116 (a counter ion for the PRSB). We also assigned strongly hydrogen-bonded water (2333 cm−1) near R109 and D251, and found that presence of a positive charge at the position of R109 is prerequisite for the pumping function of KR2.

Quantitation of the neural silencing activity of anion channelrhodopsins in Caenorhabditis elegans and their applicability for long-term illumination

Ion pumps and channels are responsible for a wide variety of biological functions. Ion pumps transport only one ion during each stimulus-dependent reaction cycle, whereas ion channels conduct a large number of ions during each cycle. Ion pumping rhodopsins such as archaerhodopsin-3 (Arch) are often utilized as light-dependent neural silencers in animals, but they require a high-density light illumination of around 1 mW/mm2. Recently, anion channelrhodopsins -1 and -2 (GtACR1 and GtACR2) were discovered as light-gated anion channels from the cryptophyte algae Guillardia theta. GtACRs are therefore expected to silence neural activity much more efficiently than Arch. In this study, we successfully expressed GtACRs in neurons of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans (C. elegans) and quantitatively evaluated how potently GtACRs can silence neurons in freely moving C. elegans. The results showed that the light intensity required for GtACRs to cause locomotion paralysis was around 1 µW/mm2, which is three orders of magnitude smaller than the light intensity required for Arch. As attractive features, GtACRs are less harmfulness to worms and allow stable neural silencing effects under long-term illumination. Our findings thus demonstrate that GtACRs possess a hypersensitive neural silencing activity in C. elegans and are promising tools for long-term neural silencing.

Molecular mechanism for thermal denaturation of thermophilic rhodopsin.

Understanding the factors affecting the stability and function of proteins at the molecular level is of fundamental importance. In spite of their use in bioelectronics and optogenetics, factors influencing thermal stability of microbial rhodopsins, a class of photoreceptor protein ubiquitous in nature are not yet well-understood. Here we report on the molecular mechanism for thermal denaturation of microbial retinal proteins, including, a highly thermostable protein, thermophilic rhodopsin (TR). External stimuli-dependent thermal denaturation of TR, the proton pumping rhodopsin of Thermus thermophilus bacterium, and other microbial rhodopsins are spectroscopically studied to decipher the common factors guiding their thermal stability. The thermal denaturation process of the studied proteins is light-catalyzed and the apo-protein is thermally less stable than the corresponding retinal-covalently bound opsin. In addition, changes in structure of the retinal chromophore affect the thermal stability of TR. Our results indicate that the hydrolysis of the retinal protonated Schiff base (PSB) is the rate-determining step for denaturation of the TR as well as other retinal proteins. Unusually high thermal stability of TR multilayers, in which PSB hydrolysis is restricted due to lack of bulk water, strongly supports this proposal. Our results also show that the protonation state of the PSB counter-ion does not affect the thermal stability of the studied proteins. Thermal photo-bleaching of an artificial TR pigment derived from non-isomerizable trans-locked retinal suggests, rather counterintuitively, that the photoinduced retinal trans-cis isomerization is not a pre-requisite for light catalyzed thermal denaturation of TR. Protein conformation alteration triggered by light-induced retinal excited state formation is likely to facilitate the PSB hydrolysis.

Protein conformational alterations induced by the retinal excited state in proton and sodium pumping rhodopsins.

Retinal proteins' biological activity is triggered by the retinal chromophore's light absorption, which initiates a photocycle. However, the mechanism by which retinal light excitation induces the protein's response is not completely understood. Recently, two new retinal proteins were discovered, namely, King Sejong 1-2 (KS1-2) and Nonlabens (Donghaeana) dokdonensis (DDR2), which exhibit H+ and Na+ pumping activities, respectively. To pinpoint whether protein conformation alterations can be achieved without light-induced retinal C13[double bond, length as m-dash]C14 double-bond isomerization, we utilized the hydroxylamine reaction, which cleaves the protonated Schiff base bond through which the retinal chromophore is covalently bound to the protein. The reaction is accelerated by light even though the cleavage is not a photochemical reaction. Therefore, the cleavage reaction may serve as a tool to detect protein conformation alterations. We discovered that in both KS1-2 and DDR2, the hydroxylamine reaction is light accelerated, even in artificial pigments derived from synthetic retinal in which the crucial C13[double bond, length as m-dash]C14 double-bond isomerization is prevented. Therefore, we propose that in both proteins the light-induced retinal charge redistribution taking place in the retinal excited state polarizes the protein, which, in turn, triggers protein conformation alterations. A further general possible application of the present finding is associated with other photoreceptor proteins having retinal or other non-retinal chromophores whose light excitation may affect the protein conformation.

Hydrogen-bonding network at the cytoplasmic region of a light-driven sodium pump rhodopsin KR2

Light-driven sodium-pumping rhodopsins are able to actively transport sodium ions. Structure/function studies of Krokinobacter eikastus rhodopsin 2 (KR2) identified N61 and G263 at the cytoplasmic surface constituting the “Ion-selectivity filter” for sodium ions, while retinal Schiff base acts as the light “Switch and Gate” for transport of sodium ions. Q123 is located between the two regions, and plays an important role for the pump function, which was implicated by functional, spectroscopic, X-ray crystallographic and computational studies. According to the atomic structure of KR2, Q123 is involved in the hydrogen-bonding network at the cytoplasmic region, together with S64, protein-bound waters, and peptide carbonyl of K255 bound to the chromophore. To gain the detailed structural information around Q123, here we compared light-induced difference Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectra at 77 K between the wild-type (WT) and mutant proteins of KR2, such as Q123A, Q123V, and S64A. The obtained spectra were very similar between WT and these mutants, whereas the observed mutation effects enabled us to identify vibrations of the hydrogen-bonding network at the Q123 and S64 region. This is unique for KR2, not for the corresponding mutations in a light-driven proton-pump bacteriorhodopsin (BR). Hydrogen-bonding alteration is absent for the mutants of KR2, suggesting that proper inter-helical connectivity of helices B, C, and G is important for protein structural changes for sodium-pump function, which is controlled by the region around Q123.

Origin of the Reactive and Nonreactive Excited States in the Primary Reaction of Rhodopsins: pH Dependence of Femtosecond Absorption of Light-Driven Sodium Ion Pump Rhodopsin KR2.

KR2 is the first light-driven Na+-pumping rhodopsin discovered. It was reported that the photoexcitation of KR2 generates multiple S1 states, i.e., "reactive" and "nonreactive" S1 states at physiological pH, but their origin remained unclear. In this study, we examined the S1 state dynamics of KR2 using femtosecond time-resolved absorption spectroscopy at different pH's in the range from 4 to 11. It was found that the reactive S1 state is predominantly formed at pH >9, but its population drastically decreases with decreasing pH while the population of the nonreactive S1 state(s) increases. The pH dependence of the relative population of the reactive S1 state correlates very well with the pH titration curve of Asp116, which is the counterion of the protonated retinal Schiff base (PRSB) in KR2. This strongly indicates that the deprotonation/protonation of Asp116 is directly related to the generation of the multiple S1 states in KR2. The quantitative analysis of the time-resolved absorption data led us to conclude that the reactive and nonreactive S1 states of KR2 originate from KR2 proteins having a hydrogen bond between Asp116 and PRSB or not, respectively. In other words, it is the ground-state inhomogeneity that is the origin of the coexistence of the reactive and nonreactive S1 states in KR2. So far, the generation of multiple S1 states having a different photoreactivity of rhodopsins has been mainly explained with the branching of the relaxation pathway in the Franck-Condon region in the S1 state. The present study shows that the structural inhomogeneity in the ground state, in particular that of the hydrogen-bond network, is the more plausible origin of the reactive and nonreactive S1 states which have been widely observed for various rhodopsins.

Living off the Sun: chlorophylls, bacteriochlorophylls and rhodopsins

Pigments absorbing 350–1,050 nm radiation have had an important role on the Earth for at least 3.5 billion years. The ion pumping rhodopsins absorb blue and green photons using retinal and pump ions across cell membranes. Bacteriochlorophylls (BChl), absorbing in the violet/blue and near infra red (NIR), power anoxygenic photosynthesis, with one photoreaction centre; and chlorophylls (Chl), absorbing in the violet/blue and red (occasionally NIR) power oxygenic photosynthesis, with two photoreaction centres. The accessory (bacterio)chlorophylls add to the spectral range (bandwidth) of photon absorption, e.g., in algae living at depth in clear oceanic water and in algae and photosynthetic (PS) bacteria in microbial mats. Organism size, via the package effect, determines the photon absorption benefit of the costs of synthesis of the pigment–protein complexes. There are unresolved issues as to the evolution of Chls vs. BChls and the role of violet/blue and NIR radiation in PS bacteria.

Low-temperature FTIR spectroscopy provides evidence for protein-bound water molecules in eubacterial light-driven ion pumps.

Light-driven H+, Na+ and Cl- pumps have been found in eubacteria, which convert light energy into a transmembrane electrochemical potential. A recent mutation study revealed asymmetric functional conversion between the two pumps, where successful functional conversions are achieved exclusively when mutagenesis reverses the evolutionary amino acid sequence changes. Although this fact suggests that the essential structural mechanism of an ancestral function is retained even after gaining a new function, questions regarding the essential structural mechanism remain unanswered. Light-induced difference FTIR spectroscopy was used to monitor the presence of strongly hydrogen-bonded water molecules for all eubacterial H+, Na+ and Cl- pumps, including a functionally converted mutant. This fact suggests that the strongly hydrogen-bonded water molecules are maintained for these new functions during evolution, which could be the reason for successful functional conversion from Na+ to H+, and from Cl- to H+ pumps. This also explains the successful conversion of the Cl- to the H+ pump only for eubacteria, but not for archaea. It is concluded that water-containing hydrogen-bonding networks constitute one of the essential structural mechanisms in eubacterial light-driven ion pumps.

Time-resolved FTIR study of light-driven sodium pump rhodopsins.

Light-driven sodium ion pump rhodopsin (NaR) is a new functional class of microbial rhodopsin. A previous flash photolysis study of Krokinobacter eikastus rhodopsin 2 (KR2) revealed the presence of three kinetically distinct intermediates: K, L/M, and O. Previous low-temperature Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy of KR2 showed that photoisomerization from the all-trans to the 13-cis form is the primary event of the Na+ pumping photocycle, but structural information on the subsequent intermediates is limited. Here, we applied step-scan time-resolved FTIR spectroscopy to KR2 and Nonlabens dokdonensis rhodopsin 2 (NdR2). Both low-temperature static and time-resolved FTIR spectra resolved a K-like intermediate, and the corresponding spectra showed few differences. Strong hydrogen-out-of-plane (HOOP) vibrations, which appeared in the K intermediate, are common among other rhodopsins. It is, however, unique for NaR that such HOOP bands are persistent in late intermediates, such as L and O intermediates. This observation strongly suggests similar chromophore structures for the K, L, and O intermediates. In fact, an isotope-labeled study that used 12,14-D2 retinal revealed that the chromophore configuration of the O intermediate in NaR is 13-cis. In contrast to the vibrations of the chromophore, those of the protein differ among intermediates, and this is related to the sodium-pumping function. The molecular mechanism of the light-driven sodium pump is discussed on the basis of the present time-resolved FTIR results.

Engineering a carotenoid-binding site in Dokdonia sp. PRO95 Na+-translocating rhodopsin by a single amino acid substitution.

Light-driven H+, Cl- and Na+ rhodopsin pumps all use a covalently bound retinal molecule to capture light energy. Some H+-pumping rhodopsins (xanthorhodopsins; XRs) additionally contain a carotenoid antenna for light absorption. Comparison of the available primary and tertiary structures of rhodopsins pinpointed a single Thr residue (Thr216) that presumably prevents carotenoid binding to Na+-pumping rhodopsins (NaRs). We replaced this residue in Dokdonia sp. PRO95 NaR with Gly, which is found in the corresponding position in XRs, and produced a variant rhodopsin in a ketocarotenoid-synthesising Escherichia coli strain. Unlike wild-type NaR, the isolated variant protein contained the tightly bound carotenoids canthaxanthin and echinenone. These carotenoids were visible in the absorption, circular dichroism and fluorescence excitation spectra of the Thr216Gly-substituted NaR, which indicates their function as a light-harvesting antenna. The amino acid substitution and the bound carotenoids did not affect the NaR photocycle. Our findings suggest that the antenna function was recently lost during NaR evolution but can be easily restored by site-directed mutagenesis.

Evidence of microbial rhodopsins in Antarctic Dry Valley edaphic systems.

Microorganisms able to synthesize rhodopsins have the capacity to translocate ions through their membranes, using solar energy to generate a proton motive force. Rhodopsins are the most abundant phototrophic proteins in oceanic surface waters and are key constituents in marine bacterial ecology. However, it remains unclear how rhodopsins are used in most microorganisms. Despite their abundance in marine and fresh-water systems, the presence of functional rhodopsin systems in edaphic habitats has never been reported. Here, we show the presence of several new putative H+ , Na+ and Cl+ pumping rhodopsins identified by metagenomic analysis of Antarctic desert hypolithic communities. Reconstruction of two Proteobacteria genomes harboring xanthorhodopsin-like proteins and one Bacteroidetes genome with a Na-pumping-like rhodopsin indicated that these bacteria were aerobic heterotrophs possessing the apparent capacity for the functional expression of rhodopsins. The existence of these protein systems in hypolithic bacteria expands the known role of rhodopsins to include terrestrial environments and suggests a possible predominant function as heterotrophic energy supply proteins, a feasible microbial adaptation to the harsh conditions prevalent in Antarctic edaphic systems.

Protonation-state-Coupled Conformational Dynamics in Reaction Mechanisms of Channel and Pump Rhodopsins.

Channel and pump rhodopsins use energy from light absorbed by a covalently bound retinal chromophore to transport ions across membranes of microbial cells. Ion transfer steps, including proton transfer, can couple to changes in protein conformational dynamics and water positions. Although general principles of how microbial rhodopsins function are largely understood, key issues pertaining to reaction mechanisms remain unclear. In this review, we compare the protonation-coupled dynamics of pump and channelrhodopsins, highlighting the roles that water dynamics, protein electrostatics and protein flexibility can have in ion transport mechanisms. We discuss observations supporting important functional roles of inter- and intra-helical carboxylate/hydroxyl hydrogen-bonding motifs. As specific examples, we use the proton pump bacteriorhodopsin, the sodium pump KR2, channelrhodopsins and Anabaena sensory rhodopsin. We outline the usefulness of theoretic biophysics approaches to the study of retinal proteins, challenges in studying the hydrogen-bond dynamics of rhodopsin active sites, and implications for conformational coupling in membrane transporters.

A phylogenetically distinctive and extremely heat stable light-driven proton pump from the eubacterium Rubrobacter xylanophilus DSM 9941T

Rhodopsins are proteins that contain seven transmembrane domains with a chromophore retinal and that function as photoreceptors for light-energy conversion and light-signal transduction in a wide variety of organisms. Here we characterized a phylogenetically distinctive new rhodopsin from the thermophilic eubacterium Rubrobacter xylanophilus DSM 9941T that was isolated from thermally polluted water. Although R. xylanophilus rhodopsin (RxR) is from Actinobacteria, it is located between eukaryotic and archaeal rhodopsins in the phylogenetic tree. Escherichia coli cells expressing RxR showed a light-induced decrease in environmental pH and inhibition by a protonophore, indicating that it works as a light-driven outward proton pump. We characterized purified RxR spectroscopically, and showed that it has an absorption maximum at 541 nm and binds nearly 100% all-trans retinal. The pKa values for the protonated retinal Schiff base and its counterion were estimated to be 10.7 and 1.3, respectively. Time-resolved flash-photolysis experiments revealed the formation of a red-shifted intermediate. Of note, RxR showed an extremely high thermal stability in comparison with other proton pumping rhodopsins such as thermophilic rhodopsin TR (by 16-times) and bacteriorhodopsin from Halobacterium salinarum (HsBR, by 4-times).

Solid-State Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Structural Study of the Retinal-Binding Pocket in Sodium Ion Pump Rhodopsin.

The recently identified Krokinobacter rhodopsin 2 (KR2) functions as a light-driven sodium ion pump. The structure of the retinal-binding pocket of KR2 offers important insights into the mechanisms of KR2, which has motif of Asn112, Asp116, and Gln123 (NDQ) that is common among sodium ion pump rhodopsins but is unique among other microbial rhodopsins. Here we present solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) characterization of retinal and functionally important residues in the vicinity of retinal in the ground state. We assigned chemical shifts of retinal C14 and C20 atoms, and Tyr218Cζ, Lys255Cε, and the protonated Schiff base of KR2 in lipid environments at acidic and neutral pH. 15N NMR signals of the protonated Schiff base showed a twist around the N-Cε bond under neutral conditions, compared with other microbial rhodopsins. These data indicated that the location of the counterion Asp116 is one helical pitch toward the cytoplasmic side. In acidic environments, the 15N Schiff base signal was shifted to a lower field, indicating that protonation of Asp116 induces reorientation during interactions between the Schiff base and Asp116. In addition, the Tyr218 residue in the vicinity of retinal formed a weak hydrogen bond with Asp251, a temporary Na+-binding site during the photocycle. These features may indicate unique mechanisms of sodium ion pumps.

A Chimera Na+-Pump Rhodopsin as an Effective Optogenetic Silencer.

With the progress of optogenetics, the activities of genetically identified neurons can be optically silenced to determine whether the neurons in question are necessary for the network performance of the behavioral expression. This logical induction is expected to be improved by the application of the Na+ pump rhodopsins (NaRs), which hyperpolarize the membrane potential with negligible influence on the ionic/pH balance. Here, we made several chimeric NaRs between two NaRs, KR2 and IaNaR from Krokinobacter eikastus and Indibacter alkaliphilus, respectively. We found that one of these chimeras, named I1K6NaR, exhibited some improvements in the membrane targeting and photocurrent properties over native NaRs. The I1K6NaR-expressing cortical neurons were stably silenced by green light irradiation for a certain long duration. With its rapid kinetics and voltage dependency, the photoactivation of I1K6NaR would specifically counteract the generation of action potentials with less hyperpolarization of the neuronal membrane potential than KR2.

Temperature Independence of Ultrafast Photoisomerization in Thermophilic Rhodopsin: Assessment versus Other Microbial Proton Pumps.

Primary photochemical events in the unusually thermostable proton pumping rhodopsin of Thermus thermophilus bacterium (TR) are reported for the first time. Internal conversion in this protein is shown to be significantly faster than in bacteriorhodopsin (BR), making it the most rapidly isomerizing microbial proton pump known. Internal conversion (IC) dynamics of TR and BR were recorded from room temperature to the verge of thermal denaturation at 70 °C and found to be totally independent of temperature in this range. This included the well documented multiexponential nature of IC in BR, suggesting that assignment of this to ground state structural inhomogeneity needs revision. TR photodynamics were also compared with that of the phylogenetically more similar proton pump Gloeobacter rhodopsin (GR). Despite this similarity GR has poor thermal stability, and the excited state decays significantly more slowly and exhibits very prominent stretched exponential behavior. Coherent torsional wave-packets induced by impulsive photoexcitation of TR and GR show marked resemblance to each other in frequency and amplitude and differ strikingly from similar signatures in pump-probe data of BR and other microbial retinal proteins. Possible correlations between IC rates and thermal stability and the promise of using torsional coherence signatures for understanding chromophore protein binding in microbial retinal proteins are discussed.

The Study and Application of Photoreceptive Membrane Protein, Rhodopsin

Abstract Microbial rhodopsins are photoreceptive seven-transmembrane proteins diversely found in unicellular microorganisms. The chromophore of microbial rhodopsin is all-trans retinal. The retinal isomerizes to 13-cis form upon light-absorption and it triggers the expression of various biological functions by light. We studied the mechanism of various types of microbial rhodopsins (H+ pump, Cl− pump and sensors) by physicochemical spectroscopic methods. On the basis of these studies, we found the importance of the residues on the third helix (helix C) for the function of microbial rhodopsin, and it led to the discovery of a new functional class of microbial rhodopsin, light-driven outward Na+ pump. The mechanism of Na+ pump rhodopsin was studied by several spectroscopic methods and X-ray crystallography. These studies provided new insights very informative for the development of novel functional artificial rhodopsins (K+ and Cs+ pumps). These new natural and artificial rhodopsins are expected to have high potential for applications such as optogenetics.

Structural Mechanism for Light-driven Transport by a New Type of Chloride Ion Pump, Nonlabens marinus Rhodopsin-3

The light-driven inward chloride ion-pumping rhodopsin Nonlabens marinus rhodopsin-3 (NM-R3), from a marine flavobacterium, belongs to a phylogenetic lineage distinct from the halorhodopsins known as archaeal inward chloride ion-pumping rhodopsins. NM-R3 and halorhodopsin have distinct motif sequences that are important for chloride ion binding and transport. In this study, we present the crystal structure of a new type of light-driven chloride ion pump, NM-R3, at 1.58 Å resolution. The structure revealed the chloride ion translocation pathway and showed that a single chloride ion resides near the Schiff base. The overall structure, chloride ion-binding site, and translocation pathway of NM-R3 are different from those of halorhodopsin. Unexpectedly, this NM-R3 structure is similar to the crystal structure of the light-driven outward sodium ion pump, Krokinobacter eikastus rhodopsin 2. Structural and mutational analyses of NM-R3 revealed that most of the important amino acid residues for chloride ion pumping exist in the ion influx region, located on the extracellular side of NM-R3. In contrast, on the opposite side, the cytoplasmic regions of K. eikastus rhodopsin 2 were reportedly important for sodium ion pumping. These results provide new insight into ion selection mechanisms in ion pumping rhodopsins, in which the ion influx regions of both the inward and outward pumps are important for their ion selectivities.

Integrated In Silico Analysis of Pathway Designs for Synthetic Photo-Electro-Autotrophy.

The strong advances in synthetic biology enable the engineering of novel functions and complex biological features in unprecedented ways, such as implementing synthetic autotrophic metabolism into heterotrophic hosts. A key challenge for the sustainable production of fuels and chemicals entails the engineering of synthetic autotrophic organisms that can effectively and efficiently fix carbon dioxide by using sustainable energy sources. This challenge involves the integration of carbon fixation and energy uptake systems. A variety of carbon fixation pathways and several types of photosystems and other energy uptake systems can be chosen and, potentially, modularly combined to design synthetic autotrophic metabolism. Prior to implementation, these designs can be evaluated by the combination of several computational pathway analysis techniques. Here we present a systematic, integrated in silico analysis of photo-electro-autotrophic pathway designs, consisting of natural and synthetic carbon fixation pathways, a proton-pumping rhodopsin photosystem for ATP regeneration and an electron uptake pathway. We integrated Flux Balance Analysis of the heterotrophic chassis Escherichia coli with kinetic pathway analysis and thermodynamic pathway analysis (Max-min Driving Force). The photo-electro-autotrophic designs are predicted to have a limited potential for anaerobic, autotrophic growth of E. coli, given the relatively low ATP regenerating capacity of the proton pumping rhodopsin photosystems and the high ATP maintenance of E. coli. If these factors can be tackled, our analysis indicates the highest growth potential for the natural reductive tricarboxylic acid cycle and the synthetic pyruvate synthase–pyruvate carboxylate -glyoxylate bicycle. Both carbon fixation cycles are very ATP efficient, while maintaining fast kinetics, which also results in relatively low estimated protein costs for these pathways. Furthermore, the synthetic bicycles are highly thermodynamic favorable under conditions analysed. However, the most important challenge identified for improving photo-electro-autotrophic growth is increasing the proton-pumping rate of the rhodopsin photosystems, allowing for higher ATP regeneration. Alternatively, other designs of autotrophy may be considered, therefore the herein presented integrated modeling approach allows synthetic biologists to evaluate and compare complex pathway designs before experimental implementation.