Pseudoscalar Glueball Research Articles

Pseudoscalar glueball mass: a window on three-gluon interactions

In pure-glue QCD, gluon-gluon scattering in the $J^{PC}=0^{-+}$ channel is described by a very simple equation, especially if one considers just the leading contribution to the scattering kernel. Of all components in this kernel, only the three-gluon vertex, $V_{\mu\nu\rho}$, is poorly constrained by contemporary analyses; hence, calculations of $0^{-+}$ glueball properties serve as a clear window onto the character and form of $V_{\mu\nu\rho}$. This is important given that many modern calculations of $V_{\mu\nu\rho}$ predict the appearance of an infrared suppression in the scalar function which comes to modulate the bare vertex after the nonperturbative resummation of interactions. Such behaviour is a peculiar prediction; but we find that such suppression is essential if one is to achieve agreement with lattice-QCD predictions for the $0^{-+}$ glueball mass. It is likely, therefore, that this novel feature of $V_{\mu\nu\rho}$ is real and has observable implications for the spectrum, decays and interactions of all QCD bound-states.

Decay of the pseudoscalar glueball and its first excited state into scalar and pseudoscalar mesons and their first excited states

We expand the study of the pseudoscalar glueball and its first excited state by constructing an interaction Lagrangian which produces the two- and three-body decays of the pseudoscalar glueball, $J^{PC}=0^{-+}$, into the (pseudo)scalar and the excited (pseudo)scalar mesons as well as by constructing other two different chiral Lagrangians which describe the two- and three-body decays of the first excited pseudoscalar glueball, $J^{PC}=0^{*-+}$, into the (pseudo)scalar and the excited (pseudo)scalar mesons. We compute the decay channels for the ground state of a pseudoscalar glueball with a mass of $2.6$ GeV and for the first excited pseudoscalar glueball with a mass $3.7$ GeV, following predictions from Lattice QCD in the quenched approximation. These states and channels are within reach of PANDA experiment at the upcoming FAIR facility experiment and ongoing BESIII experiment. In our approach, the various branching ratios are a parameter-free prediction.

Study of the pseudoscalar glueball in J/ψ radiative decays

We aim to explore the production rate of the pseudoscalar glueball in $J/\psi$ radiative decay by lattice QCD in quenched approximation. The calculation is performed on three anisotropic lattices with the spatial lattice spacing ranging from 0.222(2) fm to 0.110(1) fm. As a calibration of some systematical uncertainties, we first extract the $M1$ form factor $\hat{V}(0)$ of the process $J/\psi\to\gamma\eta_{c}$ and get the result $\hat{V}(0)=1.933(41)$ in the continuum limit, which gives the partial width $\Gamma(J/\psi\to\gamma\eta_{c})=2.47(11)$ keV. These results are in agreement with that of previous lattice studies. As for the pseudoscalar glueball $G_{0^{-+}}$, its mass is derived to be $2.395(14)$ GeV, and the form factor $\hat{V}(0)$ of the process $J/\psi\to\gamma G_{0^{-+}}$ is determined to be $\hat{V}(0)=0.0246(43)$ after continuum extrapolation. Finally, the production rate of the pseudoscalar glueball is predicted to be $2.31(90)\times10^{-4}$, which is much smaller than that of conventional light $q\bar{q}$ $\eta$ states. After the subtraction of the phase space factor, the couplings of $J/\psi X\gamma$ are similar where $X$ stands for $\eta$ states and the pseudoscalar glueball. Possibly, the $U_{A}(1)$ anomaly plays an important role for the large couplings of gluons to the flavor singlet $\eta$ states in $J/\psi$ radiative decays.

Form factors for semileptonic Bc decays into η , η′ and glueballs

We calculated the form factors of ${B}_{c}$ transitions into $\ensuremath{\eta}$, ${\ensuremath{\eta}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ meson and pseudoscalar glueballs, where the ${B}_{c}$ meson is a bound state of two different heavy flavors and is treated as a nonrelativistic state, while the mesons $\ensuremath{\eta}$, ${\ensuremath{\eta}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ and glueballs are treated as light-cone objects since their masses are small enough compared to the transition momentum scale. The mechanism of two gluon scattering into $\ensuremath{\eta}\ensuremath{'}$ dominated the form factors of ${B}_{c}$ decays into $\ensuremath{\eta}\ensuremath{'}$. We considered the $\ensuremath{\eta}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{\ensuremath{\eta}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$-glueball mixing effects, and then obtained their influences on the form factors. The form factors of ${B}_{c}$ transition into $\ensuremath{\eta}$, ${\ensuremath{\eta}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, and the pseudoscalar glueball in the maximum momentum recoil point were obtained as follows: ${f}_{0,+}^{\ensuremath{\eta}}({q}^{2}=0)=1.3{8}_{\ensuremath{-}0.02}^{+0.00}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$, ${f}_{0,+}^{{\ensuremath{\eta}}^{\ensuremath{'}}}({q}^{2}=0)=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}0.8{9}_{\ensuremath{-}0.10}^{+0.11}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}2}$, and ${f}_{0,+}^{G}({q}^{2}=0)=0.4{4}_{\ensuremath{-}0.05}^{+0.13}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}2}$. Also phenomenological discussions for semileptonic ${B}_{c}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{\ensuremath{\eta}}^{{(}^{\ensuremath{'}})}+\ensuremath{\ell}+{\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}$, ${B}_{c}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}G({0}^{\ensuremath{-}+})+\ensuremath{\ell}+{\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}$, and ${D}_{s}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\eta}+\ensuremath{\ell}+{\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{\ensuremath{\ell}}$ decays are given.

Generalized linear sigma model with two glueballs

We present a generalized linear sigma model that includes both scalar and pseudoscalar glueballs in addition to a quark-antiquark as well as a four-quark chiral nonet. Utilizing the axial and trace anomalies of QCD (at the effective mesonic level), we aim to develope the most general structure of the Lagrangian which can be used to study the interaction of quarkonia with glueballs. We then study the effect of scalar glueball on the vacuum of the model by considering a decoupling limit in which the glueball fields are decoupled from quarkonia. This determines the properties of the pure scalar glueball and builds a practical foundation for determining the model parameters when the interactions are turned on.

Hadronic decays of the (pseudo-)scalar charmonium states $\eta_{c}$ η c and $\chi_{c0}$ χ c 0 in the extended Linear Sigma Model

We study the phenomenology of the ground-state (pseudo-)scalar charmonia $\eta_c$ and $\chi_{c0}$ in the framework of a $U(4)_r \times U(4)_l$ symmetric linear sigma model with (pseudo-)scalar and (axial-) vector mesons. Based on previous results for the spectrum of charmonia and the spectrum and (OZI-dominant) strong decays of open charmed mesons, we extend the study of this model to OZI-suppressed charmonia decays. This includes decays into 'ordinary' mesons but also particularly interesting channels with scalar-isoscalar resonances $f_0(1370),\, f_0(1500),\, f_0(1710)$ that may include sizeable contributions from a scalar glueball. We study the variation of the corresponding decay widths assuming different mixings between glueball and quark-antiquark states. We also compute the decay width of the pseudoscalar $\eta_c$ into a pseudoscalar glueball. In general, our results for decay widths are in reasonable agreement with experimental data where available. Order of magnitude predictions for as yet unmeasured states and channels are potentially interesting for BESIII, Belle II, LHCb as well as the future PANDA experiment at the FAIR facility.

Localization of topological charge density near Tc in quenched QCD with Wilson flow

We smear quenched lattice QCD ensembles with lattice volume $32^3\times 8$ by using Wilson flow. Six ensembles at temperature near the critical temperature $T_c$ corresponding to the critical inverse coupling $\beta_c=6.06173(49)$ are used to investigate the localization of topological charge density. If the effective smearing radius of Wilson flow is large enough, the density, size and peak of Harrington-Shepard (HS) caloron-like topological lumps of ensembles are stable when $\beta\leq 6.050$, but start to change significantly when $\beta\geq6.055$. The inverse participation ratio (IPR) of topological charge density shows similar results, it begins to increase when $\beta\geq 6.055$ and is stable when $\beta\leq 6.050$. The pseudoscalar glueball mass is extracted from the topological charge density correlator (TCDC) of ensembles at $T=1.19T_c,~\textrm{and }1.36T_c$, the masses are $1.915(98)\textrm{ GeV}$ and $1.829(123)\textrm{ GeV}$ respectively, they are consistent with results from conventional methods.

Revisiting the pseudoscalar meson and glueball mixing and key issues in the search for a pseudoscalar glueball state

We revisit the mixing mechanism for pesudscalar mesons and glueball which is introduced by the axial vector anomaly. We demonstrate that the physical mass of the pseudoscalar glueball does not favor to be lower than 1.8 GeV if all the parameters are reasonably constrained. This conclusion, on the one hand, can accommodate the pseudoscalar glueball mass calculated by Lattice QCD, and on the other hand, is consistent with the high-statistics analyses at BESIII that all the available measurements do not support the presence of two closely overlapping pseudoscalar states in any exclusive channel. Such a result is in agreement with the recent claim that the slightly shifted peak positions for two possible states $\eta(1405)$ and $\eta(1475)$ observed in different channels are actually originated from one single state with the triangle singularity interferences. By resolving this long-standing paradox, one should pay more attention to higher mass region for the purpose of searching for the pseudoscalar glueball candidate.

Influence of the axial anomaly on the decay N(1535)→Nη

The decay width of $N(1535)\rightarrow N\eta$ is as large as that of $N(1535)\rightarrow N\pi$. This is in evident conflict with simple expectations based on flavor symmetry and phase space. Similarly, the decay width of $\Lambda(1670) \rightarrow \Lambda(1116) \eta $ is larger than predicted by flavor symmetry. In this work, we propose that the axial $U(1)_{A}$ anomaly is responsible for an enhanced coupling of (some) excited baryons to the $\eta$ meson. We test this idea by including a new, chirally symmetric but $U(1)_{A}$ anomalous, term in an effective hadronic model decribing baryons and their chiral partners in the mirror assignment. This term enhances the decay of the chiral partners into baryons and an $\eta$ meson, such as $N(1535)\rightarrow N\eta$. Moreover, a strong coupling of $N(1535)$ to $N \eta^\prime $ emerges (this is important for studies of $\eta^\prime$ production processes). Our approach shows that $N(1535)$ is predominantly the chiral partner of $N(939)$, and $\Lambda(1670)$ the chiral partner of $\Lambda(1116)$. Finally, our formalism can be used to couple the pseudoscalar glueball $\tilde{G}$ to baryons. We expect a large cross section for the reaction $\bar{p}p \rightarrow \tilde{G} \rightarrow \bar{p}p(1535)$, which can be experimentally tested in the future PANDA experiment.

Thermal spectrum of pseudo-scalar glueballs and Debye screening mass from holography

The finite temperature spectrum of pseudo-scalar glueballs in a plasma is studied using a holographic model. The 0^{-+} glueball is represented by a pseudo-scalar (axion) field living in a five dimensional geometry that comes from a solution of Einstein equations for gravity coupled with a dilaton scalar field. The spectral function obtained from the model shows a clear peak corresponding to the quasi-particle ground state. Analyzing the variation of the position of the peak with temperature, we describe the thermal behavior of the Debye screening mass of the plasma. As a check of consistency, the zero temperature limit of the model is also investigated. The glueball masses obtained are consistent with previous lattice results.

Investigating the topological structure of quenched lattice QCD with overlap fermions using a multi-probing approximation

The topological charge density and topological susceptibility are determined by a multi-probing approximation using overlap fermions in quenched SU(3) gauge theory. Then we investigate the topological structure of the quenched QCD vacuum, and compare it with results from the all-scale topological density. The results are consistent. Random permuted topological charge density is used to check whether these structures represent underlying ordered properties. The pseudoscalar glueball mass is extracted from the two-point correlation function of the topological charge density. We study 3 ensembles of different lattice spacing a with the same lattice volume 163×32. The results are compatible with the results of all-scale topological charge density, and the topological structures revealed by multi-probing are much closer to all-scale topological charge density than those from eigenmode expansion.

Holographic QCD predictions for production and decay of pseudoscalar glueballs

The top–down holographic Witten–Sakai–Sugimoto model for low-energy QCD, augmented by finite quark masses, has recently been found to be able to reproduce the decay pattern of the scalar glueball candidate f0(1710) on a quantitative level. In this Letter we show that this model predicts a narrow pseudoscalar glueball heavier than the scalar glueball and with a very restricted decay pattern involving η or η′ mesons. Production should be either in pairs or in association with η(′) mesons. We discuss the prospect of discovery in high-energy hadron collider experiments through central exclusive production by comparing with η′ pair production.

Decay modes of the excited pseudoscalar glueball

We study three different chiral Lagrangians that describe the two- and three-body decays of an excited pseudoscalar glueball, $J^{PC}=0^{*-+}$, into light mesons and charmonium states as well as into a scalar and pseudoscalar glueball. We compute the decay channels for an excited pseudoscalar glueball with a mass of $3.7$ GeV and consider a ground state pseudoscalar glueball of mass $2.6$ GeV, following predictions from lattice QCD simulations. These states and channels are in reach of the ongoing BESIII experiment and the PANDA experiments at the upcoming FAIR facility experiment. We present the resulting decay branching ratios with a parameter-free prediction.

X(1835) Decay in the Fock-Tani Formalism

In this work we have obtained an effective Hamiltonian to describe the strong decay of pseudoscalar glueball, where the microscopic interaction between the constituent gluons have been taking into account. The pseudoscalar glueball candidate we have considered here is the [Formula: see text] resonance. In our calculation the [Formula: see text] was a pure glueball.

Phenomenology of pseudotensor mesons and the pseudotensor glueball

We study the decays of the pseudotensor mesons $[ \pi_{2}(1670) , K_{2}(1770) , \eta_{2}(1645) , \eta_{2}(1870) ]$ interpreted as the ground-state nonet of $1^1 D_{2}$ $\bar{q}q$ states using interaction Lagrangians which couple them to pseudoscalar, vector, and tensor mesons. While the decays of $\pi_2 (1670)$ and $K_2 (1770)$ can be well described, the decays of the isoscalar states $\eta_2 (1645)$ and $\eta_2 (1870)$ can be brought in agreement with experimental data only if the mixing angle between nonstrange and strange states is surprisingly large (about $-42^\circ$, similar to the mixing in the pseudoscalar sector, in which the chiral anomaly is active). Such a large mixing angle is however at odd with all other conventional quark-antiquark nonets: if confirmed, a deeper study of its origin will be needed in the future. Moreover, the $\bar{q}q$ assignment of pseudotensor states predicts that the ratio $[ \eta_2 (1870) \rightarrow a_2 (1320) \pi]/[\eta_2 (1870) \rightarrow f_2 (1270) \eta]$ is about $23.5$. This value is in agreement with Barberis et al., ($20.4 \pm 6.6$), but disagrees with the recent reanalysis of Anisovich et al., ($1.7 \pm 0.4$). Future experimental studies are necessary to understand this puzzle. If Anisovich's value shall be confirmed, a simple nonet of pseudoscalar mesons cannot be able to describe data (different assignments and/or additional state, such as an hybrid state, will be needed). In the end, we also evaluate the decays of a pseudoscalar glueball into the aforementioned conventional $\bar{q}q$ states: a sizable decay into $K^\ast_2 (1430) K$ and $a_2 (1230) \pi$ together with a vanishing decay into pseudoscalar-vector pairs [such as $\rho(770) \pi$ and $K^\ast (892) K$] are expected. This information can be helpful in future studies of glueballs at the ongoing BESIII and at the future PANDA experiments.

Glueball dynamics in the hot plasma

We discuss the glueball contribution to the equation of state (EoS) of hot gluon matter below and above $T_c$. It is shown that the strong changing of masses of scalar and pseudoscalar glueballs near $T_c$ plays very important role in the thermodynamics of $SU(3)$ gauge theory. In particular, we give the arguments that these glueballs become massless at $T_G\approx 1.1T_c$ and this phenomenon is crucial in understanding of the mystery in the behavior of trace anomaly founded in the lattice calculation.

Ultralight glueballs in Quark-Gluon Plasma

We consider the dynamics of the scalar and pseudoscalar glueballs in the Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP). By using the instanton model for the QCD vacuum we give the arguments that the nonperturbative gluon-gluon interaction is qualitatively different in the confinement and deconfinement phases. Based on this observation it is shown that above $T_c$ the values of the scalar and pseudoscalar glueball masses might be very small. The estimation of the temperature of scale invariance restoration, at which the scalar glueball becomes massless, is given. We also discuss the Bose-Einstein condensation of the glueballs and the superfluidity of the glueball matter in QGP.

Decay of charmonium states into a scalar and a pseudoscalar glueball

In the framework of a chiral symmetric model, we expand a U (4)R × U (4)L symmetric linear sigma model with (axial-)vector mesons by including a dilaton field, a scalar glueball, and the pseudoscalar glueball. We compute the decay width of the scalar charmonium state χ C 0 (IP ) into a predominantly scalar glueball f 0 (1710). We calculate the decay width of the pseudoscalar charmonium states ηC (IS ) into a predominantly scalar glueball f 0 (1710) as well as into a pseudoscalar glueball with a mass of 2.6 GeV (as predicted by Lattice-QCD simulations) and with a mass of 2.37 GeV (corresponding to the mass of the resonance X (2370)). This study is interesting for the upcoming PANDA experiment at the FAIR facility and BESIII experiment. Moreover, we obtain the mixing angle between a pseudoscalar glueball, with a mass of 2.6 GeV, and the charmonium state ηC .

Mesons Beyond the Quark--Antiquark Picture

The vast majority of mesons can be understood as quark-antiquark states. Yet, various other possibilities exists: glueballs (bound-state of gluons), hybrids (quark-antiquark plus gluon), and four-quark states (either as diquark-antidiquark or molecular objects) are expected. In particular, the existence of glueballs represents one of the first predictions of QCD, which relies on the nonabelian feature of its structure; this is why the search for glueballs and their firm discovery would be so important, both for theoretical and experimental developments. At the same time, many new resonances ($X,Y,$ and $Z$ states) were discovered experimentally, some of which can be well understood as four-quark objects. In this lecture, we review some basic aspects of QCD and show in a pedagogical way how to construct an effective hadronic model of QCD. We then present the results for the decays of the scalar and the pseudoscalar glueballs within this approach and discuss the future applications to other glueball states. In conclusion, we briefly discuss the status of four-quark states, both in the low-energy domain (light scalar mesons) as well as in the high-energy domain (in the charmonia region).

Modelling glueballs

Glueballs are predicted in various theoretical approaches of QCD (most notably lattice QCD), but their experimental verification is still missing. In the low-energy sector some promising candidate for the scalar glueball exist, and some (less clear) candidates for the tensor and pseudoscalar glueballs were also proposed. Yet, for heavier gluonic states there is much work to be done both from the experimental and theoretical points of view. In these proceedings, we briefly review the current status of research of glueballs and discuss future developments.