This study explores the antioxidative activities of xanthohumol (XN) and isoxanthohumol (IXN), prenylated flavonoids from Humulus lupulus (family Cannabaceae), utilizing the oxygen radical absorption capacity (ORAC) and ferric reducing antioxidant power (FRAP) assays along with computational Density Functional Theory methods. Experimentally, XN demonstrated significantly higher antioxidative capacities than IXN. Moreover, we determined IXN pKa values using the UV/Vis spectrophotometric method for the first time, facilitating its accurate computational modeling under physiological conditions. Through a thermodynamic approach, XN was found to efficiently scavenge HOO• and CH3O• radicals via Hydrogen Atom Transfer (HAT) and Radical Adduct Formation (RAF) mechanisms, while CH3OO• scavenging was feasible only through the HAT pathway. IXN exhibited its best antioxidative activity against CH3O• via both HAT and RAF mechanisms and could also scavenge HOO• through RAF. Both Single Electron Transfer (SET) and Sequential Proton Loss-Electron Transfer (SPLET) mechanisms were thermodynamically unfavorable for all radicals and both compounds.