Protein-induced DNA Bending Research Articles

Protein-induced DNA bending: the role of phosphate neutralisation

An important component of protein–nucleic acid interactions is the formation of salt bridges between cationic amino acid side chains and the anionic phosphate groups of the nucleic acid. We have used molecular mechanics to study the energetic and conformational impact of such interactions. Firstly, crystallographic protein–nucleic acid complexes from the Protein Data Bank were analysed in terms of DNA curvature and the presence of salt bridges. For complexes where the DNA is significantly bent, the contribution of salt bridges to this curvature was modelled by studying the effect of neutralising the appropriate phosphate groups. The number and the distribution of salt bridges vary widely for different DNA binding motifs and appear to have very different effects on DNA. In the case of homeodomain, bZIP and helix–loop–helix proteins, salt bridges induce DNA bending, whereas for prokaryotic helix–turn–helix proteins the number of salt bridges is much smaller and little bending is found. By analysing the components of the DNA deformation energy involved in protein binding we show that salt bridges consistently increase the flexibility of the DNA backbone.

Strong DNA binding by covalently linked dimeric Lac headpiece: evidence for the crucial role of the hinge helices.

The combined structural and biochemical studies on Lac repressor bound to operator DNA have demonstrated the central role of the hinge helices in operator bending and the induction mechanism. We have constructed a covalently linked dimeric Lac-headpiece that binds DNA with four orders of magnitude higher affinity as compared with the monomeric form. This enabled a detailed biochemical and structural study of Lac binding to its cognate wild-type and selected DNA operators. The results indicate a profound contribution of hinge helices to the stability of the protein-DNA complex and highlight their central role in operator recognition. Furthermore, protein-DNA interactions in the minor groove appear to modulate hinge helix stability, thus accounting for affinity differences and protein-induced DNA bending among the various operator sites. Interestingly, the in vitro DNA-binding affinity of the reported dimeric Lac construct can de readily modulated by simple adjustment of redox conditions, thus rendering it a potential artificial gene regulator.

DNA-binding of phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase is accompanied by loop formation of the double-stranded DNA

The phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (FRS) from Thermus thermophilus has previously been shown to bind DNA. We demonstrate that the “winged” helix-turn-helix motifs in the duplicate domains B5 are the relevant structural elements for this DNA-binding property. By altering particular amino acids in the “wing”, the affinity of the FRS to DNA was significantly reduced. Based on experimental data, which indicate that the FRS prefers a certain DNA structure rather than a particular consensus sequence, we propose a novel loop model for the DNA-binding mode of the FRS. In our model we assume that two segments of the same DNA molecule are bound simultaneously by both B5 domains and are aligned in parallel, while the intervening DNA forms a loop. Due to the limited flexibility of the DNA, loop formation is only possible if the respective intervening DNA stretch exceeds a certain length. Several lines of evidence support this model. (1) We demonstrate by gel retardation assays that the DNA requires a minimal number of ca 80 base-pairs to be bound by the FRS. (2) In the presence of the FRS, DNA longer than ca 80 base-pairs has a significantly increased DNase I accessibility. This agrees well with its known preferential cleavage at positions where the minor grove is on the outside of looped-out DNA molecules. (3) The initial cleavage by DNase I of >80 bp long DNA occurs in the middle of the fragment. In a looped molecule this is the position with the highest accessibility to DNase I.The function of the FRS related to DNA binding is still unknown. Since the FRS exists in the nucleus of rapidly growing mammalian cells, and protein-induced DNA bending or looping contributes to several transcription, replication, and recombination systems in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, it is likely that the FRS, in addition to its aminoacylation function, influences common cellular processes via DNA binding.

DNA Sequence-dependent Differences in TATA-binding Protein-induced DNA Bending in Solution Are Highly Sensitive to Osmolytes

The complex formed between the TATA-binding protein (TBP) and the "TATA box" of eukaryotic class II promoters is the foundation for assembly of the complex to which RNA polymerase II is ultimately recruited. TBP binds productively to canonical and diverse variant TATA sequences with >100-fold differences in transcription efficiency. Co-crystals of canonical sequences and >11 variant sequences bound to various TBP molecules all have approximately 80 degrees bends. In contrast, the bend angles for TBP-TATA complexes in solution, derived from distance distributions, are approximately 80 degrees for a canonical sequence but range from 30 degrees to 62 degrees for five variant sequences. We show in this study that the osmolytes used to crystallize TBP-TATA complexes induce profound increases in the DNA bends of two transcriptionally active TBP-bound variant sequences to a common angle of approximately 80 degrees but have little effect on a transcriptionally inactive variant. The effect of osmolyte on the TBP-induced DNA bend of a variant TATA box sequence is also manifest in the kinetics of association, demonstrating a functional consequence of an osmolyte-induced structural change.

Plasmid vectors for the analysis of protein-induced DNA bending.

Bending of DNA by proteins plays an important role in transcription initiation, DNA replication, and recombination. The degree of protein-induced DNA-bending can be simply and conveniently determined by combining gel electrophoresis of DNA-protein complexes with the use of special plasmid vectors carrying the bendable DNA sequence (,). The vectors contain duplicate sets of restriction sites in a direct repeat order and cloning sites for insertion of protein-binding sequences between the two sets. Restriction enzyme digestion readily generates DNA fragments, which are identical in size but differ in the location of the protein-binding site Fig. 1). Open image in new window Fig. 1. Schematic representation of the pBend3 insert located between the EcoRI and HindIII sites. pBend3 was constructed by cloning of the 236-base-pair EcoRI-HindIII fragment of pBend2 (4) into pBluescript SK (Stratagene). pBluescript is a high-copy-number plasmid and generates a large amount of DNA upon plasmid extraction. The EcoRI-HindIII fragment contains 17 duplicated restriction sites. The duplicated sites can be used to generate DNA fragments of identical length, but in which the protein-binding sequence (gray rectangle) is shifted. The sites XbaI and SalI (in boxes) are unique and suitable for cloning of the protein binding sequence. Restriction sites are not drawn to scale. The sequence of the insert is shown in the lower part of the figure.

Relating Independent Measures of DNA Curvature: Electrophoretic Anomaly and Cyclization Efficiency

Electrophoretic methods are often used to measure DNA curvature and protein-induced DNA bending. Though convenient and widely-applied, quantitative analyses are generally limited to assays for which empirical calibration standards have been developed. Alternatively, solution-based cyclization of short DNA duplexes allows analysis of DNA curvature and bending from first principles, but a detailed understanding of this assay is still lacking. In this work, we demonstrate that calibration with an independent electrophoretic assay of DNA curvature permits interpretation of cyclization assay results in a quantitatively meaningful way. We systematically measure intrinsic DNA curvature in short duplexes using a well-established empirical ligation ladder assay. We then compare the results to those obtained from the analysis of the distribution of circular products obtained in simple enzymatic cyclization assays of the same duplexes when polymerized. A strong correlation between DNA curvature estimates from these two assays is obtained for DNA fragments between 150–300 bp in length. We discuss how this result might be used to improve quantitative analysis of protein-mediated bending events evaluated by cyclization methods. Our results suggest that measurements of DNA curvature obtained under similar conditions, in solution and in an acrylamide gel matrix, can be compared directly. The ability to correlate results of these simple assays may prove convenient in monitoring DNA curvature and flexibility.

Protein-directed DNA structure. I. Raman spectroscopy of a high-mobility-group box with application to human sex reversal.

Protein-directed reorganization of DNA underlies mechanisms of transcription, replication, and recombination. A molecular model for DNA reorganization in the regulation of gene expression is provided by the sequence-specific high-mobility-group (HMG) box. Structures of HMG-box complexes with DNA are characterized by expansion of the minor groove, sharp bending toward the major groove, and local unwinding of the double helix. The Raman vibrational signature of such DNA reorganization has been identified in a study of the SRY HMG box, encoded by the human male-determining region of the Y chromosome. We observe in the human SRY-HMG:DNA complex extraordinarily large perturbations to Raman bands associated with vibrational modes of the DNA backbone and accompanying large increases in intensities of Raman bands attributable to base unstacking. In contrast, DNA major-groove binding, as occurs for the bZIP protein GCN4 [Benevides, J. M., Li, T., Lu, X.-J., Srinivasan, A. R., Olson, W. K., Weiss, M. A., and Thomas, G. J., Jr. (2000) Biochemistry 39, 548-556], perturbs the Raman signature of DNA only marginally. Raman markers of minor-groove recognition in the human SRY-HMG:DNA complex are due primarily to perturbation of specific vibrational modes of deoxyribose moieties and presumably reflect desolvation at the nonpolar interface of protein and DNA. These Raman markers may be diagnostic of protein-induced DNA bending and are proposed as a baseline for comparative analysis of mutations in SRY that cause human sex reversal.

1999 Roche Diagnostics Prize for Biomolecular and Cellular Research / Prix Roche Diagnostics 1999 pour la recherche en biologie moléculaire et cellulaireStudies on a "jumping gene machine": Higher-order nucleoprotein complexes in Mu DNA transposition

Studies in my lab have focused on DNA transposition in the bacterial virus, Mu. In vitro studies have shown that Mu DNA transposition is a three-step process involving DNA breakage, strand transfer and DNA replication. In the first step, a nick is introduced at each end of the transposon. The liberated 3'-OH groups subsequently attack a target DNA molecule resulting in strand transfer. The transposon DNA, now covalently linked to the target, is finally replicated to generate the transposition end-product, referred to as a cointegrate. The DNA cleavage and strand transfer reactions are mediated by a "jumping gene machine" or transpososomes, which we discovered in 1987. They are assembled by bringing together three different DNA regions via a process involving multiple protein-DNA and protein-protein interactions. The action of four different proteins is required in addition to protein-induced DNA bending or wrapping to overcome the intrinsic stiffness of DNA, which would ordinarily prohibit the assembly of such a structure. Transpososome assembly is a gradual process involving multiple steps with an inherent flexibility whereby alternate pathways can be used in the assembly process, biasing the reaction towards completion under different conditions.

Replacement of Integration Host Factor Protein-induced DNA Bending by Flexible Regions of DNA

The Escherichia coli integration host factor (IHF) protein is required for site-specific recombination of bacteriophage lambda DNA. Previously, we had shown that alternative modules of static DNA curvature could partially replace IHF in recombination. Now we use regions of single-stranded DNA as a flexible tether to address whether the function of IHF in recombination is simply to reduce persistence length. Although we find that these modules clearly enhance recombination in the absence of IHF, they are not perfect replacements. In addition, evidence is presented that the efficacy of a flexibility swap is specific to a particular IHF site. This may indicate that additional functions beyond simple deformation of DNA are required of IHF. During the course of these experiments we discovered that these flexible sequences are still specific sites for IHF binding and function.

Hinge-helix formation and DNA bending in various lac repressor-operator complexes.

The hinge-region of the lac repressor plays an important role in the models for induction and DNA looping in the lac operon. When lac repressor is bound to a tight-binding symmetric operator, this region forms an alpha-helix that induces bending of the operator. The presence of the hinge-helices is questioned by previous data that suggest that the repressor does not bend the wild-type operator. We show that in the wild-type complex the hinge-helices are formed and the DNA is bent, similar to the symmetric complex. Furthermore, our data show differences in the binding of the DNA binding domains to the half-sites of the wild-type operator and reveal the role of the central base-pair of the wild-type operator in the repressor-operator interaction. The differences in binding to the operator half-sites are incorporated into a model that explains the relative affinities of the repressor for various lac operator sequences that contain left and right half-sites with different spacer lengths.

Modeling Helix-Turn-Helix Protein-Induced DNA Bending with Knowledge-Based Distance Restraints

A crucial element of many gene functions is protein-induced DNA bending. Computer-generated models of such bending have generally been derived by using a presumed bending angle for DNA. Here we describe a knowledge-based docking strategy for modeling the structure of bent DNA recognized by a major groove-inserting α-helix of proteins with a helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif. The method encompasses a series of molecular mechanics and dynamics simulations and incorporates two experimentally derived distance restraints: one between the recognition helix and DNA, the other between respective sites of protein and DNA involved in chemical modification-enabled nuclease scissions. During simulation, a DNA initially placed at a distance was “steered” by these restraints to dock with the binding protein and bends. Three prototype systems of dimerized HTH DNA binding were examined: the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP), the phage 434 repressor (Rep), and the factor for inversion stimulation (Fis). For CAP-DNA and Rep-DNA, the root mean square differences between model and x-ray structures in nonhydrogen atoms of the DNA core domain were 2.5 Å and 1.6 Å, respectively. An experimental structure of Fis-DNA is not yet available, but the predicted asymmetrical bending and the bending angle agree with results from a recent biochemical analysis.

Wrapping of DNA around the E.coli RNA polymerase open promoter complex.

High-resolution atomic force microscopy (AFM) and biochemical methods were used to analyze the structure of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase.sigma(70) (RNAP) open promoter complex (RP(o)). A detailed analysis of a large number of molecules shows that the DNA contour length of RP(o) is reduced by approximately 30 nm (approximately 90 bp) relative to the free DNA. The DNA bend angle measured with different methods varied from 55 to 88 degrees. The contour length reduction and the DNA bend angle were much less in inactive RNAP-DNA complexes. These results, together with previously published observations, strongly support the notion that during transcription initiation, the promoter DNA wraps nearly 300 degrees around the polymerase. This amount of DNA bending requires an energy of 60 kJ/mol. The structural analysis of the open promoter complexes revealed that two-thirds of the DNA wrapped around the RNAP is part of a region upstream of the transcription start site, whereas the remaining one-third is part of the downstream region. Based on these data, a model of the sigma(70).RP(o) conformation is proposed.

Expression systems and physiological control of promoter activity in bacteria

Promoter activity in vivo is not just dependent on the performance of the regulator/promoter pair which may predominantly control transcription initiation in response to a given signal, it also relies on overimposed mechanisms that connect the activity of individual promoters to the metabolic and energetic status of the bacterial cells. Such mechanisms—which frequently become limiting for biotechnological applications involving regulated promoters — include classic (i.e. cAMP/CRP-mediated) or alternative catabolite control checks, recruitment of protein intermediates of the phosphotransferase sugar transport system, coregulation through protein-induced DNA bending and the interplay of sigma factors during various growth stages.

A protein-induced DNA bend increases the specificity of a prokaryotic enhancer-binding protein.

Control of transcription in prokaryotes often involves direct contact of regulatory proteins with RNA polymerase from binding sites located adjacent to the target promoter. Alternatively, in the case of genes transcribed by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase holoenzyme containing the alternate sigma factor sigma54, regulatory proteins bound at more distally located enhancer sites can activate transcription via DNA looping by taking advantage of the increasing flexibility of DNA over longer distances. While this second mechanism offers a greater possible flexibility in the location of these binding sites, it is not clear how the specificity offered by the proximity of the regulatory protein and the polymerase intrinsic to the first mechanism is maintained. Here we demonstrate that integration host factor (IHF), a protein that induces a sharp bend in DNA, acts both to inhibit DNA-looping-dependent transcriptional activation by an inappropriate enhancer-binding protein and to facilitate similar activation by an appropriate enhancer-binding protein. These opposite effects have the consequence of increasing the specificity of activation of a promoter that is susceptible to regulation by proteins bound to a distal site.

Evidence for intrinsic DNA bends within the human cdc2 promoter

Cyclin-dependent protein kinases (Cdks) are key regulatory proteins of the eukaryotic cell cycle. The product of the cdc2 gene, p34 cdc2 (cdk1), is the catalytic subunit of a serine/threonine protein kinase that is expressed in S phase and functions in the G2 to M phase transition. Previous studies indicate that the human cdc2 gene expression is dependent on cell growth, and is transcriptionally regulated in a complex manner involving multiple transcription factors binding to specific sites in the promoter. One possible mechanism by which these transcription factors regulate transcription is that by binding to their cognate sites they induce bends in the DNA helix, thereby allowing their interaction with the basal transcription machinery through protein-protein contacts. Such protein-induced DNA bending is also influenced by intrinsic bends in the regulatory region. Using both theoretical and experimental approaches, the study reports that the human cdc2 promoter has an intrinsic DNA bend with a broad locus of curvature.

Functional analysis of DNA bending and unwinding by the high mobility group domain of LEF-1.

LEF-1 (lymphoid enhancer-binding factor 1) is a cell type-specific member of the family of high mobility group (HMG) domain proteins that recognizes a specific nucleotide sequence in the T cell receptor (TCR) alpha enhancer. In this study, we extend the analysis of the DNA-binding properties of LEF-1 and examine their contributions to the regulation of gene expression. We find that LEF-1, like nonspecific HMG-domain proteins, can interact with irregular DNA structures such as four-way junctions, albeit with lower efficiency than with specific duplex DNA. We also show by a phasing analysis that the LEF-induced DNA bend is directed toward the major groove. In addition, we find that the interaction of LEF-1 with a specific binding site in circular DNA changes the linking number of DNA and unwinds the double helix. Finally, we identified two nucleotides in the LEF-1-binding site that are important for protein-induced DNA bending. Mutations of these nucleotides decrease both the extent of DNA bending and the transactivation of the TCR alpha enhancer by LEF-1, suggesting a contribution of protein-induced DNA bending to the function of TCR alpha enhancer.

Electrostatic mechanism for DNA bending by bZIP proteins.

Biology is replete with examples of protein-induced DNA bending, yet the forces responsible for bending have been neither established nor quantified. Mirzabekov and Rich proposed in 1979 that asymmetric neutralization of the anionic phosphodiester backbone by basic histone proteins could provide a thermodynamic driving force for DNA bending in the nucleosome core particle [Mirzabekov, A. D., & Rich, A. (1979) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 76, 1118-1121]. Strauss and Maher lent support to this proposal in 1994 by demonstrating that replacement of six proximal phosphate residues with neutral methylphosphonates resulted in DNA bent spontaneously toward the neutralized face [Strauss, J. K., & Maher, L. J., III (1994) Science 266, 1829-1834; Strauss, J. K., Prakash, T. P., Roberts, C., Switzer, C., & Maher, L. J., III (1996) Chem. Biol. 3, 671-678; Strauss, J. K., Roberts, C.; Nelson, M. G.; Switzer, C., & Maher, J. L., III (1996) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 93, 9515-9520]. Here it is shown that bZIP proteins bend DNA via a mechanism involving direct contacts between one or two basic side chains and a symmetry-related pair of unique, nonbridging phosphate oxygens. The locations of these phosphates provide direct experimental support for a protein-induced bending mechanism based on asymmetric charge neutralization. This straightforward mechanism is compatible with many DNA-recognition motifs and may represent a general strategy for the assembly of protein-DNA complexes of defined stereochemistries.

DNA Bending Is Essential for the Site-specific Recognition of DNA Response Elements by the DNA Binding Domain of the Tumor Suppressor Protein p53

We have used circular permutation assays to determine the extent and location of the DNA bend induced by the DNA binding domain of human wild type p53 (p53DBD) upon binding to several naturally occurring DNA response elements. We have found that p53DBD binding induces axial bending in all of the response elements investigated. In particular, response elements having a d(CATG) sequence at the junction of two consensus pentamers in each half-site favor highly bent complexes (bending angle is approximately 50 degrees ), whereas response elements having d(CTTG) bases at this position are less bent (bending angles from approximately 37 to approximately 25 degrees ). Quantitative electrophoretic mobility shift assays of different complexes show a direct correlation between the DNA bending angle and the binding affinity of the p53DBD with the response elements, i.e. the greater the stability of the complex, the more the DNA is bent by p53DBD binding. The study provides evidence that the energetics of DNA bending, as determined by the presence or absence of flexible sites in the response elements, may contribute significantly to the overall binding affinity of the p53DBD for different sequences. The results therefore suggest that both the structure and the stability of the p53-DNA complex may vary with different response elements. This variability may be correlated with variability in p53 function.

Topological Measurement of Protein-induced DNA Bend Angles

A new method measures independently the changes in the DNA bend and winding angles that occur when a protein binds to its specific site in DNA. The procedure requires an investigation of the change in DNA topology induced when the protein binds to tandemly repeated sites of varying repeat length in circular DNA. This new method is superior to currently used methods because topology permits the measurements to be derived absolutely from first principles, and no comparison standards are required. The method is used to determine the bend and winding angles induced when catabolite gene activator protein binds to its site. The bend value obtained (69±4°) is intermediate to those reported for two crystal forms of the complex.

Transcriptional activation by protein-induced DNA bending: evidence for a DNA structural transmission model.

Integration host factor (IHF) is a DNA-bending protein that binds to an upstream activating sequence (UAS1) and, on a negatively supercoiled DNA template, activates transcription from the ilvPG promoter of the ilvG-MEDA operon of Escherichia coli. The transcriptional initiation site of the ilvGMEDA operon is located 92 bp downstream of UAS1. Activation is still observed when the orientation of the upstream IHF binding site is reversed. This manipulation places the IHF binding site on the opposite face of the DNA helix, directs the IHF-induced DNA bend in the opposite direction, and presents the opposite face of the nonsymmetrical, heterodimeric, IHF molecule to the downstream RNA polymerase. Lymphoid enhancer-binding factor, LEF-1, is a DNA-bending, lymphoid-specific, mammalian transcription factor that shares no amino acid sequence similarity with IHF. When the IHF site in UAS1 is replaced with a LEF-1 site, LEF-1 activates transcription from the downstream ilvPG promoter in E. coli as well as it is activated by its natural activator, IHF. These results suggest that specific interactions between IHF and RNA polymerase are not required for activation. The results of DNA structural studies show that IHF forms a protein-DNA complex in the UAS1 region that, in the absence of RNA polymerase, alters the structure of the DNA helix in the -10 hexanucleotide region of the downstream ilvPG promoter. The results of in vitro abortive transcription assays show that IIIF also increases the apparent rate of RNA polymerase isomerization from a closed to an open complex. We suggest, therefore, that IHF activates transcription by forming a higher-order protein-DNA complex in the UAS1 region that structurally alters the DNA helix in a way that facilitates open complex formation at the downstream ilvPG promoter site.