Protein Film Voltammetry Research Articles

Electrochemical Definitions of O2Sensitivity and Oxidative Inactivation in Hydrogenases

A new strategy is described for comparing, quantitatively, the ability of hydrogenases to tolerate exposure to O2 and anoxic oxidizing conditions. Using protein film voltammetry, the inherent sensitivities to these challenges (thermodynamic potentials and rates of reactions) have been measured for enzymes from a range of mesophilic microorganisms. In the absence of O2, all the hydrogenases undergo reversible inactivation at various potentials above that of the H+/H2 redox couple, and H2 oxidation activities are thus limited to characteristic "potential windows". Reactions with O2 vary greatly; the [FeFe]-hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 7757, an anaerobe, is irreversibly damaged by O2, surviving only if exposed to O2 in the anaerobically oxidized state (which therefore affords protection). In contrast, the membrane-bound [NiFe]-hydrogenase from the aerobe, Ralstonia eutropha, reacts reversibly with O2 even during turnover and continues to catalyze H2 oxidation in the presence of O2.

Redox Properties of Wild-Type and Heme-Binding Loop Mutants of Bacterial CytochromescMeasured by Direct Electrochemistry

We have used protein film voltammetry (PFV) to determine the midpoint potentials of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Hydrogenobacter thermophilus, and Nitrosomonas europaea wild-type monoheme cytochromes c (cyts c; PA, HT, and NE, respectively), as well as PA N64Q, HT Q64N, and NE V65delta mutants, as a function of pH, and buffer conditions. Recent studies have suggested that the identity of the 64 position of the heme-binding loop (either Asn or Gln) strongly influences the conformation of the Met ligand that binds the heme iron. The PFV studies reveal that HT and NE possess significantly lower potentials (wild-type cyts c having E(m) values of +227 and +250 mV vs SHE) than PA (+290 mV) in 50 mM phosphate buffer, pH 7 at 3 degrees C. The HT Q64N mutant rises in potential compared to wild-type, and the PA N64Q mutant has a lower potential, indicating relationships between Met ligand fluxion, hydrogen bonding to the Met ligand, and redox chemistry. Surprisingly, NE V65delta, possessing a heme binding loop nearly identical to that of the PA protein, displayed an E(m) of +232 mV, even lower than wild-type NE. These data are discussed in terms of models of Met ligand properties and proton dependence.

Diode or Tunnel-Diode Characteristics? Resolving the Catalytic Consequences of Proton Coupled Electron Transfer in a Multi-Centered Oxidoreductase

Protein film voltammetry has been employed to define multiple catalytic consequences of proton coupled electron transfer (PCET) in a cytochrome c nitrite reductase. Current-potential profiles reflecting the steady-state rate of nitrite-limited reduction have been defined from pH 4 to 8. Lowering the electrode potential at pH 8 causes the catalytic current to increase and then decrease before it takes a value independent of any further lowering of electrode potential. By comparison, at pH 4, catalysis is initiated at more positive electrode potentials in an approximately sigmoidal fashion with no attenuation of the catalytic rate evident at more negative electrode potentials. The results show that activity is turned on by the coupled transfer of two electrons and one proton to the enzyme. The decreased rate of catalysis at lower electrode potentials under more alkaline conditions shows that this rate attenuation occurs only when reduction is not coupled to compensating protonation(s) of the enzyme. Sites within the enzyme whose reduction and/or protonation may contribute to the definition of these activities are discussed.

Protein Film Electrochemistry of Microsomes Genetically Enriched in Human Cytochrome P450 Monooxygenases

This communication demonstrates direct electron delivery from electrodes to cyt P450 reductases in stable films ( approximately 100 nm thick) of genetically enriched CYP1A2 and CYP3A4 microsomes made by layer-by-layer assembly with polyions. Reversible voltammetry of films containing genetically enriched cyt P450 monooxygenase microsomes was shown to involve cyt P450 reductase by comparison with the pure rabbit reductase and by lack of characteristic reactions of iron heme enzymes, such as reaction of the FeII form with CO and catalytic electrochemical reduction of oxygen and hydrogen peroxide. The microsome films were activated electrochemically to catalyze styrene epoxidation, consistent with the pathway utilized in the human liver, although further work is required to establish this definitively.

Electron Transfer and Catalytic Control by the Iron−Sulfur Clusters in a Respiratory Enzyme,E.coliFumarate Reductase

Factors governing the efficacy of long-range electron relays in enzymes have been examined using protein film voltammetry in conjunction with site-directed mutagenesis. Investigations of the fumarate reductase from Escherichia coli, in which three Fe-S clusters relay electrons over more than 30 A, lead to the conclusion that varying the medial [4Fe-4S] cluster potential over a 100 mV range does not have a significant effect on the inherent kinetics of electron transfer to and from the active-site flavin. The results support a proposal that the reduction potential of an individual electron relay site in a multicentered enzyme is not a strong determinant of activity; instead, as deduced from the potential dependence of catalytic electron transfer, electron flow through the intramolecular relay is rapid and reversible, and even uphill steps do not limit the catalytic rate.

Cytochrome c nitrite reductase: from structural to physicochemical analysis

The recent structural characterization of the NrfA from Escherichia coli provides a framework to rationalize the spectroscopic and functional properties of this enzyme. Analyses by EPR and magnetic CD spectroscopies have been complemented by protein-film voltammetry and these are discussed in relation to the essential structural features of the enzyme.

Investigating Metalloenzyme Reactions Using Electrochemical Sweeps and Steps: Fine Control and Measurements with Reactants Ranging from Ions to Gases

Protein film voltammetry is a powerful method for probing the chemistry of redox-active sites in metalloproteins. The technique affords precise potential control over a tiny quantity of material that is manipulated on an electrode surface, providing information on ligand- or metal-exchange reactions coupled to electron transfer. This is illustrated by examples of transformations of the iron-sulfur clusters in ferredoxins. Protein film voltammetry is particularly advantageous in studies of metalloenzymes for which the current response is proportional to catalytic activity: kinetic data of extremely high signal/noise ratio are obtained for highly active enzymes. We present a series of interesting examples in which catalytic activity varies in unusual ways with applied potential, surveying information that can be obtained from cyclic voltammetry and then looking beyond this method to controlled potential-step experiments that yield kinetic and mechanistic details. Recent results on the voltammetry of the highly active [NiFe]-hydrogenase from Allochromatium vinosum illustrate how it is possible to use the precise kinetic information from potential-step experiments to diagnose subtle details of transformations between catalytically active and inactive states of an enzyme. Protein film voltammetry thus complements spectroscopic techniques and other physical methods, revealing the chemistry of systems that might appear intractable or convoluted by other means.

Reductive activation of nitrate reductases

Protein film voltammetry of Paracoccus pantotrophus respiratory nitrate reductase (NarGH) and Synechococcus elongatus assimilatory nitrate reductase (NarB) shows that reductive activation of these enzymes may be required before steady state catalysis is observed. For NarGH complementary spectroscopic studies suggest a structural context for the activation. Catalytic protein film voltammetry at a range of temperatures has allowed quantitation of the activation energies for nitrate reduction. For NarGH with an operating potential of ca. 0.05 V the activation energy of ca. 35 kJ mol-1 is over twice that measured for NarB whose operating potential is ca. -0.35 V.

Resolving Complexity in the Interactions of Redox Enzymes and Their Inhibitors: Contrasting Mechanisms for the Inhibition of a Cytochrome c Nitrite Reductase Revealed by Protein Film Voltammetry

Cytochrome c nitrite reductase is a dimeric decaheme-containing enzyme that catalyzes the reduction of nitrite to ammonium. The contrasting effects of two inhibitors on the activity of this enzyme have been revealed, and defined, by protein film voltammetry (PFV). Azide inhibition is rapid and reversible. Variation of the catalytic current magnitude describes mixed inhibition in which azide binds to the Michaelis complex (approximately 40 mM) with a lower affinity than to the enzyme alone (approximately 15 mM) and leads to complete inhibition of enzyme activity. The position of the catalytic wave reports tighter binding of azide when the active site is oxidized (approximately 39 microM) than when it is reduced. By contrast, binding and release of cyanide are sluggish. The higher affinity of cyanide for reduced versus oxidized forms of nitrite reductase is immediately revealed, as is the presence of two sites for cyanide binding and inhibition of the enzyme. Formation of the monocyano complex by reduction of the enzyme followed by a "rapid" scan to high potentials captures the activity-potential profile of this enzyme form and shows it to be distinct from that of the uninhibited enzyme. The biscyano complex is inactive. These studies demonstrate the complexity that can be associated with inhibitor binding to redox enzymes and illustrate how PFV readily captures and deconvolves this complexity through its impact on the catalytic properties of the enzyme.

Inhibition and aerobic inactivation kinetics of Desulfovibrio fructosovorans NiFe hydrogenase studied by protein film voltammetry.

We have used protein film voltammetry to study the NiFe hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio fructosovorans. We show how measurements of transient activity following the addition in the electrochemical cell of H(2), CO, or O(2) allow simple and virtually instantaneous determinations of the Michaelis constant, inhibition constant, or rate of inactivation, respectively, thus opening new opportunities to study the active site of NiFe hydrogenases. The binding and release of CO occur within a fraction of a second, and we determine and discuss how its affinity for the active site changes as the driving force for the H(+)/H(2) reaction is continuously varied. Inactivation by O(2) is a slow, bimolecular process (with pH-independent rate constant approximately 3 x 10(4) s(-1) M(-1) at 40 degrees C, under one atm of H(2)) that leads to a mixture of fully oxidized states, and unlike the case of CO inhibition, the active site is not fully protected by H(2). This experimental approach could be used to study the reaction of other multicentered metalloenzymes with their gaseous substrates or inhibitors.

Formation and characterization of an all-ferrous Rieske cluster and stabilization of the [2Fe-2S]0 core by protonation.

The all-ferrous Rieske cluster, [2Fe-2S](0), has been produced in solution and characterized by protein-film voltammetry and UV-visible, EPR, and Mössbauer spectroscopies. The [2Fe-2S](0) cluster, in the overexpressed soluble domain of the Rieske protein from the bovine cytochrome bc(1) complex, is formed at -0.73 V at pH 7. Therefore, at pH 7, the [2Fe-2S](1+/0) couple is 1.0 V below the [2Fe-2S](2+/1+) couple. The two cluster-bound ferrous irons are both high spin (S = 2), and they are coupled antiferromagnetically (-J > or = 30 cm(-1), H =-2JS1.S2) to give a diamagnetic (S = 0) ground state. The ability of the Rieske cluster to exist in three oxidation states (2+, 1+, and 0) without an accompanying coupled reaction, such as a conformational change or protonation, is highly unusual. However, uncoupled reduction to the [2Fe-2S](0) state occurs at pH > 9.8 only, and at high pH the intact cluster persists in solution for <1 min. At pH < 9.8, the all-ferrous cluster is stabilized significantly by protonation. A combination of experimental data and calculations based on density functional theory suggests strongly that the proton binds to one of the cluster mu(2)-sulfides, consistent with observations that reduced [3Fe-4S] clusters are protonated also. The implications for our understanding of coupled reactions at iron-sulfur clusters and of the factors that determine the relative stabilities of their different oxidation states are discussed.

Tuning a Nitrate Reductase for Function: THE FIRST SPECTROPOTENTIOMETRIC CHARACTERIZATION OF A BACTERIAL ASSIMILATORY NITRATE REDUCTASE REVEALS NOVEL REDOX PROPERTIES

Bacterial cytoplasmic assimilatory nitrate reductases are the least well characterized of all of the subgroups of nitrate reductases. In the present study the ferredoxin-dependent nitrate reductase NarB of the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7942 was analyzed by spectropotentiometry and protein film voltammetry. Metal and acid-labile sulfide analysis revealed nearest integer values of 4:4:1 (iron/sulfur/molybdenum)/molecule of NarB. Analysis of dithionite-reduced enzyme by low temperature EPR revealed at 10 K the presence of a signal that is characteristic of a [4Fe-4S](1+) cluster. EPR-monitored potentiometric titration of NarB revealed that this cluster titrated as an n = 1 Nernstian component with a midpoint redox potential (E(m)) of -190 mV. EPR spectra collected at 60 K revealed a Mo(V) signal termed "very high g" with g(av) = 2.0047 in air-oxidized enzyme that accounted for only 10-20% of the total molybdenum. This signal disappeared upon reduction with dithionite, and a new "high g" species (g(av) = 1.9897) was observed. In potentiometric titrations the high g Mo(V) signal developed over the potential range of -100 to -350 mV (E(m) Mo(6+/5+) = -150 mV), and when fully developed, it accounted for 1 mol of Mo(V)/mol of enzyme. Protein film voltammetry of NarB revealed that activity is turned on at potentials below -200 mV, where the cofactors are predominantly [4Fe-4S](1+) and Mo(5+). The data suggests that during the catalytic cycle nitrate will bind to the Mo(5+) state of NarB in which the enzyme is minimally two-electron-reduced. Comparison of the spectral properties of NarB with those of the membrane-bound and periplasmic respiratory nitrate reductases reveals that it is closely related to the periplasmic enzyme, but the potential of the molybdenum center of NarB is tuned to operate at lower potentials, consistent with the coupling of NarB to low potential ferredoxins in the cell cytoplasm.

A Distinctive Electrocatalytic Response from the Cytochrome c Peroxidase of Nitrosomonas europaea

Here the cytochrome c peroxidase (CcP) from Nitrosomonas europaea is examined using the technique of catalytic protein film voltammetry. Submonolayers of the bacterial diheme enzyme at a pyrolytic graphite edge electrode give catalytic, reductive signals in the presence of the substrate hydrogen peroxide. The resulting waveshapes indicate that CcP is bound non-covalently in a highly active configuration. The native enzyme has been shown to possess two heme groups of low and high potential (L and H, -260 and +450 mV versus hydrogen, respectively), and here we find that the catalytic waves of the N. europaea enzyme have a midpoint potential of >500 mV and a shape that corresponds to a 1-electron process. The signals increase in magnitude with hydrogen peroxide concentration, revealing Michaelis-Menten kinetics and K(m) = 55 microm. The midpoint potentials shift with substrate concentration, indicating the electrochemically active species observed in our data corresponds to a catalytic species. The potentials also shift with respect to pH, and the pH dependence is interpreted in terms of a two pK(a) model for proton binding. Together the data show that the electrochemistry of the N. europaea cytochrome c peroxidase is unlike other peroxidases studied to date, including other bacterial enzymes. This is discussed in terms of a catalytic model for the N. europaea enzyme and compared with other cytochrome c peroxidases.

Third-generation biosensors based on the direct electron transfer of proteins.

Recent progress in third-generation electrochemical biosensors based on the direct electron transfer of proteins is reviewed. The development of three generations of electrochemical biosensors is also simply addressed. Special attention is paid to protein-film voltammetry, which is a powerful way to obtain the direct electron transfer of proteins. Research activities on various kinds of biosensors are discussed according to the proteins (enzymes) used in the specific work.

Redox-triggered events in cytochrome c nitrite reductase

Escherichia coli cytochrome c nitrite reductase is a homodimeric enzyme whose 10 heme centres range in reduction potential from ca. −30 to −320 mV. Protein film voltammetry (PFV) was performed to assess how the reactivity of the enzyme towards a number of small molecules was influenced by heme oxidation state. The experimental approach provided a high-resolution description of activity across the electrochemical potential domain by virtue of the fact that the enzyme sample was under the precise potential control of an electrode at all times. The current potential profiles displayed by nitrite reductase revealed that heme oxidation state has a profound, and often unanticipated, effect on the interactions with substrate molecules, nitrite and hydroxylamine, as well as the inhibitor, cyanide. Thus, PFV provides a powerful route to define redox-triggered events in this complex multi-centred redox enzyme.

Electrochemical studies of arsenite oxidase: an unusual example of a highly cooperative two-electron molybdenum center.

Arsenite oxidase from Alcaligenes faecalis, an unusual molybdoenzyme that does not exhibit a Mo(V) EPR signal during oxidative-reductive titrations, has been investigated by protein film voltammetry. A film of the enzyme on a pyrolytic graphite edge electrode produces a sharp two-electron signal associated with reversible reduction of the oxidized Mo(VI) molybdenum center to Mo(IV). That reduction or oxidation of the active site occurs without accumulation of Mo(V) is consistent with the failure to observe a Mo(V) EPR signal for the enzyme under a variety of conditions and is indicative of an obligate two-electron center. The reduction potential for the molybdenum center, 292 mV (vs SHE) at pH 5.9 and 0 degrees C, exhibits a linear pH dependence for pH 5-10, consistent with a two-electron reduction strongly coupled to the uptake of two protons without a pK in this range. This suggests that the oxidized enzyme is best characterized as having an L(2)MoO(2) rather than L(2)MoO(OH) center in the oxidized state and that arsenite oxidase uses a "spectator oxo" effect to facilitate the oxo transfer reaction. The onset of the catalytic wave observed in the presence of substrate correlates well with the Mo(VI/IV) potential, consistent with catalytic electron transport that is limited only by turnover at the active site. The one-electron peaks for the iron-sulfur centers are difficult to observe by protein film voltammetry, but spectrophotometric titrations have been carried out to measure their reduction potentials: at pH 6.0 and 20 degrees C, that of the [3Fe-4S] center is approximately 260 mV and that of the Rieske center is approximately 130 mV.

In Rhodobacter sphaeroides respiratory nitrate reductase, the kinetics of substrate binding favors intramolecular electron transfer.

The respiratory nitrate reductase (NapAB) from Rb. sphaeroides is a periplasmic molybdenum-containing enzyme which belongs to the DMSO reductase family. We report a study of NapAB by protein film voltammetry (PFV), and we present the first quantitative interpretation of the complex redox-state dependence of activity that has also been observed with other related enzymes. The model we use to fit the data assumes that binding of substrate partly limits turnover and is faster and weaker when the Mo ion is in the V oxidation state than when it is fully reduced. We explain how the presence in the catalytic cycle of such slow chemical steps coupled to electron transfer to the active site decreases the driving force required to reduce the MoV ion and makes exergonic the last intramolecular electron-transfer step (between the proximal cubane and the Mo cofactor). Importantly, comparison is made with all Mo enzymes for which PFV data are available, and we emphasize general features of the energetics of the catalytic cycles in enzymes of the DMSO reductase family.

Voltammetric studies of the catalytic mechanism of the respiratory nitrate reductase from Escherichia coli: how nitrate reduction and inhibition depend on the oxidation state of the active site.

The respiratory molybdoenzyme nitrate reductase (NarGHI) from Escherichia coli has been studied by protein film voltammetry, with the enzyme adsorbed on a rotating disk pyrolytic graphite edge (PGE) electrode. Catalytic voltammograms for nitrate reduction show a complex wave consisting of two components that vary with pH, nitrate concentration, and the presence of inhibitors. At micromolar levels of nitrate, the activity reaches a maximum value at approximately -25 mV and then decreases as the potential becomes more negative. As the nitrate concentration is raised, the activity at more negative potentials increases and eventually becomes the dominant feature at millimolar concentrations. This leads to the hypothesis that nitrate binds more tightly to Mo(V) than Mo(IV), so that low levels of nitrate are more effectively reduced at a higher potential despite the lower driving force. However, an alternative interpretation, that nitrate binding is affected by a change in the redox state of the pterin, cannot be ruled out. This proposal, implicating a specific redox transition at the active site, is supported by experiments carried out using the inhibitors azide and thiocyanate. Azide is the stronger inhibitor of the two, and each inhibitor shows two inhibition constants, one at high potential and one at low potential, both of which are fully competitive with nitrate; closer analysis reveals that the inhibitors act preferentially upon the catalytic activity at high potential. The unusual potential dependence therefore derives from the weaker binding of nitrate or the inhibitors to a more reduced state of the active site. The possible manifestation of these characteristics in vivo has interesting implications for the bioenergetics of E. coli.

Reduction potentials of Rieske clusters: importance of the coupling between oxidation state and histidine protonation state.

Rieske [2Fe-2S] clusters can be classified into two groups, depending on their reduction potentials. Typical high-potential Rieske proteins have pH-dependent reduction potentials between +350 and +150 mV at pH 7, and low-potential Rieske proteins have pH-independent potentials of around -150 mV at pH 7. The pH dependence of the former group is attributed to coupled deprotonation of the two histidine ligands. Protein-film voltammetry has been used to compare three Rieske proteins: the high-potential Rieske proteins from Rhodobacter sphaeroides (RsRp) and Thermus thermophilus (TtRp) and the low-potential Rieske ferredoxin from Burkholderia sp. strain LB400 (BphF). RsRp and TtRp differ because there is a cluster to serine hydrogen bond in RsRp, which raises its potential by 140 mV. BphF lacks five hydrogen bonds to the cluster and an adjacent disulfide bond. Voltammetry measurements between pH 3 and 14 reveal that all the proteins, including BphF, have pH-dependent reduction potentials with remarkably similar overall profiles. Relative to RsRp and TtRp, the potential versus pH curve of BphF is shifted to lower potential and higher pH, and the pK(a) values of the histidine ligands of the oxidized and reduced cluster are closer together. Therefore, in addition to simple electrostatic effects on E and pK(a), the reduction potentials of Rieske clusters are determined by the degree of coupling between cluster oxidation state and histidine protonation state. Implications for the mechanism of quinol oxidation at the Q(O) site of the cytochrome bc(1) and b(6)f complexes are discussed.

Enzyme electrokinetics: using protein film voltammetry to investigate redox enzymes and their mechanisms.

Protein film voltammetry is a relatively new approach to studying redox enzymes, the concept being that a sample of a redox protein is configured as a film on an electrode and probed by a variety of electrochemical techniques. The enzyme molecules are bound at the electrode surface in such a way that there is fast electron transfer and complete retention of the chemistry of the active site that is observed in more conventional experiments. Modulations of the electrode potential or catalytic turnover result in the movement of electrons to, from, and within the enzyme; this is detected as a current that varies in characteristic ways with time and potential. Henceforth, the potential dimension is introduced into enzyme kinetics. The presence of additional intrinsic redox centers for providing fast intramolecular electron transfer between a buried active site and the protein surface is an important factor. Centers which carry out cooperative two-electron transfer, most obviously flavins, produce a particularly sharp signal that allows them to be observed, even as transient states, when spectroscopic methods are not useful. High catalytic activity produces a large amplification of the current, and useful information can be obtained even if the coverage on the electrode is low. Certain enzymes display optimum activity at a particular potential, and this can be both mechanistically informative and physiologically relevant. This paper outlines the principles of protein film voltammetry by discussing some recent results from this laboratory.