It would be easy to dismiss the study by Ellensen and colleagues [1Ellensen V.S. Andersen K.S. Vitale N. Davidsen E.S. Segadal L. Haaverstad R. Acute obstruction by pannus in patients with aortic Medtronic-Hall valves: 30 years of experience.Ann Thorac Surg. 2013; 96: 2123-2128Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (16) Google Scholar] as one of only historical interest, given that the Medtronic-Hall valve is no longer in use. The valve itself is an elegant design but is not relevant in today's “bileaflet world.” This comprehensive data set, however, gives us insight into a complication of mechanical valves common to all in character, albeit uncommon in occurrence: pannus formation.The incidence of pannus causing acute dysfunction in this study was 0.7/1,000 patient-years. This may be something of an underestimate, given that some pannus might occur causing stenosis without overt valve failure, even given a single-disc design. It is also conceivable that differences in the composition of the sewing rings could impact its development. Still, these data give us a reasonable estimate of the risk of pannus formation in the setting of a mechanical valve, a complication I always mention to a patient choosing a prosthesis but one for which I have not had handy number.The findings in this study also alert us to the serious nature of this complication, with one-quarter of individuals dying before surgical intervention could be accomplished and 2 dying during the reoperative procedure, for an overall mortality rate of 33%. It is unfortunate that the only risk factor identified is an unmodifiable one: female gender.Unfortunately, the details of suture technique, including use or nonuse of pledgets, were incomplete as was information on supraannular vs intraannular implantation, so the authors cannot give us technical advice for prevention. This leaves us with only the admonition to proceed without delay to definitive diagnostic and therapeutic measures when the diagnosis is suspected. Surely, that is of value to us all. It would be easy to dismiss the study by Ellensen and colleagues [1Ellensen V.S. Andersen K.S. Vitale N. Davidsen E.S. Segadal L. Haaverstad R. Acute obstruction by pannus in patients with aortic Medtronic-Hall valves: 30 years of experience.Ann Thorac Surg. 2013; 96: 2123-2128Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (16) Google Scholar] as one of only historical interest, given that the Medtronic-Hall valve is no longer in use. The valve itself is an elegant design but is not relevant in today's “bileaflet world.” This comprehensive data set, however, gives us insight into a complication of mechanical valves common to all in character, albeit uncommon in occurrence: pannus formation. The incidence of pannus causing acute dysfunction in this study was 0.7/1,000 patient-years. This may be something of an underestimate, given that some pannus might occur causing stenosis without overt valve failure, even given a single-disc design. It is also conceivable that differences in the composition of the sewing rings could impact its development. Still, these data give us a reasonable estimate of the risk of pannus formation in the setting of a mechanical valve, a complication I always mention to a patient choosing a prosthesis but one for which I have not had handy number. The findings in this study also alert us to the serious nature of this complication, with one-quarter of individuals dying before surgical intervention could be accomplished and 2 dying during the reoperative procedure, for an overall mortality rate of 33%. It is unfortunate that the only risk factor identified is an unmodifiable one: female gender. Unfortunately, the details of suture technique, including use or nonuse of pledgets, were incomplete as was information on supraannular vs intraannular implantation, so the authors cannot give us technical advice for prevention. This leaves us with only the admonition to proceed without delay to definitive diagnostic and therapeutic measures when the diagnosis is suspected. Surely, that is of value to us all. Acute Obstruction by Pannus in Patients With Aortic Medtronic-Hall Valves: 30 years of ExperienceThe Annals of Thoracic SurgeryVol. 96Issue 6PreviewAcute dysfunction of mechanical aortic valve prostheses is a life-threatening adverse event. Pannus overgrowth, which is fibroelastic hyperplasia originating from the periannular area, is one cause of dysfunction. The aim of this study was to determine the annual incidence of readmittance resulting from acute obstruction caused by pannus during 30 years of observation in patients with Medtronic-Hall aortic valve prostheses and to analyze the risk factors associated with pannus development. Full-Text PDF
Read full abstract