A fundamental understanding of the design of polymer ligands of proximal enzymes is essential for the precise targeting of cancer cells, but it is still in its infancy. In this study, we systematically investigated the contribution of the chain length, ligand density, and ligand ratio of proximal enzyme-targeted polymers to the efficacy, synergy, and selectivity for the inhibition of cancer cell proliferation. The results revealed that employing a moderate chain length as a scaffold allowed for an intrinsically high efficacy and synergy of proximal enzyme-targeted polymers, in contrast to single enzyme-targeted polymers that prefer longer chain length for efficacy. The synergy obtained in proximal enzyme targeting was not provided by the combination of the corresponding small molecules. Moreover, the maturation of the synergistic efficacy of the proximal enzyme-targeted polymers also improved selectivity. This study proposes a rational design for polymer inhibitors and/or ligands for cancer cells with a high efficacy and selectivity.