Prokaryotic Argonaute Research Articles

The abortive infection functions of CRISPR-Cas and Argonaute.

CRISPR-Cas and prokaryotic Argonaute (pAgo) are nucleic acid (NA)-guided defense systems that protect prokaryotes against the invasion of mobile genetic elements. Previous studies established that they are directed by NA fragments (guides) to recognize invading complementary NA (targets), and that they cleave the targets to silence the invaders. Nevertheless, growing evidence indicates that many CRISPR-Cas and pAgo systems exploit the abortive infection (Abi) strategy to confer immunity. The CRISPR-Cas and pAgo Abi systems typically sense invaders using the NA recognition ability and activate various toxic effectors to kill the infected cells to prevent the invaders from spreading. This review summarizes the diverse mechanisms of these CRISPR-Cas and pAgo systems, and highlights their critical roles in the arms race between microbes and invaders.

Genome manipulation by guide-directed Argonaute cleavage.

Many prokaryotic argonautes (pAgos) mediate DNA interference by using small DNA guides to cleave target DNA. A recent study shows that CbAgo, a pAgo from Clostridium butyricum, induces DNA interference between homologous sequences and generates double-stranded breaks (DSBs) in target DNAs. This mechanism enables the host to defend against invading DNAs such as plasmids and viruses. However, whether such a CbAgo-mediated DNA cleavage is mutagenic remains unexplored. Here we demonstrate that CbAgo, directed by plasmid-encoded guide sequences, can cleave genome target sites and induce chromosome recombination between downstream homologous sequences in Escherichia coli. The recombination rate correlates well with pAgo DNA cleavage activity and the mechanistic study suggests the recombination involves DSBs and RecBCD processing. In RecA-deficient E. coli strain, guide-directed CbAgo cleavage on chromosomes severely impairs cell growth, which can be utilized as counter-selection to assist Lambda-Red recombineering. These findings demonstrate the guide-directed cleavage of pAgo on the host genome is mutagenic and can lead to different outcomes according to the function of the host DNA repair machinery. We anticipate this novel DNA-guided interference to be useful in broader genetic manipulation. Our study also provides an in vivo assay to characterize or engineer pAgo DNA cleavage activity.

Strong temperature effects on the fidelity of target DNA recognition by a thermophilic pAgo nuclease

Prokaryotic Argonaute (pAgo) proteins are programmable nucleases with great promise in genetic engineering and biotechnology. Previous studies identified several DNA-targeting pAgo nucleases from mesophilic and thermophilic prokaryotic species that are active in various temperature ranges. However, the effects of temperature on the specificity of target recognition and cleavage by pAgos have not been studied. Here, we describe a thermostable pAgo nuclease from the thermophilic bacterium Thermobrachium celere, TceAgo. We show that TceAgo preferentially uses 5′-phosphorylated small DNA guides and can perform specific cleavage of both single-stranded and double-stranded DNA substrates in a wide range of temperatures. Single-nucleotide mismatches between guide and target molecules differently change the reaction efficiency depending on the mismatch position, with the fidelity of target recognition greatly increased at elevated temperatures. Thus, TceAgo can serve as a tool to allow specific detection and cleavage of DNA targets in a temperature-dependent manner. The results demonstrate that the specificity of programmable nucleases can be strongly affected by the reaction conditions, which should be taken into account when using these nucleases in various in vitro and in vivo applications.

Prokaryotic Argonaute Proteins as a Tool for Biotechnology

Programmable nucleases are the most important tool for manipulating the genes and genomes of both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Since the end of the 20th century, many approaches were developed for specific modification of the genome. The review briefly considers the advantages and disadvantages of the main genetic editors known to date. The main attention is paid to programmable nucleases from the family of prokaryotic Argonaute proteins. Argonaute proteins can recognize and cleave DNA sequences using small complementary guide molecules and play an important role in protecting prokaryotic cells from invading DNA. Argonaute proteins have already found applications in biotechnology for targeted cleavage and detection of nucleic acids and can potentially be used for genome editing.

A bacterial Argonaute from Tepiditoga spiralis with the ability of RNA guided plasmid cleavage

The eukaryotic Argonaute proteins (eAgos) play an important role in the RNA interference pathway. The function and mechanism of prokaryotic Argonaute proteins (pAgos) in vivo are still unclear although the structure of pAgos and eAgos are highly homologous. Most of the reported pAgos have a preference for 5′P-gDNA, but MpAgo originated from bacteria Marinitoga piezophila preferentially uses 5′OH-gRNA to target DNA and RNA. To enrich our knowledge of this type of Argonaute proteins, here we report an Argonaute protein derived from Tepiditoga spiralis (TsAgo). Like MpAgo, TsAgo has a preference for 5′OH-gRNA. Meanwhile, TsAgo has DNA and RNA cleavage activity in presence of Mn2+ and Mg2+, and TsAgo has catalytic activity at 37–70 °C. In addition, TsAgo can tolerate mismatches in the 5′-end and 3′-tail regions of guides but is sensitive to mismatches in the 5′-seed and central regions of guides, especially the central region. Furthermore, the EMSA assay reveals that TsAgo exhibits a stronger binding affinity for 5′OH-gRNA than 5′P-gRNA which is consistent with its cleavage activity. Moreover, the structural modeling analysis demonstrates that like MpAgo, TsAgo has an ordered α5 at the C terminus of the PIWI domain which may hinder to binding of 5′ phosphate. Importantly, we find that TsAgo can target and cut plasmid DNA in vitro at 60 °C under the direction of RNA guides. These studies broaden our understanding of pAgos, and demonstrate that TsAgo can be regarded as an RNA-guided programmable nuclease for cleaving plasmids.

Short prokaryotic Argonautes provide defence against incoming mobile genetic elements through NAD+ depletion.

Argonaute (Ago) proteins are found in all three domains of life. The so-called long Agos are composed of four major domains (N, PAZ, MID and PIWI) and contribute to RNA silencing in eukaryotes (eAgos) or defence against invading mobile genetic elements in prokaryotes (pAgos). The majority (~60%) of pAgos identified bioinformatically are shorter (comprising only MID and PIWI domains) and are typically associated with Sir2, Mrr or TIR domain-containing proteins. The cellular function and mechanism of short pAgos remain enigmatic. Here we show that Geobacter sulfurreducens short pAgo and the NAD+-bound Sir2 protein form a stable heterodimeric complex. The GsSir2/Ago complex presumably recognizes invading plasmid or phage DNA and activates the Sir2 subunit, which triggers endogenous NAD+ depletion and cell death, and prevents the propagation of invading DNA. We reconstituted NAD+ depletion activity in vitro and showed that activated GsSir2/Ago complex functions as a NADase that hydrolyses NAD+ to ADPR. Thus, short Sir2-associated pAgos provide defence against phages and plasmids, underscoring the diversity of mechanisms of prokaryotic Agos.

Prokaryotic Argonaute Proteins as a Tool for Biotechnology.

Programmable nucleases are the most important tool for manipulating the genes and genomes of both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Since the end of the 20th century, many approaches were developed for specific modification of the genome. The review briefly considers the advantages and disadvantages of the main genetic editors known to date. The main attention is paid to programmable nucleases from the family of prokaryotic Argonaute proteins. Argonaute proteins can recognize and cleave DNA sequences using small complementary guide molecules and play an important role in protecting prokaryotic cells from invading DNA. Argonaute proteins have already found applications in biotechnology for targeted cleavage and detection of nucleic acids and can potentially be used for genome editing.

Programmable RNA targeting by bacterial Argonaute nucleases with unconventional guide binding and cleavage specificity

Argonaute proteins are programmable nucleases that have defense and regulatory functions in both eukaryotes and prokaryotes. All known prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgos) characterized so far act on DNA targets. Here, we describe a new class of pAgos that uniquely use DNA guides to process RNA targets. The biochemical and structural analysis of Pseudooceanicola lipolyticus pAgo (PliAgo) reveals an unusual organization of the guide binding pocket that does not rely on divalent cations and the canonical set of contacts for 5’-end interactions. Unconventional interactions of PliAgo with the 5’-phosphate of guide DNA define its new position within pAgo and shift the site of target RNA cleavage in comparison with known Argonautes. The specificity for RNA over DNA is defined by ribonucleotide residues at the cleavage site. The analysed pAgos sense mismatches and modifications in the RNA target. The results broaden our understanding of prokaryotic defense systems and extend the spectrum of programmable nucleases with potential use in RNA technology.

Mesophilic Argonaute-based isothermal detection of SARS-CoV-2.

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19), caused by SARS-CoV-2 infection and its mutations, has spread rapidly all over the world and still requires sensitive detection to distinguish mutations. CRISPR-based diagnosis has been regarded as a next-generation detection method; however, it has some limitations, such as the need for specific recognition sequences and multiple enzymes for multiplex detection. Therefore, research on the exploration and development of novel nucleases helps to promote specific and sensitive diagnoses. Prokaryotic Argonaute (Ago) proteins exert directed nuclease activity that can target any sequence. Recently, thermophilic Agos have been developed as new detection techniques achieving multiplexity for multiple targets using a single enzyme, as well as accurate recognition of single-base differential sequences. In this study, to overcome the requirement for high reaction temperature of thermophilic Ago-based methods, we expanded the mining of mesophilic Agos to achieve CRISPR-like isothermal detection, named mesophilic Ago-based isothermal detection method (MAIDEN). The principle of MAIDEN uses mesophilic Ago cleavage combined with reverse transcription, which can provide single-strand DNA as a substrate and allow cleavage of fluorescence probes to sense SARS-CoV-2 at moderate temperature. We first mined and optimized the mesophilic Ago and the fluorescence reporter system and then selected a compatible reverse transcription reaction. Furthermore, we optimized MAIDEN into a one-step reaction that can detect SARS-CoV-2 RNA at the nanomolar concentration at a constant temperature of 42°C within 60 min. Therefore, MAIDEN shows advantageous portability and easy-to-implement operation, avoiding the possibility of open-lid contamination. Our study was the first attempt to demonstrate that mesophilic Agos can be harnessed as diagnostic tools, and MAIDEN was easily extended to detect other pathogens in a rapid and efficient manner.

A short prokaryotic Argonaute activates membrane effector to confer antiviral defense

Argonaute (Ago) proteins are widespread nucleic-acid-guided enzymes that recognize targets through complementary base pairing. Although, in eukaryotes, Agos are involved in RNA silencing, the functions of prokaryotic Agos (pAgos) remain largely unknown. In particular, a clade of truncated and catalytically inactive pAgos (short pAgos) lacks characterization. Here, we reveal that a short pAgo protein in the archaeon Sulfolobus islandicus, together with its two genetically associated proteins, Aga1 and Aga2, provide robust antiviral protection via abortive infection. Aga2 is a toxic transmembrane effector that binds anionic phospholipids via a basic pocket, resulting in membrane depolarization and cell killing. Ago and Aga1 form a stable complex that exhibits nucleic-acid-directed nucleic-acid-recognition ability and directly interacts with Aga2, pointing to an immune sensing mechanism. Together, our results highlight the cooperation between pAgos and their widespread associated proteins, suggesting an uncharted diversity of pAgo-derived immune systems.

An Argonaute from Thermus parvatiensis exhibits endonuclease activity mediated by 5' chemically modified DNA guides.

Prokaryotic Argonaute (pAgo) nucleases with precise DNA cleavage activity show great potential for gene manipulation. Extensive biochemical studies have revealed that recognition of guides with different 5' groups by Ago is important for biocatalysis. Here, we identified an Ago from the thermophilic Thermus parvatiensis ( TpsAgo) and analyzed the regulatory effect of 5'-modified guides on TpsAgo cleavage activity. Recombinant TpsAgo cleaves single-stranded DNA and RNA targets at 65-90°C, which is mediated by a 5' hydroxyl or phosphate DNA guide. Notably, TpsAgo can utilize various 5'-modified DNA guides for catalysis, including 5'-NH 2C 6, 5'-Biotin, 5'-FAM and 5'-SHC 6 guides. Moreover, TpsAgo performs programmable cleavage of double-stranded DNA at temperatures over 80°C and strongly tolerates NaCl concentrations up to 3.2 M. These results provide insight into the catalytic performance of Agos by guide regulation, which may facilitate their biotechnological applications.

Programmable cleavage of linear double-stranded DNA by combined action of Argonaute CbAgo from Clostridium butyricum and nuclease deficient RecBC helicase from E. coli.

Prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgos) use small nucleic acids as specificity guides to cleave single-stranded DNA at complementary sequences. DNA targeting function of pAgos creates attractive opportunities for DNA manipulations that require programmable DNA cleavage. Currently, the use of mesophilic pAgos as programmable endonucleases is hampered by their limited action on double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). We demonstrate here that efficient cleavage of linear dsDNA by mesophilic Argonaute CbAgo from Clostridium butyricum can be activated in vitro via the DNA strand unwinding activity of nuclease deficient mutant of RecBC DNA helicase from Escherichia coli (referred to as RecBexo–C). Properties of CbAgo and characteristics of simultaneous cleavage of DNA strands in concurrence with DNA strand unwinding by RecBexo–C were thoroughly explored using 0.03–25 kb dsDNAs. When combined with RecBexo–C, CbAgo could cleave targets located 11–12.5 kb from the ends of linear dsDNA at 37°C. Our study demonstrates that CbAgo with RecBexo–C can be programmed to generate DNA fragments with custom-designed single-stranded overhangs suitable for ligation with compatible DNA fragments. The combination of CbAgo and RecBexo–C represents the most efficient mesophilic DNA-guided DNA-cleaving programmable endonuclease for in vitro use in diagnostic and synthetic biology methods that require sequence-specific nicking/cleavage of linear dsDNA at any desired location.

Short prokaryotic Argonaute systems trigger cell death upon detection of invading DNA

SummaryArgonaute proteins use single-stranded RNA or DNA guides to target complementary nucleic acids. This allows eukaryotic Argonaute proteins to mediate RNA interference and long prokaryotic Argonaute proteins to interfere with invading nucleic acids. The function and mechanisms of the phylogenetically distinct short prokaryotic Argonaute proteins remain poorly understood. We demonstrate that short prokaryotic Argonaute and the associated TIR-APAZ (SPARTA) proteins form heterodimeric complexes. Upon guide RNA-mediated target DNA binding, four SPARTA heterodimers form oligomers in which TIR domain-mediated NAD(P)ase activity is unleashed. When expressed in Escherichia coli, SPARTA is activated in the presence of highly transcribed multicopy plasmid DNA, which causes cell death through NAD(P)+ depletion. This results in the removal of plasmid-invaded cells from bacterial cultures. Furthermore, we show that SPARTA can be repurposed for the programmable detection of DNA sequences. In conclusion, our work identifies SPARTA as a prokaryotic immune system that reduces cell viability upon RNA-guided detection of invading DNA.

Prokaryotic Argonaute Protein from Natronobacterium gregoryi Requires RNAs To Activate for DNA Interference In Vivo.

ABSTRACTThe Argonaute proteins are present in all three domains of life, which are archaea, bacteria, and eukarya. Unlike the eukaryotic Argonaute proteins, which use small RNA guides to target mRNAs, some prokaryotic Argonaute proteins (pAgos) use a small DNA guide to interfere with DNA and/or RNA targets. However, the mechanisms of pAgo natural function remain unknown. Here, we investigate the mechanism by which pAgo from Natronobacterium gregoryi (NgAgo) targets plasmid and bacteriophage T7 DNA using a heterologous Escherichia coli-based model system. We show that NgAgo expressed from a plasmid linearizes its expression vector. Cotransformation assays demonstrate that NgAgo requires an RNA in trans that is transcribed from the bacteriophage T7 promoter to activate cleavage of a cotransformed plasmid, reminiscent of the trans-RNA function in CRISPR/Cas9. We propose a mechanism to explain how NgAgo eliminates invading foreign DNA and bacteriophage. By leveraging this discovery, we show that NgAgo can be programmed to target a plasmid or a chromosome locus.

Characterization of a Programmable Argonaute Nuclease from the Mesophilic Bacterium Rummeliibacillus suwonensis.

Prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgos) from mesophilic bacteria are attracting increasing attention for their genome editing potential. So far, it has been reported that KmAgo from Kurthia massiliensis can utilize DNA and RNA guide of any sequence to effectively cleave DNA and RNA targets. Here we find that three active pAgos, which have about 50% sequence identity with KmAgo, possess typical DNA-guided DNA target cleavage ability. Among them, RsuAgo from Rummeliibacillus suwonensis is mainly explored for which can cleave both DNA and RNA targets. Interestingly, RsuAgo-mediated RNA target cleavage occurs only with short guide DNAs in a narrow length range (16–20 nt), and mismatches between the guide and target sequence greatly affect the efficiency of RNA target cleavage. RsuAgo-mediated target cleavage shows a preference for a guide strand with a 5′-terminal A residue. Furthermore, we have found that RsuAgo can cleave double-stranded DNA in a low-salt buffer at 37 °C. These properties of RsuAgo provide a new tool for DNA and RNA manipulation at moderate temperatures.

Characterization of endogenous nucleic acids that bind to NgAgo in Natronobacterium gregoryi sp2 cells

As nucleic acid-guided endonucleases, some prokaryotic Argonautes have been used as programmable nucleases. Natronobacterium gregoryi Argonaute (NgAgo) has also been proposed for gene editing, but this remains very controversial. Until now, the endogenous nucleic acids that bind to NgAgo in Natronobacterium gregoryi sp2 (N. gregoryi sp2) have not been characterized. We expressed the conserved PIWI domain of NgAgo and used it to induce anti-PIWI antibody. We also cultured the N. gregoryi sp2 strain and performed immunoprecipitation, chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP), and RNA immunoprecipitation (RIP) assays. The nucleic acids that endogenously bound NgAgo in N. gregoryi sp2 cells were sequenced and analyzed. The results showed that NgAgo endogenously bound RNA rather than DNA. NgAgo-associated RNAs were mainly transcripts of genes that encoded tRNA, transcriptional regulators, RNA polymerases, and RNA-binding proteins. NgAgo mainly binds to the transcripts inside genes or in their upstream sequences. Interestingly, the top enriched motif of peaks was the same as that of miR-1289, suggesting that NgAgo may regulate gene expression post-transcriptionally. GO enrichment analysis showed that the peak-associated genes were enriched in transmembrane transport processes. These results revealed that NgAgo binds RNA and may function in post-transcriptional regulation in vivo.

Characterization of endogenous nucleic acids that bind to NgAgo in Natronobacterium gregoryi sp2 cells

As nucleic acid-guided endonucleases, some prokaryotic Argonautes have been used as programmable nucleases. Natronobacterium gregoryi Argonaute (NgAgo) has also been proposed for gene editing, but this remains very controversial. Until now, the endogenous nucleic acids that bind to NgAgo in Natronobacterium gregoryi sp2 (N. gregoryi sp2) have not been characterized. We expressed the conserved PIWI domain of NgAgo and used it to induce anti-PIWI antibody. We also cultured the N. gregoryi sp2 strain and performed immunoprecipitation, chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP), and RNA immunoprecipitation (RIP) assays. The nucleic acids that endogenously bound NgAgo in N. gregoryi sp2 cells were sequenced and analyzed. The results showed that NgAgo endogenously bound RNA rather than DNA. NgAgo-associated RNAs were mainly transcripts of genes that encoded tRNA, transcriptional regulators, RNA polymerases, and RNA-binding proteins. NgAgo mainly binds to the transcripts inside genes or in their upstream sequences. Interestingly, the top enriched motif of peaks was the same as that of miR-1289, suggesting that NgAgo may regulate gene expression post-transcriptionally. GO enrichment analysis showed that the peak-associated genes were enriched in transmembrane transport processes. These results revealed that NgAgo binds RNA and may function in post-transcriptional regulation in vivo.

Programmable endonuclease combined with isothermal polymerase amplification to selectively enrich for rare mutant allele fractions

Liquid biopsy is a highly promising method for non-invasive detection of tumor-associated nucleic acid fragments in body fluids but is challenged by the low abundance of nucleic acids of clinical interest and their sequence homology with the vast background of nucleic acids from healthy cells. Recently, programmable endonucleases such as clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) associated protein (Cas) and prokaryotic Argonautes have been successfully used to remove background nucleic acids and enrich mutant allele fractions, enabling their detection with deep next generation sequencing (NGS). However, the enrichment level achievable with these assays is limited by futile binding events and off-target cleavage. To overcome these shortcomings, we conceived a new assay (Programmable Enzyme-Assisted Selective Exponential Amplification, PASEA) that combines the cleavage of wild type alleles with concurrent polymerase amplification. While PASEA increases the numbers of both wild type and mutant alleles, the numbers of mutant alleles increase at much greater rates, allowing PASEA to achieve an unprecedented level of selective enrichment of targeted alleles. By combining CRISPR-Cas9 based cleavage with recombinase polymerase amplification, we converted samples with 0.01% somatic mutant allele fractions (MAFs) to products with 70% MAFs in a single step within 20 min, enabling inexpensive, rapid genotyping with such as Sanger sequencers. Furthermore, PASEA's extraordinary efficiency facilitates sensitive real-time detection of somatic mutant alleles at the point of care with custom designed Exo-RPA probes. Real-time PASEA’ performance was proved equivalent to clinical amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS)-PCR and NGS when testing over hundred cancer patients’ samples. This strategy has the potential to reduce the cost and time of cancer screening and genotyping, and to enable targeted therapies in resource-limited settings.

Profiling Thermus thermophilus Argonaute Guide DNA Sequence Preferences by Functional Screening.

Prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgo) are an increasingly well-studied class of guided endonucleases, and the underlying mechanisms by which pAgo generate nucleic acid guides in vivo remains an important topic of investigation. Recent insights into these mechanisms for the Argonaute protein from Thermus thermophilus has drawn attention to global sequence and structural feature preferences involved in oligonucleotide guide selection. In this work, we approach the study of guide sequence preferences in T. thermophilus Argonaute from a functional perspective. Screening a library of 1,968 guides against randomized single- and double-stranded DNA substrates, endonuclease activity associated with each guide was quantified using high-throughput capillary electrophoresis, and localized sequence preferences were identified which can be used to improve guide design for molecular applications. The most notable preferences include: a strong cleavage enhancement from a first position dT independent of target sequence; a significant decrease in activity with dA at position 12; and an impact of GC dinucleotides at positions 10 and 11. While this method has been useful in characterizing unique preferences of T. thermophilus Argonaute and criteria for creating efficient guides, it could be expanded further to rapidly characterize more recent mesophilic variants reported in the literature and drive their utility toward molecular tools in biology and genome editing applications.

Expression and Functional Analysis of the Argonaute Protein of Thermus thermophilus (TtAgo) in E. coli BL21(DE3).

The prokaryotic Argonaute proteins (pAgos) have been reported to cleave or interfere with DNA targets in a guide-dependent or independent manner. It is often difficult to characterize pAgos in vivo due to the extreme environments favored by their hosts. In the present study, we expressed functional Thermus thermophilus pAgo (TtAgo) in E. coli BL21 (DE3) cells at 37 °C. Initial attempts to express TtAgo in BL21(DE3) cells at 37 °C failed. This was not because of TtAgo mediated general toxicity to the host cells, but instead because of TtAgo-induced loss of its expression plasmid. We employed this discovery to establish a screening system for isolating loss-of-function mutants of TtAgo. The E. coli fabI gene was used to help select for full-length TtAgo loss of function mutants, as overexpression of fabI renders the cell to be resistant to the triclosan. We isolated and characterized eight mutations in TtAgo that abrogated function. The ability of TtAgo to induce loss of its expression vector in vivo at 37 °C is an unreported function that is mechanistically different from its reported in vitro activity. These results shed light on the mechanisms by which TtAgo functions as a defense against foreign DNA invasion.