The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of sward diversification combined with a reduction of chemical nitrogen (N) fertilizer on the performance of spring calving grazing dairy cows within a farm systems experiment. Three farmlets were created; a monoculture of perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.; PRG) fertilized with 250 kg N/ha (PRG-250N), a PRG - white clover (Trifolium repens; WC) sward fertilized with 125 kg N/ha (PRGWC-125N) and a multispecies sward (MSS) comprising of grasses, legumes and herbs also fertilized with 125 kg N/ha (MSS-125N). Each farmlet had its own herd of dairy cows on a total area of 18.7 ha divided into 20 paddocks. Each herd was comprised of pure Holstein-Friesian (HF) and HF Jersey crossbred (JFX) animals and randomly assigned through the 3 treatments. For 3 years (2021 to 2023), the performances of both swards (grass yield, botanical composition, nutritive value) and grazing animals (milk production and composition, body weight (BW) and body condition score (BCS)) were recorded. There were no significant differences in pasture production or sward nutritive value between sward systems and grazing season length was also similar (264 d). On average over the 3 years, PRGWC-125N contained 150 g/kg DM of legumes and the MSS-125N contained 160 g/kg DM legumes, 130 g/kg DM plantain and 40 g/kg DM chicory. Both individual cow milk and fat plus protein (Milk solids; MS) yield were lower for PRG-250N (5,018 and 452 kg, respectively), intermediate for PRGWC-125N (5,139 and 463 kg, respectively) and highest for MSS-125N (5,297 and 476 kg, respectively) while milk and MS production per hectare from grazing were similar during the study period (11,523 and 1,016 kg/ha, respectively). Breed also had a significant effect with the JFX having lower milk yield but higher fat and protein concentration compared with HF. This resulted in higher MS production per kg of BW for the JFX compared with HF (0.96 and 0.87 kg MS/kg BW, respectively). The results of this study highlight the possibility for more diverse pastures to reduce chemical N fertilizer input requirements and maintain pasture productivity while increasing animal performance within pasture-based spring calving systems.