two casebooks and two daily journals provide a snapshot of the life and times of J.C. Goodwin, a resident house surgeon or “houseman” in obstetrics and gynaecology at the Toronto General Hospital during 1927-28. No comparable record of that era survives. Ninety-one gynaecological cases have been meticulously recorded in the casebook for September 1927. They are largely concerned with pelvic floor problems, severe infections managed without antibiotics, and invasive cervical cancer. Similarly, 66 cases recorded in the casebook for March 1928 attest to the fact that obstetrical practice was an almost entirely mechanical affair. Even in Toronto, two-thirds of women still delivered at home and maternal mortality was one hundred times worse than today. Obstetric research was in its infancy. There was emerging emphasis on good prenatal care and concern about severe toxemia, but perinatology, neonatology, and sophisticated obstetric anesthesia were unheard of. The daily journals make no nostalgic exaggeration of the fact that a resident in training in the 1920s worked harder and longer than is the case today. Pay consisted of an absurd honorarium. No one could afford marriage. In those days, chiefs and chairmen valued common sense, enthusiasm, kindness, and a capacity for hard work far more than genius and erudition. Perhaps we are so obsessed today by evidence-based medicine, randomized clinical trials, and meta-analyses that we tend to overlook the cultivation of these attributes in our young residents.
Read full abstract