Treatment with antibiotics is a major risk factor for Clostridioides difficile infection, likely due to depletion of the gastrointestinal microbiota. Two microbiota-mediated mechanisms thought to limit C. difficile colonization include conversion of conjugated primary bile salts into secondary bile salts toxic to C. difficile growth, and competition between the microbiota and C. difficile for limiting nutrients. Using a continuous flow model of the distal colon, we investigated how treatment with six clinically-used antibiotics influenced susceptibility to C. difficile infection in 12 different microbial communities cultivated from healthy individuals. Antibiotic treatment reduced microbial richness; disruption varied by antibiotic class and microbiota composition, but did not correlate with C. difficile susceptibility. Antibiotic treatment also disrupted microbial bile salt metabolism, increasing levels of the primary bile salt, cholate, and decreasing levels of the secondary bile salt, deoxycholate. However, decreased levels of deoxycholate did not correlate with increased C. difficile susceptibility. Further, bile salts were not required to inhibit C. difficile colonization. We tested whether amino acid fermentation contributed to persistence of C. difficile in antibiotic-treated communities. C. difficile mutants unable to use proline as an electron acceptor in Stickland fermentation due to disruption of proline reductase (ΔprdB) had significantly lower levels of colonization than wild-type strains in four of six antibiotic-treated communities tested. This data provides further support for the importance of bile salt-independent mechanisms in regulating colonization of C. difficile.