Dietary intervention is considered a safe preventive strategy to slow down aging. This study aimed to evaluate the protective effects of a commercially available supplement and six simpler formulations against DNA damage in 3D human keratinocytes. The ingredients used are well known and were combined into various formulations to test their potential anti-aging properties. Firstly, we determined the formulations' safe concentration by evaluating cytotoxicity and cell viability through spectrophotometric assays. We then examined the presence of tumor p53 binding protein 1 and phosphorylated histone H2AX foci, which are markers of genotoxicity. The foci count revealed that a 24-h treatment with the supplement did not induce DNA damage, and significantly reduced DNA damage in cells exposed to neocarzinostatin for 2 h. Three of the simpler formulations showed similar results. Moreover, the antioxidant activity was tested using a recently developed whole cell-based chemiluminescent bioassay; results showed that a 24-h treatment with the supplement and three simpler formulations significantly reduced intracellular H2O2 after pro-oxidant injury, thus suggesting their possible antiaging effect. This study's originality lies in the use of a 3D human keratinocyte cell model and a combination of natural ingredients targeting DNA damage and oxidative stress, providing a robust evaluation of their anti-aging potential.