Spatiotemporal gait parameters are commonly used to quantify physical functioning including in populations with atypical foot strike patterns. The current gold standard measurement system for gait analysis is marker-based motion capture and floor-mounted force plates, but it can be expensive and cumbersome to set up. Pressure sensitive walkways are more affordable, quicker to set up, and more portable. Currently available walkways have not been compared to marker-based motion capture when measuring atypical foot strike patterns. The recently developed Tekscan® Strideway pressure sensitive walkway system has not been compared to any gold standard. This study compared measurements of step width, step length, and step time from the Strideway™ system against a gold standard marker-based motion capture (Vicon® Vantage™) and floor-mounted force plate (AMTI®) system. Ten typically ambulating adults, free of injury, emulated five different foot strike patterns recording two-hundred footsteps for each. Results indicate that the Strideway™ compares well to the gold standard especially under typical foot strike patterns. The errors were highest for step width and near-zero for step time. However, the user needs to be aware that errors can substantially increase with certain foot strike patterns such as when the heel does not make contact with the walkway. The results of this study will help inform users about potential limitations when using a pressure sensitive walkway like the Strideway™ for testing populations with typical and atypical strike patterns.