Predator Consumption Rates Research Articles

Stingray life history trade-offs associated with nursery habitat use inferred from a bioenergetics model

Consumption rates of marine predators are vital to assessing their trophic impacts and potential consequences of fisheries removal and habitat alteration, yet are rarely estimated. Standard metabolic rates were estimated for juvenile brown stingrays, Dasyatis lata, and used as input parameters for a bioenergetics model to predict consumption rates. Temperature and mass had significant effects on metabolic rates. The energy budget of juvenile brown stingrays was heavily weighted toward metabolism, accounting for 66 % of consumed energy. Growth accounted for 7 % of the energy budget indicating very slow growth potentially due to limited food resources. Population consumption rates suggest potential for strong top-down effects on prey populations due to stingray predation. This study suggests the use of Kāne‘ohe Bay as a nursery habitat for juvenile brown stingrays is a trade-off between increased juvenile survival through predator avoidance and a late age at first maturity due to slow growth rates resulting from low prey availability.

Predator confusion is sufficient to evolve swarming behaviour

Swarming behaviours in animals have been extensively studied owing to their implications for the evolution of cooperation, social cognition and predator-prey dynamics. An important goal of these studies is discerning which evolutionary pressures favour the formation of swarms. One hypothesis is that swarms arise because the presence of multiple moving prey in swarms causes confusion for attacking predators, but it remains unclear how important this selective force is. Using an evolutionary model of a predator-prey system, we show that predator confusion provides a sufficient selection pressure to evolve swarming behaviour in prey. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the evolutionary effect of predator confusion on prey could in turn exert pressure on the structure of the predator's visual field, favouring the frontally oriented, high-resolution visual systems commonly observed in predators that feed on swarming animals. Finally, we provide evidence that when prey evolve swarming in response to predator confusion, there is a change in the shape of the functional response curve describing the predator's consumption rate as prey density increases. Thus, we show that a relatively simple perceptual constraint--predator confusion--could have pervasive evolutionary effects on prey behaviour, predator sensory mechanisms and the ecological interactions between predators and prey.

Seabirds maintain offspring provisioning rate despite fluctuations in prey abundance: a multi‐species functional response for guillemots in the North Sea

Summary Seabirds that consume more than one prey type may adjust their foraging to maintain provisioning rates for their chicks. How energetically effective are these strategies, and what are the implications for the management of seabirds and their marine habitat? A multi‐species functional response links consumption rates to the availability of multiple prey types, but fitting multi‐species functional responses to field data can be difficult, requiring consumption measurements over a range of different prey abundances. Such detailed data may be especially difficult to obtain in marine ecosystems. We used annual time‐series data on chick provisioning for the common guillemot Uria aalge together with abundance indices for its two main prey (lesser sandeel Ammodytes marinus and sprat Sprattus sprattus) to parameterize a multi‐species functional response for parents provisioning chicks at a major North Sea colony from 1992 to 2005. The fitted model reproduced changes in diet and consumption rate which were consistent with changes in local prey abundance including a long‐term decline in sandeels. The model predicted that energy intake by chicks would be more sensitive to changes in sprat abundance than sandeel abundance. Guillemots appeared able to adjust their foraging tactics over a wide range of prey abundances to maintain a consistent energetic intake rate for chicks. Synthesis and applications. Our results suggest guillemot chicks obtain adequate calorific intake from their parents despite fluctuating prey abundances, conferring some resilience in the face of environmental variation. The parameterized multi‐species functional response model can be used to estimate levels of severe prey shortage that compromise provisioning. It also enables us to interpret predator consumption rates so that these can be used as a metric of prey availability. Further, quantifying trophic links between marine prey and apex predators is needed to support the development of multi‐species models in which the predators can be included. Such models are needed as tools to effectively manage the marine ecosystem, taking into account the objectives of fishing, conservation and the need to maintain Good Environmental Status.

Effects of plant gross morphology on predator consumption rates.

We find that spatial structure, and in particular, differences in gross plant morphology, can alter the consumption rates of generalist insect predators. We compared Asian lady beetle, Harmonia axyridis Pallas, and green lacewing larvae, Chrysoperla carnea Stephens, consumption rates of pea aphids, Acyrthosiphon pisum Harris, in homogeneous environments (petri dishes) and heterogeneous environments (whole plants). Spatial complexity is often described as reducing predator success, and we did find that predators consumed significantly more aphids on leaf tissue in petri dishes than on whole plants with the same surface area. However, subtle differences in plant morphology may have more unexpected effects. A comparison of consumption rates on four different isogenic pea morphs (Pisum sativum L.) controlled for surface area indicated that both lady beetles and lacewings were more successful on morphologies that were highly branched. We speculate that predators move more easily over highly branched plants because there are more edges to grasp.

Predator–prey relationships in a Mediterranean vertebrate system: Bonelli’s eagles, rabbits and partridges

How predators impact on prey population dynamics is still an unsolved issue for most wild predator-prey communities. When considering vertebrates, important concerns constrain a comprehensive understanding of the functioning of predator-prey relationships worldwide; e.g. studies simultaneously quantifying 'functional' and 'numerical responses' (i.e., the 'total response') are rare. The functional, the numerical, and the resulting total response (i.e., how the predator per capita intake, the population of predators and the total of prey eaten by the total predators vary with prey densities) are fundamental as they reveal the predator's ability to regulate prey population dynamics. Here, we used a multi-spatio-temporal scale approach to simultaneously explore the functional and numerical responses of a territorial predator (Bonelli's eagle Hieraaetus fasciatus) to its two main prey species (the rabbit Oryctolagus cuniculus and the red-legged partridge Alectoris rufa) during the breeding period in a Mediterranean system of south Spain. Bonelli's eagle responded functionally, but not numerically, to rabbit/partridge density changes. Type II, non-regulatory, functional responses (typical of specialist predators) offered the best fitting models for both prey. In the absence of a numerical response, Bonelli's eagle role as a regulating factor of rabbit and partridge populations seems to be weak in our study area. Simple (prey density-dependent) functional response models may well describe the short-term variation in a territorial predator's consumption rate in complex ecosystems.

Effect of trichomes on the predation of Tetranychus urticae (Acari: Tetranychidae) by Phytoseiulus macropilis (Acari: Phytoseiidae) on tomato, and the interference of webbing

The two-spotted spider mite, Tetranychus urticae Koch, is an important pest of tomato in different parts of the world. Biological control of this pest on this crop has not been very successful. Phytoseiulus macropilis (Banks) has been used commercially for the control of T. urticae on different crops, but no information has been published on its potential to control T. urticae on tomato. The objective of this work was to compare the performance of a Brazilian population of P. macropilis on tomato with its performance on other plant species, relating the observed variation to the respective types and densities of trichomes. It has been hypothesized that the presence of the webbing produced by T. urticae could help the predator to avoid contact with trichomes and consequently to improve its performance on tomato plants. This hypothesis was also evaluated. Phytoseiulus longipes Evans was included in the work as a control, given that it has been reported to be a promising predator of Tetranychus species on tomato. The study was conducted under laboratory conditions. It was found that the performance of P. macropilis was similar to that of P. longipes and that trichomes hampered the locomotion as well as prey consumption and oviposition rate of both predators; that the presence of webbing resulted in higher levels of prey consumption and of predator oviposition; and that the presence of webbing eliminated the negative effect of trichomes of eggplants and partially eliminated the negative effect of trichomes of the 'cerasiforme' tomato variety. The observed density of trichomes in 'Carmem' one of the most common tomato varieties grown in Brazil, seems not to have interfered significantly with the prey consumption and the oviposition rate of P. macropilis. The results suggest that the latter is a promising predator of T. urticae on tomato. Complementary studies are warranted, to further evaluate the potential of P. macropilis for use as a biological control agent of this pest.

Habitat structure and prey aggregation determine the functional response in a soil predator–prey interaction

Functional responses describe the per capita consumption rates of predators depending on prey density, which quantifies the energy transfer between trophic levels. We studied a typical interaction of the litter–soil systems between hunting spiders ( Pardosa lugubris ; Araneae: Lycosidae) and springtails ( Heteromurus nitidus ; Collembola: Entomobryidae) at varying habitat structure, i.e. with moss vs. without moss. We found a hyperbolic increase in consumption (functional response type II) in the treatment without habitat structure that was converted into a roller-coaster (or dome-shaped in a broad sense) functional response in treatments with habitat structure. Additional experiments suggest that the reduced per capita consumption rates at high prey densities may be explained by aggregative defence behaviour of the springtails. Experimentally, this behaviour was induced by the presence of habitat structure. We analyzed the net-energy gain of this predator–prey interaction by comparing the predator’s metabolic energy loss to its energy gain by consumption. In treatments with habitat structure, the net-energy gain of the predator was limited at intermediate prey densities where prey aggregation reduced the consumption rates. Our results stress the importance of habitat structure and prey behaviour in shaping the functional response in a typical soil–litter predator–prey interaction.

Allometric functional response model: body masses constrain interaction strengths

1. Functional responses quantify the per capita consumption rates of predators depending on prey density. The parameters of these nonlinear interaction strength models were recently used as successful proxies for predicting population dynamics, food-web topology and stability. 2. This study addressed systematic effects of predator and prey body masses on the functional response parameters handling time, instantaneous search coefficient (attack coefficient) and a scaling exponent converting type II into type III functional responses. To fully explore the possible combinations of predator and prey body masses, we studied the functional responses of 13 predator species (ground beetles and wolf spiders) on one small and one large prey resulting in 26 functional responses. 3. We found (i) a power-law decrease of handling time with predator mass with an exponent of -0.94; (ii) an increase of handling time with prey mass (power-law with an exponent of 0.83, but only three prey sizes were included); (iii) a hump-shaped relationship between instantaneous search coefficients and predator-prey body-mass ratios; and (iv) low scaling exponents for low predator-prey body mass ratios in contrast to high scaling exponents for high predator-prey body-mass ratios. 4. These scaling relationships suggest that nonlinear interaction strengths can be predicted by knowledge of predator and prey body masses. Our results imply that predators of intermediate size impose stronger per capita top-down interaction strengths on a prey than smaller or larger predators. Moreover, the stability of population and food-web dynamics should increase with increasing body-mass ratios in consequence of increases in the scaling exponents. 5. Integrating these scaling relationships into population models will allow predicting energy fluxes, food-web structures and the distribution of interaction strengths across food web links based on knowledge of the species' body masses.

Response of a complex foraging phenotype to artificial selection on its component traits

In nature, where predators must often track dynamic and dispersed prey populations, predator consumption rate, conversion efficiency, dispersal, and prey finding are likely to be important links between foraging and predator–prey population dynamics. Small differences in predator foraging caused by variation in any of the abovementioned traits might lead to significant differences in predator success as well as population dynamics. We used artificial selection to create lines of the predatory mite, Phytoseiulus persimilis in order to determine the potential for or constraints on the evolution of predator foraging behaviors. All four foraging traits demonstrated considerable phenotypic variation. They also exhibited significant realized heritabilities after artificial selection, except that prey finding did not respond to downward selection. Lines that responded to selection did so rapidly, and high-consumption, high-conversion efficiency, and high- and low-dispersal were stable for at least four generations after artificial selection was relaxed. There were some indirect responses to selection among the foraging traits. For example, there was positive correlation between consumption and dispersal. However, none of the correlated responses were of the magnitude of the direct responses we measured on the same trait. We also observed some correlations between foraging traits and life-history traits such as low-consumption and development time (negative), high-consumption and fecundity (positive), and high-conversion efficiency and fecundity (positive), but these were more likely to represent non-genetic constraints. Intrinsic rates of increase in low-consumption and low-conversion efficiency lines were lower than in their respective high lines and the unselected control, whereas rates of increase in dispersal and olfactory response lines did not differ from the unselected control. Thus, traits that make up foraging share partially overlapping genetic architectures with highly heritable phenotypic components, suggesting that each foraging trait will be able to respond rapidly to changes in the density and distribution of resources.

How community ecology links natural mortality, growth, and production of fish populations

AbstractAndersen, K. H., Farnsworth, K. D., Pedersen, M., Gislason, H., and Beyer, J. E. 2009. How community ecology links natural mortality, growth, and production of fish populations. – ICES Journal of Marine Science, 66: 1978–1984. Size-spectrum theory is used to show that (i) predation mortality is a decreasing function of individual size and proportional to the consumption rate of predators; (ii) adult natural mortality M is proportional to the von Bertalanffy growth constant K; and (iii) productivity rate P/B is proportional to the asymptotic weight W∞−1/3. The constants of proportionality are specified using individual level parameters related to physiology or prey encounter. The derivations demonstrate how traditional fisheries theory can be connected to community ecology. Implications for the use of models for ecosystem-based fisheries management are discussed.

Climate, season, and social status modulate the functional response of an efficient stalking predator: the Eurasian lynx

1. Predation plays a major role in shaping the structure and dynamics of ecological communities, and the functional response of a predator is of crucial importance to the dynamics of any predator-prey system by linking the trophic levels. For large mammals, there is a dearth of field studies documenting functional responses, and observations at low prey density are particularly scarce. Furthermore, there is a lack of understanding about how variables such as season, social status and climate modulate the functional response curves. 2. We analysed kill rate data collected over a 10-year period based on radio-marked lynx (Lynx lynx) mainly preying on roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) along a steep prey density gradient in south-eastern Norway. 3. The asymptotic kill rate was reached at a very low prey density for both solitary individuals and family groups (i.e. females with their dependent kittens), indicative of an efficient predator. This highlights the importance of understanding the interplay between predator and prey at low prey densities. 4. A purely prey-dependent functional response was a poor descriptor of the data, as the curve was strongly modulated by season and differences between lynx of different social status. In addition, there was a clear effect of abiotic climatic factors (indexed by the North Atlantic Oscillation) on observed kill rates in the more snow-rich portion of our study area. 5. Our analysis suggests that simple functional response curves might be poor descriptors of predator consumption rates in complex natural system, and that auxiliary factors are likely to induce complexity into any predator-prey systems that would not be captured by simple deterministic approaches.

Post-settlement predation on ascidian recruits: predator responses to changing prey density

To understand factors contributing to sessile marine species mortality, we assessed the role of two species of small predaceous neogastropods (Mitrella lunata and Anachis lafresnayi) on mortality patterns of different species of ascidian recruits. By using the functional response approach (i.e., predator response to variations in prey density) we obtained comparative information on the survival and potential local persistence patterns of several species of ascidians common to southern New England, USA, coastal waters. In addition, we were able to compare the influence of the predators on ascidian species which were relatively recent invaders (e.g., last ~30 yrs or less) into southern New England from those species which have been resident in the region for more than a century. Ascidian recruits examined included both solitary (Ciona intestinalis, Styela clava, Molgula manhattensis, Ascidiella aspersa) and colonial (Botryllus schlosseri, Botrylloides violaceus and Diplosoma listerianum) forms. Collectively, our studies indicated that the predators displayed fairly generalized predation patterns and neither species readily consumed Botrylloides recruits. When ascidian recruit densities were manipulated over a 1 to 3 order of magnitude range, predator consumption rates differed between prey species. Proportional mortality was prey density independent (Type I functional response) when Anachis was preying on Styela, Ciona, Botrylloides and Diplosoma and when Mitrella was foraging on Diplosoma. Mortality was inversely prey density dependent (Type II functional response) when Anachis was feeding on Molgula and Mitrella was feeding on Styela, Ciona and Botryllus recruits. Low prey density mortality rates, suggestive of a Type III functional response, were observed when Anachis was feeding on Ascidiella and Botryllus and when Mitrella was feeding on Molgula recruits. Collectively, results indicate that, for the most part, the predators are capable of effectively controlling the prey regardless of naturally occurring variations in ascidian recruitment densities.

Seasonal Migration Determined by a Trade-Off between Predator Avoidance and Growth

Migration is a common phenomenon in many organisms, terrestrial as well as aquatic, and considerable effort has been spent to understand the evolution of migratory behaviour and its consequences for population and community dynamics. In aquatic systems, studies on migration have mainly been focused on commercially important fish species, such as salmon and trout. However, seasonal mass-migrations may occur also among other freshwater fish, e.g. in cyprinids that leave lakes and migrate into streams and wetlands in the fall and return back to the lake in spring. In a conceptual model, we hypothesized that this is an adaptive behaviour in response to seasonal changes in predation (P) and growth (G) and that migrating fish change habitat so as to minimise the ratio between predation mortality and growth rate (P/G). Estimates from bioenergetic modelling showed that seasonal changes in the ratio between predator consumption rate and prey growth rate followed the predictions from the conceptual model and also gave more precise predictions for the timing of the habitat change. By quantifying the migration of more than 1800 individually marked fish, we showed that actual migration patterns followed predictions with a remarkable accuracy, suggesting that migration patterns have evolved in response to seasonally fluctuating trade-offs between predator avoidance and foraging gains. Thus, the conceptual model provides a mechanistic understanding to mass–migration in prey fish. Further, we also show that the dominant prey fish is actually absent from the lake during a major part of the year, which should have strong implications for the dynamics of the lake ecosystem through direct and indirect food-web interactions.

Behavioural mechanisms underlying functional response of sea stars Asterias vulgaris preying on juvenile sea scallops Placopecten magellanicus

The functional response characterises the relationship between prey density and the consumption rate of individual predators. Typically, it is studied by fitting a model to observations of predation rate at different prey densities. The behavioural mechanisms underlying a functional response are not well understood, and estimates of model parameters seldom conform to observations of behaviour. We have developed a mechanistic approach that directly incorporates behavioural observations into characterisation of the functional response. Laboratory experiments were used to record predation rates and observe foraging behaviour of sea stars Asterias vulgaris preying on juve- nile sea scallops Placopecten magellanicus at different densities. Experiments were conducted in tanks with no sediment and tanks with sediment. Behavioural data from the experiments were used to calculate parameters of functional response models Th (handling time per prey) and a (rate of suc- cessful search). On both substrates, Th remained constant across prey density, while a was density- dependent. An inverse quadratic was used to describe a and was incorporated into a functional response model. Estimates of a were also obtained by fitting the functional response model to the pre- dation rate data using regression analysis. These estimates of a were highly consistent with the esti- mates calculated from behavioural data. On both substrates, sea stars preying on scallops had a Type III sigmoid-shaped functional response; on sediment, predation rate decreased at high prey densities. Sea star ability to capture attacked prey was probably the mechanism underlying the observed responses. In general, behavioural information can lead to better understanding of observed func- tional responses.

Rock crab predation of juvenile sea scallops: the functional response and its implications for bottom culture

The functional response describes how consumption rate of individual predators changes as prey density changes, and can have important implications for the bottom culture of scallops. We examined (i) the functional response of rock crabs (Cancer irroratus) preying on juvenile sea scallops (Placopecten magellanicus); (ii) the effect of substrate type and scallop size on the functional response; and (iii) the underlying behavioural mechanisms of observed functional responses. Specifically, we quantified predation rate and behaviours, such as the proportion of time spent searching for prey, encounter rate between predators and prey and the outcomes of encounters, when individual rock crabs were offered a range of scallop density (2–50 or 11–111 scallops m−2) and two size classes of scallops (∼ ∼25 and ∼ ∼35 mm shell height) on two different substrate types (“glass-bottom” and “granule”). We found that crab predation rate on small juvenile scallops increased at a decelerating rate with prey density to a plateau at high prey density on both substrates, indicating a hyperbolic (type II) functional response. Crab predation rate on large juvenile scallops was independent of prey density (i.e., no functional response evident), suggesting that crabs were at their satiation level. Prey density did not influence any behaviour except encounter rate on small juvenile scallops, which increased as prey density increased. Substrate type influenced crab predation: maximum predation rate of crabs on small juvenile scallops and encounter rate with either size of juvenile scallops was lower on granule than on glass-bottom. Our results in the laboratory suggest that crabs could potentially be swamped if scallops are seeded at a high density in the field. However, many factors in the field may influence the functional response. For example, the presence of multiple prey types may lead to sigmoid functional responses, while the presence of many crab individuals may lead to aggregation of crabs in areas of high prey density.

Emergence of ratio-dependent and predator-dependent functional responses for pollination mutualism and seed parasitism

Prey ( N) dependence [ g( N)], predator ( P) dependence [ g( P) or g( N, P)], and ratio dependence [ f( P/ N)] are often seen as contrasting forms of the predator's functional response describing predator consumption rates on prey resources in predator–prey and parasitoid–host interactions. Analogously, prey-, predator-, and ratio-dependent functional responses are apparently alternative functional responses for other types of consumer–resource interactions. These include, for example, the fraction of flowers pollinated or seeds parasitized in pollination (pre-dispersal) seed-parasitism mutualisms, such as those between fig wasps and fig trees or yucca moths and yucca plants. Here we examine the appropriate functional responses for how the fraction of flowers pollinated and seeds parasitized vary with the density of pollinators (predator dependence) or the ratio of pollinator and flower densities (ratio dependence). We show that both types of functional responses can emerge from minor, but biologically important variations on a single model. An individual-based model was first used to describe plant–pollinator interactions. Conditional upon on whether the number of flowers visited by the pollinator was limited by factors other than search time (e.g., by the number of eggs it had to lay, if it was also a seed parasite), and on whether the pollinator could directly find flowers on a plant, or had to search, the simulation results lead to either a predator-dependent or a ratio-dependent functional response. An analytic model was then used to show mathematically how these two cases can arise.

Predation on stocked Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) fry

We studied predator–prey interactions between juvenile Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) and trout in three Massachusetts, U.S.A., streams and in artificial streams. We sampled stomach contents of age-1+ and older salmon and trout (Salvelinus fontinalis, Salmo trutta) following salmon fry stocking in the spring of 1997 and 1998. Between 4.3 and 48.6% of the stocked fry were consumed within the first 2 days after stocking, and total fry mortality from predation varied from 4.3 to 60.7%. No significant differences were found between stomach weights of predators ( without fry weight) that consumed fry and those that did not. Artificial stream experiments testing effects of habitat complexity and predator species on predator consumption rates revealed that consumption rates were not different between brook (S. fontinalis) and brown (S. trutta) trout (p = 0.59). Predation rate tended to decrease as the percentage of riffle habitat increased but the decrease was not significant (p = 0.22). Our results indicate that predation on stocked Atlantic salmon fry can be substantial (up to 60%), appears to be short lived (2 days), and is not related in a simple way to abiotic and biotic factors.

Food Consumption, Digestion, Tissue Growth, Egesta and Assimilation of Harmonia dimidiata (Fabricius) on Cervaphis rappardi Indica Basu

Food intake, assimilation, tissue growth, approximate digestibility (A.D.), efficiency of conversion of digested (E.C.D.) and ingested food (E.C.I.) of coccinellid, Harmonia dimidiata ( Fabricius) on Cervaphis rappardi indica Basu were studied under laboratory conditions. On this prey, duration of the feeding period, fresh weight of food ingested, faeces produced and weight gain by the predator were recorded for computing quantitative nutritional parameters. The results revealed that food ingestion, egestion, assimilation and tissue growth increased with increase in biomass. The value of A. D. was highest in the first instar and showed a gradual decline as larvae matured. The maximum E.C.D. and E.C.I. were observed in second instar larvae. The consumption rate of predator showed a significant positive relationship with assimilation, egestion and tissue growth.

Estimating predation mortality in the Georges Bank fish community

Multispecies virtual population analysis (MSVPA) is one of the most successful methods of including predation in fishery models. By applying MSVPA to nine important fish species on Georges Bank, we estimated predation mortality of prey species, fishing mortality, and population abundance from 1978 to 1992. One of the inputs to the MSVPA, relative stomach content, was estimated by fitting gamma distributions to the logarithmic predator-to-prey size ratios. Chi-square tests indicated that the gamma distributions fit the observed ratios well. Predation mortality was highest at ages 0 and 1. Total biomass of all species remained relatively constant with decreasing predator biomass and increasing prey biomass. MSVPA requires extensive input data, and the uncertainty in the inputs will propagate into the model output. The sensitivity of MSVPA to perturbations in the inputs was assessed with a two-level fractional factorial design. Results of the sensitivity test indicated that MSVPA outputs were most sensitive to predator consumption rates and terminal fishing mortalities. With ±25% perturbations to the input parameters, MSVPA outputs varied within ±10% of the levels from the base run. Therefore, MSVPA appears to be relatively robust to uncertainty in the input data.

Application of a model of scale dependence to quantify scale domains in open predation experiments

We use a model of open predation experiments to define scale domains that differ in terms of the controlling processes and scale dependence of predator impacts. For experimental arenas that are small compared to the movements of the prey (small scale domain) the model predicts that predator impacts are scale independent and controlled by prey movements. For arenas of intermediate scale we predict that predator impacts are scale dependent and controlled by both prey movements and direct predation, and for the largest scale domain we predict weak scale dependence and predation control. We propose that the scale‐domain concept is useful when designing and interpreting field experiments. As an illustration we apply the concept to experiments examining predator effects on the stream benthos. First, we test two key assumptions of the underlying model: that area‐specific prey migration rates decrease with increasing size of experimental arenas and that predation rates are independent of arena size. For this purpose we used published estimates of prey emigration and predator consumption rates for nine studies examining the effects of stream predators on benthic prey. We found that prey per capita emigration rates but not predation rates decreased with increasing arena length. Second, we demonstrate a method for identifying the scale domain of real experiments. The model of predation experiments was parameterized using experimental data and the expected spatial and temporal scale dependence of predator impacts on prey in these experiments was simulated. The simulations suggest that the studies conducted in the largest arenas (length 15–35 m) should be classified as large‐scale, consumption‐controlled experiments, whereas the experiments conducted in smaller arenas (length 1.5–6 m) should be classified as small or intermediate‐scale. We also attempted to determine the scale domain of the experiments in a large data set, including results from most published stream predation experiments. The majority of arenas used in these experiments (73%) were smaller than 1 m in length. Our data on the scale dependence of predation and prey migration rate suggest that experiments in this scale range (<1 m) should be classified as small‐scale, movement‐controlled experiments for most prey taxa.