Stationary and rotational source are two types of source configuration used in commercial Gamma Ray Stereotactic Radiosurgery Systems (GRSRSs). However, it is unclear which one is better in dosimetric performance for clinical use. In this study, precise dose distributions in high resolution of the single source channel of two GRSRSs (the Elekta Leksell Gamma Knife® Model 4C (LGK 4C) for stationary GRSRS and the OUR XGD for rotational GRSRS) were generated by Monte Carlo simulation. Because of the geometrical symmetry, the overall dose distribution is generated by combining the transformed dose distributions of the single source channel. Output factors and penumbra widths were calculated and compared. The differences of output factors between two GRSRSs are minor. The penumbra widths of dose profile from all sources of the LGK 4C are 2.2-1.3-1.4 mm, 3.5-1.6-1.7 mm, 5.8-2.2-2.4 mm, and 7.2-2.6-3.0 mm (in XY-(+Z)-(−Z) form) for the secondary collimator of 4 mm, 8 mm, 14 mm, and 18 mm, respectively and those of the OUR XGD are 3.1-2.3-2.4 mm, 4.0-2.4-2.5 mm, 5.8-2.6-3.0 mm, and 7.2-3.0-3.6 mm for the secondary collimator of 5 mm, 10 mm, 15 mm, and 20 mm, respectively. The dose profiles in Z direction are not symmetrical, because all sources are distributed in +Z direction. Secondly, since the sources are located in higher latitude in the OUR XGD (14°–43°) comparing with that in the LGK 4C (6°–36°), the penumbra widths in Z direction of the OUR XGD are larger than those of the LGK 4C. Thirdly, although the penumbra widths of dose profiles from the single source channel of the LGK 4C are smaller than those of the OUR XGD, with rotational source configuration the OUR XGD has smaller penumbra width of dose profile from all sources in X–Y plane when the secondary collimator is more than 10 mm.
Read full abstract