Retroperitoneal lymph node dissection (RPLND) and adjuvant chemotherapy are two adjuvant treatment options for patients with clinical Stage I nonseminomatous germ cell tumors of the testis (NSGCT). Aim of this trial was to prove the advantage of one cycle of bleomycin, etoposide, and cisplatin (BEP) chemotherapy compared with RPLND in terms of recurrence.Between 1996 and 2005, 382 patients were randomly assigned to receive either RPLND (n = 191) or one course of BEP (n = 191) after orchidectomy. The primary study end point was the rate of recurrence. The trial was powered to detect a 7% reduction (from 10% to 3%) of recurrence with chemotherapy compared with surgery.After a median follow-up of 4.7 years, 2 and 15 recurrences were observed in the intention-to-treat population with chemotherapy and surgery, respectively (P = 0.0011). The difference in the 2-year recurrence-free survival rate between chemotherapy (99.46%; 95% CI, 96.20%–99.92%) and surgery (91.87%; 95% CI, 86.87%–95.02%) was 7.59% (95% CI, 3.13%–12.05%). The hazard ratio to experience a tumor recurrence with surgery as opposed to chemotherapy was 7.937 (95% CI, 1.808–34.48).To our knowledge, this is the largest randomized trial investigating adjuvant treatment strategies in clinical Stage I NSGCT, which showed the superiority of 1 course BEP over RPLND performed according to community standards to prevent recurrence. Although not standard treatment, 1 course of BEP is active in an unselected group of patients with clinical Stage I disease and merits further investigation.
Read full abstract