Renewable Energy Power Generation Research Articles

Peak-shaving cost of power system in the key scenarios of renewable energy development in China: Ningxia case study

Renewable energy has developed rapidly in Ningxia, and it has become the first provincial power system in China whose renewable energy power generation output exceeds the power load of the whole region. The access of a high proportion of renewable energy puts forward higher requirements for the peak-shaving capacity of the Ningxia power system. In order to solve the problem of calculating the peak-shaving cost in the key scenarios of renewable energy development in Ningxia, a quantitative model of the peak-shaving cost of the power system considering time-of-use price is proposed. We take Ningxia power system as an example to study. First, the key scenarios of the Ningxia power system peak-shaving are obtained, and the technical cost characteristic boundaries of various peak-shaving resources are determined. Second, according to the characteristics of typical daily renewable energy and load in Ningxia, the quantification model of the power system peak-shaving cost is established. The model takes the minimum total cost of the power system as the objective function and considers the constraints such as technical output of thermal power units, charge-discharge characteristics of energy storage and time-of-use price mechanism. Finally, the model is solved and the peak-shaving cost and unit output under the optimal scheme are obtained. This example shows that the model can effectively evaluate the peak-shaving cost and unit output of the Ningxia power system under the key scenarios of peak-shaving.

Preface

The 2023 2nd International Conference on Renewable Energy and Electrical Technology (ICREET 2023) was held from December 22nd to 24th, 2023 in Tianjin, China via virtual form. With ICREET 2023, the conference series International Conference on Renewable Energy and Electrical Technology (ICREET) completed its second edition.ICREET 2023 attracted a number of papers related to renewable energy and electrical technology, including but not limited to: Renewable Energy Power Generation, Clean Production and Green Chemical Technology, Smart Grid Power Transmission and Distribution, Power System Modeling, Simulation and Analysis, Electric Traction Systems and Control, etc.All of the papers were exhaustively reviewed by the program committee members and peer-reviewers, who took into account the breadth and depth of the research topics that fall under the scope of ICREET. The most promising contributions were selected from all the submissions for presentation and inclusion in this paper volume, which presents innovative original ideas or results of general significance supported by clear and rigorous reasoning and compelling new evidence, as well as methods.The Conference agenda fell into mainly three parts, including keynote speeches, oral presentations, and academic investigation. Keynote speeches were performed by three distinguished professors: Prof. Abdul Hasib Chowdhury (Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology, Bangladesh), whose research interests include power system planning, stability, reliability analysis, contingency and security analysis, power quality analysis etc., talked on Torsional Resonance in Turbine-Generator Shaft Due to the Operation of Multiple Electric Furnaces at Close Proximity, Assoc. Prof. Hidayat Bin Zainuddin (Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka, Malaysia), who has authored and co-authored over 50 technical papers comprising journals and conference proceedings, and contributed in reviewing articles for many conferences and journals published by IEEE, Elsevier, etc., on Ester Oil as Greener Insulating Fluid for Oil-Filled Transformers, Assoc. Prof. Norzanah Rosmin (Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, Malaysia), who has 23 years’ experience in electrical engineering courses teaching and supervision of students’ projects and researches, and has published many papers in books, journals and conference proceedings and got numbers of awards for innovation projects based on her expertise, on Energy Efficiency and Energy Management System via Double Layer Approach for A Sustainable Future.We would like to acknowledge all the speakers, authors, Technical Program Committee members and anonymous reviewers for their efforts in making ICREET 2023 so successful. We’d also appreciate the support from the staff of Journal of Physics: Conference Series for making this volume published.The Committee of ICREET 2023List of Committee Member is available in this Pdf.

A Series Impedance Reshaping Control Method Considering PLL Dynamics for Grid-Connected Inverters Under Weak Grid Conditions

Grid-connected inverters are the key part in renewable energy power generation systems. Usually, phase-locked loop (PLL) is adopted in grid-connected inverters to achieve synchronization. However, prior-art works have revealed that the negative resistance behavior in the low-frequency band caused by PLLs may lead to system instability under weak grids. In this paper, first, a comprehensive small-signal output impedance modeling of the LCL-filtered single-phase grid-connected inverter is derived for stability analysis, where the digital control delays and PLL dynamics have been taken into account. Then, a simple but effective virtual series based impedance reshaping method is proposed. With that, the inverter system can operate stably even under a very weak grid (e.g., short-circuit ratio (SCR) is as low as 1.2). Compared with the traditional grid impedance compensation by virtually increasing grid resistance or reducing the grid inductance, the proposed method does not require grid impedance estimation and is robust against system parameter variations. Thus, its feasibility is improved. Finally, experimental tests are carried out on a single-phase 5-kW prototype, validating the effectiveness of the proposed scheme.

Comparative investigation on the thermodynamic performance of coal-fired power plant integrating with the molten salt thermal storage system

One of the most critical challenges facing China is enhancing the operational flexibility of coal-fired power plants (CFPPs), given the increasing reliance on renewable energy for power generation. This study focuses on analyzing and comparing the molten salt thermal storage systems integrated in CFPP in consideration of peak-shaving capacity, equivalent round-trip efficiency, heat consumption rate, and exergy efficiency. Five charging schemes integrating thermal energy storage (TES), power to heat (P2H) and combination of TES and P2H are proposed and tested via their thermodynamic models. Results show that all five integrated molten salt thermal storage systems can enhance the peak shaving capability of the CFPP. When integrating P2H system, CFPP has the potential to achieve a zero-power output. Furthermore, comparing to the other four schemes, P2H-only integrating scheme has the highest equivalent round-trip efficiency of 36.23 % and the lowest heat consumption rate of 8288.87 kJ·(kW·h)−1. However, its exergy efficiency decreases to 36.51 % due to the electric heater experiencing the highest exergy loss of 132.56 MW, in contrast to the TES-coupled system which shows a higher exergy efficiency of 39.58 %. The P2H-only scheme boasts the largest investment of $33,353,100 and the longest repayment time, while also earning the highest compensation for peak shaving. This study provides a promising approach for molten salt thermal storage system designs in enhancing flexibility for CFPPs.

Integrated optimization of production planning and electric trucks charging and discharging scheduling

The majority of supply chains in any manufacturing industry rely on heavy trucks for their flow of material from suppliers to end-users. Transportation by these heavy trucks causes greenhouse gas emissions detrimental to the environment. To cope with challenges caused by environmental issues and energy crises, replacing heavy trucks with electric trucks seems to be a viable solution. They can be considered as an energy resource that supports grid-to-vehicle and vehicle-to-grid, enabling efficient energy management for smart manufacturing systems and supply chains. Proper scheduling of charging and discharging activities of electric trucks also supports the penetration of renewable energy sources with volatile energy generation. This paper encourages sustainable practices and proposes a mixed integer programming model for the simultaneous optimization of production planning and transportation scheduling of electric trucks in a smart manufacturing system. The uncertainty sources considered in this system include power generation of renewable energy, transportation patterns, and customer demand for products. The results show that utilizing electric trucks in smart manufacturing with real-time pricing, save up to 11% of the total cost compared to traditional manufacturing systems without electric trucks and renewable energies. This integration also increases the efficient utilization of renewable energies such as wind and solar powers. The savings decrease to 4% and 8% under flat and time-of-use electricity pricing strategies. The results also highlight the complexity of setting utilization level of electric trucks and renewable energy sources into well-implemented sustainability standards.

Reinvestigating the EKC hypothesis: Does renewable energy in power generation reduce carbon emissions and ecological footprint?

For a developing nation such as Malaysia with a significant reliance on fossil fuels for electricity, understanding the environmental consequences of this dependency is crucial. Thus, this study utilizes the Autoregressive Distributed Lag (ARDL) method to explore the impact of electricity intensity (EINT), renewable energy in electricity generation (ERE), and gross domestic product (GDP) on Malaysia's environmental quality, from 1985 to 2020. By using carbon emissions (CO2 emissions) and ecological footprint (EF) as proxies, the study finds a significant long-run impact of these factors on environmental degradation. Notably, the study also observed an inverted U-shaped relationship between GDP and environmental degradation, validating the existence of Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) hypothesis. The findings also imply that while electricity intensity is associated with increased emissions, the use of renewable energy (RE) sources for electricity generation may contribute to emission reduction. But the results for both variables show reversal signs on EF. The study's adoption of the fully ordinary least square (FMOLS) method reinforces the same results, thus, justifying the cointegrating relationship between studied variables. Drawing from these outcomes, the study advocates for a comprehensive approach to renewable energy management, emphasizing both its utilization and waste in order to improve ecological footprint. Moreover, the pressing need to enact legislation on energy efficiency and conservation is crucial in ensuring decoupling and securing sustainable development in Malaysia.

A Review of the Research on the Wide-Band Oscillation Analysis and Suppression of Renewable Energy Grid-Connected Systems

With the continuous expansion of the scale of power generated by grid-connected renewable energy, the form and operation characteristics of power grids have undergone significant changes, and the power electronic characteristics of power systems are prominent, resulting in the frequent occurrence of wide-band oscillation problems when renewable energy power generation equipment is connected to a power grid. Oscillation has the characteristics of nonlinearity and has an oscillation frequency ranging from a few hertz to several thousand hertz or more, which seriously threatens the stable operation of power grids. This paper summarizes the wide-band oscillation events that occur worldwide under the background of renewable energy access to power grids, classifies the wide-band oscillation events according to the distribution of oscillation frequency bands, and sorts out the characteristics of various oscillations. From the perspectives of the source side and network side, the existing oscillation suppression measures are classified and prospected.

Development pathway and influencing factors of hydrogen energy storage accommodating renewable energy growth

Hydrogen energy is considered an important energy storage mode with medium- and long-term cross-seasonal storage capabilities in scenarios with high penetration of renewable energy (RE). However, there is a lack of research regarding the appropriate scale of hydrogen energy storage (HES) considering different RE power generation scenarios. In response to this gap, the present study aims to establish a power system simulation model to analyze the development pathway of HES while accommodating RE growth with a minimum cost constraint for a power system operation. The impacts of carbon trading prices, advances in HES technology, and RE resource endowment on HES development are also investigated. The findings indicate that the total available solar energy resources in China are 46.94TW, and the total available wind energy resources are 9.52TW. When the share of RE generation reaches 44.33–54.78 % of total power generation, the utilization of HES for balancing power system is advantageous in reducing the overall system costs. Looking ahead to 2060, the year when China is projected to achieve its carbon-neutrality goal, RE is estimated to reach 63.12–91.1 % of total power generation. Consequently, the HES in each province is estimated to contribute to 3.58–18.02 % of total electricity consumption. Provinces with more abundant wind resources relative to solar resources are expected to have a 36.43 % higher demand for HES.

A smart parametrisation for robust adaptive PI controller applied on renewable energy power generation systems under weak and uttermost weak grid conditions

The increasing penetration of renewable energy systems into the global energy matrix is a necessity for sustainable development. The benefits impact the well-being of humanity and the environment directly. However, these power generation systems demand reliable controllers to regulate the current injection into the electrical grid. Therefore, this paper presents a smart parametrisation for a robust adaptive proportional integral controller applied to grid-injected current control of a voltage inverter source with an LCL filter. Controller parameter optimisation and the initialisation of their gains are performed using the particle swarm optimisation algorithm. Three cost functions are assessed on controller parametrisation, considering the current tracking error minimisation and control action limitations: integral of absolute error (IAE) + integral of absolute control action (IAU), integral of square error (ISE) + IAU, and integral of the time-weighted absolute error (ITAE) + IAU. A framework for performance analysis and an in-depth discussion are presented, providing a systematic decision-support methodology for controller configuration. The function determined as the best one is implemented experimentally and compared with a designer’s experience-based robust adaptive proportional integral controller using a hardware-in-the-loop test bench, where the improvements in controller performance are corroborated, contributing to the enhancement of energy quality in renewable energy systems. In addition, the controller’s robustness is evaluated on a weak grid and an uttermost weak grid, where it presents high robustness and global stability.

Integrated energy system evaluation and optimization based on integrated evaluation model and time-series optimization

Against the backdrop of global attention to climate change and environmental sustainability, the development timing and comprehensive cost of regional renewable energy power generation projects have become a focus of attention. By constructing effective models to evaluate them, it can help promote the healthy development of renewable energy projects. The research aims to quantitatively evaluate the development status of local renewable energy projects by constructing a comprehensive evaluation model, minimize information loss, and improve the accuracy of evaluation results. This study adopted a comprehensive evaluation model that combines Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) based on accelerated genetic algorithm, entropy weight method, and ideal point method. Firstly, the subjective weights of the development evaluation indicators for regional renewable energy power generation projects are calculated. Secondly, the entropy weight method is used to analyze the trend of each indicator and obtain objective weights. Finally, combined with the objective weights and the evaluation results calculated using the TOPSIS method, a comprehensive evaluation of renewable energy power generation projects in various regions is conducted. Through analysis, the core indicators of the development level of renewable energy power generation projects in various regions show specific performance, such as Hebei’s evaluation value of 0.4945 in the proportion of comprehensive energy development, and Inner Mongolia’s evaluation value of 0.4045 in the proportion of comprehensive energy installed capacity. Meanwhile, genetic optimization methods exhibit significant advantages in the calculation of optimization schemes compared to dynamic programming methods, possessing strong global search capabilities and high-precision solutions. This study provides a new research method and approach for the evaluation of regional renewable energy power generation projects, demonstrating the practical value and certain advantages of the research method.

Simulation of Small-Scale Solar Power Generation System in The Central Java Region: A Case Study of the Cilacap Area

The limitations of conventional non-renewable energy resources raise concerns about sustainability and energy supply security in the future. One of the worrying factors is the carbon dioxide emissions that can affect living organisms' health. Renewable energy sources, such as solar, wind, and hydropower, emerge as solutions capable of minimizing environmental impacts and reducing dependence on limited resources. Therefore, this research will simulate and design a small-scale renewable energy power generation system, particularly solar energy, in the Cilacap region, Central Java. The main components involved in this research include PV arrays, IGBT diodes, and universal bridges, supported by supporting elements such as displays, scopes, resistors, capacitors, inductors, and bus selectors. The technical data used as input are specific to the area. The simulation results show that the direct power generated by one modelled PV array is 221.7 W per hour. This research contributes to optimising small-scale solar power generation systems in the designated area, considering relevant components and parameters to enhance efficiency and sustainability.

Research on Fast Frequency Response Control Strategy of Hydrogen Production Systems

With the large-scale integration of intermittent renewable energy generation presented by wind and photovoltaic power, the security and stability of power system operations have been challenged. Therefore, this article proposes a control strategy of a hydrogen production system based on renewable energy power generation to enable the fast frequency response of a grid. Firstly, based on the idea of virtual synchronous control, a fast frequency response control transformation strategy for the grid-connected interface of hydrogen production systems for renewable energy power generation is proposed to provide active power support when the grid frequency is disturbed. Secondly, based on the influence of VSG’s inertia and damping coefficient on the dynamic characteristics of the system, a VSG adaptive control model based on particle swarm optimization is designed. Finally, based on the Matlab/Simulink platform, a grid-connected simulation model of hydrogen production systems for renewable energy power generation is established. The results show that the interface-transformed electrolytic hydrogen production device can actively respond to the frequency disturbances of the power system and participate in primary frequency control, providing active support for the frequency stability of the power system under high-percentage renewable energy generation integration. Moreover, the system with parameter optimization has better fast frequency response control characteristics.

Evaluation of the Environmental Impact and Energy Utilization Efficiency of Wastewater Treatment Plants in Tumen River Basin Based on a Life Cycle Assessment + Data Envelopment Analysis Model

The environmental impacts from energy consumption account for a high percentage of the environmental impacts of wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) throughout their life cycle; therefore, controlling energy use in WWTPs could bring substantial benefits to the environment. In this study, according to the different percentages of electricity generation from renewable energy compared to fossil energy, the global warming, acidification, eutrophication, human toxicity, and photochemical smog, the environmental impacts of WWTP operation were considered. Furthermore, to explore a more sustainable way of operating WWTPs under the “dual-carbon” strategic decision, the environmental impacts and energy utilization efficiency of different power allocation scenarios at present and in the next 40 years were compared based on the LCA+DEA integrated model. The study revealed that in scenarios 1–5, as the proportion of renewable energy power generation gradually increased, all LCA results showed a gradual decrease, of which GWP decreased by 83.32% and human toxicity decreased by 93.34%. However, in scenarios 2–5, the contribution ratio (proportion) of gas and electricity to GWP and POCP gradually increased, reaching 77.11% and 59.44%, respectively, in scenario 5. The contribution ratio (proportion) of biomass generation to AP and EP gradually increased as well, reaching 65.22% and 68.75%, respectively, in scenario 5. Meanwhile, the combined technical efficiency in energy utilization in the five scenarios showed a decreasing trend; only scenario 1 was fully efficient, and the combined efficiency was 1. The values of combined technical efficiency in scenarios 2, 3, 4, and 5 gradually decreased and were 0.7386, 0.4771, 0.2967, and 0.1673, respectively. This study discusses whether the use of renewable energy in place of fossil energy power elicits an environmental impact in WWTPs. We explore the feasibility of achieving energy savings and emission reductions in WWTPs within the Tumen River Basin, to provide a theoretical basis for their sustainable development.

Analysis and Design of CUK-SEPIC-based Converter for Hybrid Power Generation Systems

Background: The increasing demand for electricity, coupled with an imbalanced supply and demand, population growth, and climate change, has prompted the shift from conventional to non-conventional energy systems. However, the unreliability and intermittency of the latter pose a challenge to their feasibility. To address this challenge, a proposal has been made to explore the combination of two renewable energy sources (RES) using a unique DC-DC converter topology, with the aim of meeting the load demand in a sustainable and efficient manner. Objective: The focus of this research was to explore solutions for the challenges associated with operating RES independently, including issues with intermittency, weather dependence, and meeting load demands. The proposed hybrid system features exclusively RES, offering a promising approach to reducing carbon footprint. Ultimately, we aimed to develop a CUK-SEPIC-based converter that can effectively integrate two independent RES to satisfy the load demand of a standalone application. Method: Effective hybrid power generation through RES is a complex challenge, but it has been found that combining solar and biomass energy sources is one of the best options for achieving this goal. To tap into these sources, it is essential to have a suitable power electronic converter, and the CUK-SEPIC converter has been chosen for its many benefits. The features of this converter have been described in detail. The integration of solar and biomass energy sources is achieved using this converter, which has been designed and mathematically modeled in the MATLAB/Simulink environment to ensure optimal performance. To validate the effectiveness of the proposed converter, a comparison with existing power electronic converters has been done using the MATLAB/Simulink platform. Results: The hybrid power generation system model has been comprehensively developed in this work using the sophisticated MATLAB/Simulink environment. The input and output parameters have been diligently estimated through an extensive simulation process. The research has yielded valuable insights, indicating that the CUK-SEPIC converter exhibits an impressive power conversion efficiency of 96.57%, along with an overall step-up ratio of 5.25 and significantly reduced ripple content. Conclusion: Upon conducting a comprehensive analysis of the CUK-SEPIC DC-DC converter, it has been observed that the proposed system exhibits significant promise in rectifying the reliability issues commonly associated with renewable energy power generation. Therefore, it is recommended that this system be considered for implementation in rural electrification initiatives. Furthermore, it is worth noting that this system represents one of the most recent developments in the field of renewable energy power generation technology.

An overview of wind energy to optimize initial potential in Java

The amount of energy derived from fossil fuels has been dwindling rapidly while its consumption has gradually increased. Indonesia, especially Java and East Nusa Tenggara islands, has excellent potential for developing renewable energy and an environmentally friendly economy. One of the more comprehensive energy resources is wind, which can provide renewable resources because it is renewable, widespread, and abundant. Wind energy can be used as an alternative energy material instead of fossil fuels in power generation systems. This article explores the potential of wind energy as a renewable energy source in Java through a literature study. Data was collected by collecting references from nationally and internationally reputable indexed books and journals related to the topic and government website platforms, reports and other relevant sources. The results showed that wind energy in several areas of Java Island has the potential to become renewable energy for power generation. The benefits of renewable energy can outweigh the drawbacks.

A Novel Non-Isolated Cubic DC-DC Converter with High Voltage Gain for Renewable Energy Power Generation System

A Novel Non-Isolated Cubic DC-DC Converter with High Voltage Gain for Renewable Energy Power Generation System

Identification of Hydrogen-Energy-Related Emerging Technologies Based on Text Mining

As a versatile energy carrier, hydrogen possesses tremendous potential to reduce greenhouse emissions and promote energy transition. Global interest in producing hydrogen from renewable energy sources and transporting, storing, and utilizing hydrogen is rising rapidly. However, the high costs of producing clean hydrogen and the uncertain application scenarios for hydrogen energy result in its relatively limited utilization worldwide. It is necessary to find new promising technological paths to drive the development of hydrogen energy. As part of technological innovation, emerging technologies have vital features such as prominent impact, novelty, relatively fast growth, etc. Identifying emerging hydrogen-energy-related technologies is important for discovering innovation opportunities during the energy transition. Existing research lacks analysis of the characteristics of emerging technologies. Thus, this paper proposes a method combining the latent Dirichlet allocation topic model and hydrogen-energy expert group decision-making. This is used to identify emerging hydrogen-related technology regarding two features of emerging technologies, novelty and prominent impact. After data processing, topic modeling, and analysis, the patent dataset was divided into twenty topics. Six emerging topics possess novelty and prominent impact among twenty topics. The results show that the current hotspots aim to promote the application of hydrogen energy by improving the performance of production catalysts, overcoming the wide power fluctuations and large-scale instability of renewable energy power generation, and developing advanced hydrogen safety technologies. This method efficiently identifies emerging technologies from patents and studies their development trends. It fills a gap in the research on emerging technologies in hydrogen-related energy. Research achievements could support the selection of technology pathways during the low-carbon energy transition.

STUDI POTENSI PLTS ATAP DI MAKASSAR UNTUK MENINGKATKAN PENGGUNAAN ENERGI TERBARUKAN DAN MENGURANGI EMISI KARBON

Indonesia is located below the equator and has high exposure to sunlight throughout the year, providing great potential for generating electrical energy from solar sources. The demand for electrical energy in Indonesia continues to increase every year, so that it is very important to take advantage of the abundant potential of solar energy to become a source of renewable energy for power generation. This study focuses on analyzing the potential and effectiveness of using solar power and the challenges in its use, especially in the Makassar area. Solar power can generate up to 112,000 GWp of electricity or the equivalent of 89,600,000 MW. One of the challenges faced in using solar panels is the high material and installation costs, as well as people's dependence on conventional electricity. The Indonesian government has set a target to obtain 23% of the total electricity capacity from renewable energy sources by 2025. One solution is to use a rooftop solar system which can directly convert solar radiation into electrical energy. The energy generated from the Rooftop PLTS system can be stored in a battery that is controlled by a regulator and used at night. The use of on-grid PLTS or Rooftop PLTS can provide the advantage of saving PLN's electricity by 39.9% to 110.5%. It can be concluded that using energy from solar panels in a month can produce carbon gas emissions by 3.3% or carbon gas emissions are reduced by up to 96.7%.

Examining the multiple impacts of renewable energy development on redefined energy security in China: A panel quantile regression approach

The increasing generation of renewable energy and its concurrent technological innovation are driving the transformations of the energy sector, but little effort has been made at the regional level to specify the heterogeneous impacts of different types of renewable energy development on multi-dimensional energy security. Therefore, this paper establishes a four-dimensional energy security assessment system based on the current energy market situation and economic context of China. Renewable energy generation and technological innovation were simultaneously used as the core proxies for renewable energy development. Then, the panel quantile regression method was used to analyze the heterogeneity of the impact of solar, hydro, and wind energy on energy security, covering 30 provinces in China from 2006 to 2019. The empirical results show that renewable energy power generation generally promotes energy security, but it cannot be effectively applicable to all levels of energy security. Renewable energy technology innovation has surprisingly hindered energy security. These results can serve as a policy and practical guide, suggesting that provincial governments in China should implement energy security and renewable energy policies in line with local characteristics.

Does the change in incentive policies promote renewable energy power generation in China?

ABSTRACT To reduce the financial burden brought by the feed-in tariff (FIT) policy, China is shifting its renewable energy support policy to the renewable portfolio standard with tradable green certificates (RPS/TGC). Moreover, the two policies are being implemented in parallel in the transitional period. In this context, this study investigates the game between renewable energy power plants (REPPs) regarding electricity outputs and tradable green certificate (TGC) prices under different renewable energy support policies practiced in China. We focus on analyzing the impact of policy changes on the competing REPPs’ decisions and the renewable electricity market with TGCs. The results show that implementing the RPS/TGC policy inhibits the development of renewable electricity unless the subscription of TGCs is promoted. Government subsidy arrears significantly affect electricity outputs and TGC subscriptions. The low subscription rate of TGCs is caused not by the subsidy-based TGC pricing mechanism but by government subsidies. This suggests that the government should implement the RPS/TGC policy, and demand-side power consumption responsibility weights should also be strengthened to promote TGC subscriptions.