Influence of the pouring temperature ranging from 680 to 780 °C on the solidification behavior, the microstructure and mechanical properties of the sand-cast Mg−10Gd−3Y−0.4Zr alloy was investigated. It was found that the nucleation undercooling of the α-Mg phase increased from 2.3 to 6.3 °C. The average α-Mg grain size increased from 44 to 71 μm, but then decreased to 46 μm. The morphology of the eutectic compound transformed from a continuous network into a discontinuous state and then subsequently into an island-like block. The volume fraction of β-Mg24RE5 phase increased and its morphology transformed from particle into rod-like. The increase in pouring temperature increased the solute concentration. YS increased from 138 to 151 MPa, and UTS increased from 186 to 197 MPa. The alloy poured at 750 °C had optimal combining strength and ductility. The fracture surface mode transformed from quasi-cleavage crack into transgranular fracture, all plus the dimple-like fracture, with the micro-porosity and the re-oxidation inclusion as major defects. The average α-Mg grain size played a main role in the YS of sand-cast Mg−10Gd−3Y−0.4Zr alloy, besides other factors, i.e. micro-porosity, morphology of eutectic compounds, re-oxidation inclusion and solute concentration.