Similar to the anterior cruciate ligament, the femoral footprint of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) is composed of different fibre areas, possibly having distinct biomechanical functions. The aim of this study was to determine the role of different fibre areas of the femoral footprint of the PCL in restraining posterior tibial translation (PTT). A sequential cutting study was performed on eight fresh-frozen human knee specimens, utilizing a six-degrees-of-freedom robotic test setup. The femoral attachment of the PCL was divided into 15 areas, which were sequentially cut from the bone in a randomized sequence. After determining the native knee kinematics, a displacement-controlled protocol was performed replaying the native motion, while constantly measuring the force. The reduction of the restraining force presented the percentage contribution of each cut, according to the principle of superposition. The PCL was found to contribute 29 ± 16% in 0°, 51 ± 24% in 30°, 60 ± 22% in 60° and 55 ± 18% in 90°, to restricting a PTT. The fibre areas contributing the most were located at the proximal border of the PCL footprint, away from the cartilage, and directly adjacent to the medial intercondylar ridge (p < 0.05). Of these, one fibre area showed the highest contribution at all flexion angles. This area was located at the posterior half of the medial intercondylar ridge. No clear assignment of the areas to either the anterolateral or posteromedial bundle was possible. An area towards the proximal and posterior part of the femoral PCL footprint was found to significantly restrain a posterior tibial force. Based on the data of this testing setup, a PCL graft positioned at the identified area may best mimic the part of the native PCL, which bears the most load in resisting a PTT force. No evidence level (laboratory study).