HISTORY - A 23-year-old senior male basketball player for a Division I university landed after an attempted blocked shot and felt intense pain over the posterior-lateral aspect of his knee. He did not feel a pop or have complaints of instability. He had no previous history of knee pain or injury. The fifth year senior wanted to complete his final season if possible. PHYSICAL EXAM - The athlete was evaluated at courtside by the athletic trainer and in the training room by the team physician. His primary complaint was of pain and inability to fully extend his knee. Range of motion was 15°-60° limited by pain. No gross effusion was present. He was focally tender over the posterior lateral joint line. Ligamentous stability appeared to be intact with a negative Lachman's, negative posterior sag, negative external rotation recurvatum, and negative laxity to varus and valgus stress at 0° and 30°. McMurray's examination instituted pain laterally but was not complete secondary to limited range of motion. DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS: Lateral meniscus tear, 2. Posterior-lateral complex injury, 3. Popliteal tendon rupture, 4. Lateral collateral ligament strain, 5. Fracture or bone bruise. TEST AND RESULTS: Plain radiographs were negative for fracture or bony pathology. Magnetic resonance imaging revealed a peripheral tear of the entire posterior horn of the lateral meniscus and Grade I changes in the lateral collateral ligament and posterior lateral complex. FINAL DIAGNOSIS: After review of the test results with the athlete, his family, and his athletic trainer, he was taken to surgery for arthroscopy of his knee. A large bucket handle tear of his posterior meniscus was identified locked in the intercondylar notch. The unstable fragment comprised 60-70% of his entire meniscus and 100% of his posterior horn. Meniscal repair was selected over meniscectomy due to the peripheral nature and overwhelming size of the tear. An accelerated aggressive rehabilitation allowing full weight-bearing and full range of motion immediately was instituted. However, he was restricted from twisting and cutting activities for two months. TREATMENT: While meniscus tears are not an uncommon injury in elite athletes, they do present a difficult dilemma in recommendation and treatment options for coaches, athletic trainers, team physicians, and orthopaedic surgeons. This case notes an athlete playing in his final collegiate season who is an important cog in his team's success. The player, coach, athletic trainer, and physician all would like to have the athlete back as soon as possible which would imply partial meniscectomy. Nonetheless, due to the likelihood of early degenerative arthritis with a nearly complete meniscectomy, a meniscal repair with its associated longer rehabilitation would best serve this patient in the long run.
Read full abstract