HISTORY: An 18 year-old softball catcher presenting with a 3 year history of left progressive postero-lateral knee discomfort with associated knee locking when squatting or deep knee flexion. Onset was 3 years ago when she was in a squat position during a softball game. She had been avoiding aggravating activities and initially sought medical care 3 months ago, presenting to an orthopedic specialist’s clinic. Following a negative MRI, she was referred to our clinic for diagnostic ultrasound of the knee. She reported no reliable way to reproduce locking, but, when locking does occur, she must manually unlock herself. Previous treatment included 8 weeks of physical therapy without benefit. PHYSICAL EXAMINATION: No discoloration or swelling of the left knee. Non-antalgic gait. Valgus alignment with dynamic valgus on single leg squat. Posterior lateral joint line tenderness. No other focal tenderness. Full and symmetric bilateral knee active range of motion without pain, except in terminal flexion. Negative McMurray’s, cruciate and collateral ligament testing and dial test. 9/9 Beighton criteria. DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS: 1. Meniscocapsular separation 2. Lateral meniscus injury 3. Proximal tibiofibular ligament injury 4. Popliteus muscle/tendon injury 5. Anteriolateral complex sprain 6. PFL injury TEST AND RESULTS: MRI: Subtle irregularity of posterior superior meniscocapsular fascicle deemed secondary to volume-averaging artifact. Otherwise, no discrete pathology was noted. Ultrasound: No discrete lesion of entirety of lateral meniscus on static exam. Development of a separation (3.1mm) between posterior knee capsular tissue and posterior outermost fiber of left lateral meniscus when knee is in near full flexion. FINAL WORKING DIAGNOSIS: left postero-lateral meniscocapsular separation TREATMENT AND OUTCOMES: Management options (expectant management, injection options to mitigate pain, and a surgery) were discussed. Patient elected surgical fixation of lateral meniscus. Arthroscopic fixation of lateral meniscus with 2 vertical mattress sutures using a FasTFix device was performed. After 4 weeks of bracing to allow proper surgical healing, she was able to start using an elliptical at 6 weeks and jogging at 9 weeks. She remains void of pre-surgical pain and locking at 16 weeks post-operatively.