With a focus on transitions in schooling and instructional practice, one would be justified in expecting this book to be an interdisciplinary publication, as transitions are not a field of their own. Rather, researchers in a variety of educational domains–both subject area specialities (e.g., science) and interdisciplinary fields (e.g., educational leadership)–address these topics in their work. Compiling a collection of essays on such a broad topic would understandably be a challenge for any scholar. While the editors did an admirable job with this difficult task, the resulting publication is not without concerns. The editors of this book, Susan E. Elliott and Daniel H. Jarvis, are professors in the Schulich School of Education at Nipissing University in North Bay, Ontario, Canada, and research literacy and mathematics education, respectively. The editors’ research areas and a geographic focus in Canada are reflected in the composition of the book’s chapters. Specifically, this 527-page edited book is comprised of 19 chapters written by 26 authors, as well as an Introduction and a Coda written by the editors. Although the book’s description depicts the authors as international experts, the authors only represent four countries–Australia, Canada, Singapore, and the United States–three of which are culturally very similar. The majority of the contributors are Canadians writing about research in Canadian (more specifically, Ontario) contexts. While this geographic focus is not a problem as such, the description of the book as containing chapters by international experts seems a bit misleading. The chapters are grouped into four sections based on chronological transitions in schooling, which are Part I: Early Years (Home/Preschool/Kindergarten) to Early Elementary (Grades 13); Part II: Early Elementary (Grades 1-3) to Late Elementary (Grades 4-8); Part III: Late Elementary (Grades 4-8) to Secondary (Grades 9-12); and Part IV: Secondary (Grades 9-12) to Postsecondary (College/University). The chapters are unevenly distributed among the four sections, with four, five, seven, and three chapters, respectively. The inclusion of seven chapters about the elementary to secondary school transition is understandable, given its focus in the extant body of literature. However, the dearth of chapters on the secondary to postsecondary school transition was rather surprising, as a great deal of research exists regarding this particular transition in schooling. For example, a search of the ERIC database for “transition to university/college/postsecondary” results in approximately 8,000 results. As will be discussed, one of the chapters in Part IV did not address the secondary to postsecondary school transition, resulting in only two topic-specific chapters, which seems mismatched when compared to the
Read full abstract