Customer portfolio analysis may be useful for improving retailers' attempts to successfully position their stores in the minds of customers. A customer portfolio for a store includes new-primary, loyal-primary, and defector (formerly primary) customers, as well as occasional customers who shop primarily at competing stores. Customers' attitude-accessibilities with respect to first-linking a given store with evaluative attributes may offer useful information about the reasons for the shopping behavior of customers in a store's customer portfolio. We offer several hypotheses related to customer portfolio analysis and store attitude-accessiblity in the present article. The principal hypothesis (H1) examined is that the attitude-accessibility of the major supermarkets competing in the same metropolitan area will differ substantially among loyal, new, competitors' customers, and defector customer segments for each supermarket. More specifically, for a given store, greater shares of loyal and new customers will exhibit positive, store attitude-accessibility profiles compared to noncustomers and defectors (H2). A greater share of customer defectors will exhibit a negative attitude-accessibility profile compared to each of the loyal and new shopper segments (H3). The results of a cross-sectional telephone survey of 317 supermarket shoppers are described, and the findings support these hypotheses. We conclude with recommendations for planning changes in retailing positioning strategies and for monitoring the success of implementing these strategies.