Null models for generating binary phylogenetic trees are useful for testing evolutionary hypotheses and reconstructing phylogenies. We consider two such null models – the Yule and uniform models – and in particular the induced distribution they generate on the number C n of cherries in the tree, where a cherry is a pair of leaves each of which is adjacent to a common ancestor. By realizing the process of cherry formation in these two models by extended Polya urn models we show that C n is asymptotically normal. We also give exact formulas for the mean and standard deviation of the C n in these two models. This allows simple statistical tests for the Yule and uniform null hypotheses.