Despite all recent progresses in nerve tissue engineering, critical-sized nerve defects are still extremely challenging to repair. Therefore, this study targets the bridging of critical nerve defects and promoting an oriented neuronal outgrowth by engineering innovative nerve guidance conduits (NGCs) synergistically possessing exclusive topographical, chemical, and mechanical cues. To do so, a mechanically adequate mixture of polycaprolactone (PCL) and polylactic-co-glycolic acid (PLGA) was first carefully selected as base material to electrospin nanofibrous NGCs simulating the extracellular matrix. The electrospinning process was performed using a newly designed 2-pole air gap collector that leads to a one-step deposition of seamless NGCs having a bilayered architecture with an inner wall composed of highly aligned fibers and an outer wall consisting of randomly oriented fibers. This architecture is envisaged to afford guidance cues for the extension of long neurites on the underlying inner fiber alignment and to concurrently provide a sufficient nutrient supply through the pores of the outer random fibers. The surface chemistry of the NGCs was then modified making use of a hollow cathode discharge (HCD) plasma reactor purposely designed to allow an effective penetration of the reactive species into the NGCs to eventually treat their inner wall. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) results have indeed revealed a successful O2 plasma modification of the inner wall that exhibited a significantly increased oxygen content (24 → 28%), which led to an enhanced surface wettability. The treatment increased the surface nanoroughness of the fibers forming the NGCs as a result of an etching effect. This effect reduced the ultimate tensile strength of the NGCs while preserving their high flexibility. Finally, pheochromocytoma (PC12) cells were cultured on the NGCs to monitor their ability to extend neurites which is the base of a good nerve regeneration. In addition to remarkably improved cell adhesion and proliferation on the plasma-treated NGCs, an outstanding neural differentiation occurred. In fact, PC12 cells seeded on the treated samples extended numerous long neurites eventually establishing a neural network-like morphology with an overall neurite direction following the alignment of the underlying fibers. Overall, PCL/PLGA NGCs electrospun using the 2-pole air gap collector and O2 plasma-treated using an HCD reactor are promising candidates toward a full repair of critical nerve damage.