Reckoning Mande: The Politics of Ethnic and Academic Identity in West Africa and Beyond Joseph Hellweg (bio) Ethnicity: Homogeneity or Multiplicity? The notion of ethnicity has the potential to divide a scholarly community such as ours as much as it has splintered West Africa nation-states. I therefore suggest here that the Mande Studies Association (MANSA), and our journal, Mande Studies, reorient ourselves away from our long-standing, tacit, linguistico-cultural focus to a more geographical one. I do so from my perspective as a researcher who has worked with Manding- and Senufo-speaking dozo hunters in Côte d’Ivoire. I also do so to heed scholarly critiques of the notion of ethnicity in Africa and because I have witnessed the destruction wreaked on Côte d’Ivoire in the name of ethnicity. Considering my colleagues’—and my own— misgivings about the integrity of the concept of “Mande” in Mande Studies, I suggest that changing the names of both MANSA and its journal could reorient our association in productive ways. I propose that we can, as a result, embrace more explicitly the multiple identities that have informed the lives of the people with whom we work. Mande Down in Côte d’Ivoire: The Fall and Rise of Alassane Ouattara Critiques of the notion of ethnicity have featured prominently in African Studies for nearly a century, beginning with Audrey Richard’s (1941) review of [End Page 205] E. E. Evans-Pritchard’s The Nuer and, notably, since Crawford Young’s Politics in Congo (1965), continuing with Johannes Fabian’s Time and the Other (1983), Jean-Loup Amselle and Elikia M’Bokolo’s Au cœur de l’ethnie (1985), Adam Kuper’s Invention of Primitive Society (1988), and Leroy Vail›s (ed.) Creation of Tribalism in Southern Africa (1989). Nonetheless, Akan-speaking, Christian politicians provoked ethnic antagonisms in Côte d’Ivoire in the run-up to the country’s 1995 presidential elections in order to prevent Jula and Muslim candidate Alassane Ouattara from running (Hellweg 2011, 39–45). Ouattara’s opponents portrayed his Mande ethnicity as less than “Ivorian” because of his family’s alleged ties to Jula-speaking populations in Burkina Faso (Cissé 2007, 57–64). This maneuver reflected the emerging ideology of ivoirité or ‘Ivorianess’, a form of nativist nationalism, described below by a biographer of Alassance Ouattara, writing at the time of ivoirité’s heyday in the early 2000s: “Ivorianess” is basically an attempt at fascist ideological conceptualization . . . which leads to separating and stratifying Ivorians into at least two categories: “native or blood Ivorians,” who have all the rights without necessarily the duties that go with them; “circumstantial or impure Ivorians,” having practically no rights, although they bear all the duties linked to their status … [T]his distribution corresponds to no verifiable criteri[a], particularly legal … other than “the long boubou, prayer beads, big beards, peanut sauce, kabatô, etc.,” that characterize northern Ivorians and Muslims. Therefore, origin and religion are the criteria used. (Cissé 2007, 63, my translation)1 This selective marginalization of Muslim, northern-descended populations most benefited the fledgling president, Henri Konan Bédié, who had succeeded Côte d’Ivoire’s founding president and political giant, Félix Houphouët-Boigny, after the latter’s death in 1993. Ivoirité gave Bédié a ready-made political constituency: Ivorian citizens who resented the sizable number of non-Ivorians living in the country—26% of Côte d’Ivoire’s population at the time, most of whom had come from Burkina Faso and Mali to earn a better living on Côte d’Ivoire’s cocoa and coffee plantations and in its cities, ports, and towns. Their presence, in an era of economic downturn for Ivorians, made them easy scapegoats for nationalist resentment (see Dembélé 2002, 126–127, 159–161). In addition to politicians, scholars also championed ivoirité. Two symposia, organized by two different academic associations, even attracted significant media attention: (1) “Ivorianness, or the Spirit of President Henry Konan Bédié’s New Social Contract,” on March 20–23, 1996, organized by the University Research Group for the Propagation of President Henri Konan Bédié’s Political Ideas and Endeavors (CURDIPHE...
Read full abstract