The split in South Africa's ruling National Party (NP) delivered the coup de grace to the traditional image of white South African politics as a contest between Englishand Afrikaans-speakers, but the new conventional wisdoms are hardly more satisfactory. After the myth of the Afrikaner monolith was shown up by the events of February and March 1982, most observers switched from ethnic to ideological analysis, attributing them to the differences in outlook between verligte ('enlightened') and verkrampte ('narrow-minded') Afrikaners. Some on the left wrote off the split as inconsequential, due to the NP's unwavering support for white political control and capitalism. However, both these types of ideological exegesis ultimately offer only another way to describe the split, not an explanation of its origins or significance. While the split was precipitated by disagreements between verligtes and verkramptes over responses to the political and economic crises facing the South African state, its roots lay in a process of class realignment. They can be traced to the evolution of the National Party into a party dominated by the Afrikaner bourgeoisie, who need new strategies and new allies. The split freed the NP to restructure the training, use, and living conditions of black workers, as capital demands, while attempting to broaden the base of the regime. Nevertheless, liberals who viewed the split as a 'step in the right direction' are likely to be disappointed. While the class character of the NP now encourages a degree of economic liberalisation, it still seems to rule out political liberalisation. Although the Afrikaner bourgeoisie shares the interest of English-speaking capitalists in the efficient employment of black labour, it is still too dependent upon state power and patronage to accept genuine power-sharing or majority rule. To justify these claims, this article first examines the class character of the National Party split, and then the struggles which followed it. The conclusion explains why the party's new class base still imposes narrow limits to reform.
Read full abstract