Abstract Despite a recent resurgence of observational studies attempting to quantify the ice-induced attenuation of ocean waves in polar oceans, the physical processes governing this phenomenon are still poorly understood. Most analyses have attempted to relate the spatial rate of wave attenuation to wave frequency, but have not considered how this relationship depends on ice, wave, and atmospheric conditions. An in-depth analysis of the wave-buoy data collected during the 2017 Polynyas, Ice Production, and Seasonal Evolution in the Ross Sea (PIPERS) program in the Ross Sea is conducted. Standard techniques are used to estimate the spatial rate of wave attenuation α, and the influence of a number of potential physical drivers on its dependence on wave period T is investigated. A power law is shown to consistently describe the α(T) relationship, in line with other recent analyses. The two parameters describing this relationship are found to depend significantly on sea ice concentration, mean wave period, and wind direction, however. Looking at cross correlations between these physical drivers, three regimes of ice-induced wave attenuation are identified, which characterize different ice, wave, and wind conditions, and very possibly different processes causing this observed attenuation. This analysis suggests that parameterizations of ice-induced wave decay in spectral wave models should be piecewise, so as to include their dependence on local ice, wave, and wind conditions. Significance Statement This work attempts to quantify how ice, wave, and wind conditions in polar oceans affect the way that ocean waves decay as a result of their interactions with sea ice. In situ wave data collected in the Ross Sea are analyzed along with several freely available ice, wave, and wind datasets. A simple relationship is shown to describe how wave attenuation due to sea ice depends on the wave period consistently across all data analyzed. However, the parameters of this relationship are significantly affected by sea ice concentration, mean wave period, and wind direction. This finding suggests that large-scale wave models need to account for this dependence on ice, wave, and wind conditions to improve wave forecast in ice-covered oceans.