pMHC Ligands Research Articles

Energetic Impact of Individual Peptide Residues on Binding by High-Affinity TCRs: Implications for Antigen Specificity (93.17)

Abstract The mouse CD8+ clone 2C recognizes the syngeneic pMHC ligand SIYR:Kb and the allogeneic pMHC ligand QL9:Ld. High-affinity mutants of the 2C TCR have been generated previously against these ligands by directed evolution using yeast display. In order to generate specific probes for the detection of these pMHC ligands, we have developed a strategy to express high-affinity TCRs that are biotinylated in vivo in E. coli. The biotinylated TCRs and a collection of single amino acid variants of peptides SIYR and QL9 were used to quantitate relative energy contributions of each peptide residue to TCR binding. Generation of a quantitative binding energy map allowed comparison of two structurally very different MHC (Kb versus Ld) that bind to the same TCR. The energetic contributions of different residues from the peptides SIYR and QL9 were distinct. Analysis of QL9:Ld showed that four central positions of peptide QL9 contributed a significant amount of binding free energy to both wild type and high-affinity TCRs. Analysis of SIYR:Kb showed that there are distinct differences, compared to QL9:Ld, in recognition by the same family of mutated TCRs. Using crystal structures of TCR/QL9:Ld and TCR/SIYR:Kb complexes, it was possible to assess whether binding energies were influenced directly through contacts with the TCR, or indirectly through peptide induced conformational changes in the peptide or MHC. Supported by grants from the NIH.

Monomeric Agonist pMHC Ligand Triggers TCR Signaling Independent of Endogenous Ligand (87.31)

Abstract At the contact interface between T-cell and antigen presenting cell (APC), peptide antigen presented by MHC (pMHC) binds to T-cell receptor (TCR) and initiates signaling. The mechanism of TCR signal initiation, or triggering, remains unclear. A critical yet controversial issue is whether monomeric agonist pMHC is sufficient to trigger TCR, or if simultaneous engagement of TCRs by two pMHCs is required. Here, we show that CD4+ T-cells are triggered by very low numbers of monomeric agonist pMHCs anchored on fluid planar lipid bilayers. T-cells responded to bilayer-anchored agonist MCC-IEk in a sub-linear fashion, further indicating the sufficiency of monovalent ligand. Moreover, on bilayers, fixed plastic surfaces, or live APCs, endogenous pMHC did not enhance TCR triggering by agonist pMHC. Therefore, agonist pMHCs trigger TCR as individual monomers, independent of endogenous pMHC, supporting a model of TCR triggering by conformational change or kinetic segregation, and not via pMHC pseudodimers.

The Stimulatory Potency of T Cell Antigens Is Influenced by the Formation of the Immunological Synapse

T cell activation is predicated on the interaction between the T cell receptor and peptide-major histocompatibility (pMHC) ligands. The factors that determine the stimulatory potency of a pMHC molecule remain unclear. We describe results showing that a peptide exhibiting many hallmarks of a weak agonist stimulates T cells to proliferate more than the wild-type agonist ligand. An in silico approach suggested that the inability to form the central supramolecular activation cluster (cSMAC) could underlie the increased proliferation. This conclusion was supported by experiments that showed that enhancing cSMAC formation reduced stimulatory capacity of the weak peptide. Our studies highlight the fact that a complex interplay of factors determines the quality of a T cell antigen.

Comparison of CDR3 length among thymocyte subpopulations: Impacts of MHC and BV segment on the CDR3 shortening

Thymocytes are thought to be selected on the basis of antigen specificity between TCR and peptide-MHC (pMHC) ligands. The specificity depends primarily on extensive diversities of complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3), whose specificity is considered to be determined through thymocyte selection. We examined the CDR3 length profiles with 20 BV segments in thymocyte subpopulations from C57BL/6 (H-2 b), C.B10 (Balb/c congenic, H-2 b) and Balb/c (H-2 d) mice. The CDR3 length was shorter in both CD4 single positive (SP) and CD8SP than in double positive (DP), but not altered among DP, double negative (DN) 4 and DN3 subpopulations. The CDR3 shortened more prominently in CD4SP than in CD8SP for C57BL/6 and C.B10, but the shortening was only slight for Balb/c. Although the shortening varied considerably among different BV segments, the greater shortening was observed in most BV segments for CD4SP and in several for CD8SP, in particular, the extent was the greatest in BV1, BV2, BV15, BV16, BV23 and BV26 for CD4SP, and in BV13-1 and BV29 for CD8SP. Moreover, the extent and the pattern of CDR3 shortening were basically the same among highly homologous BV segments (e.g. BV12-1 and 12-2; BV13-1, 13-2 and 13-3). These results taken together indicate that (1) the CDR3 shortening occurred between the DP to the SP stages but never earlier, that (2) there would be the MHC class preference for the CDR3 shortening, that (3) it was in part influenced by MHC haplotype, and finally that (4) the primary structure of particular BV segments would possibly affect the CDR3 length in selected thymocytes. It could be deduced from these results that the CDR3 shortening might play roles in ensuring geometrical disposition of CDRs unique to each BV segment and consequently allow CDRs to intimately interact with pMHC ligands.

Altered Peptide Ligands Induce Delayed CD8-T Cell Receptor Interaction—a Role for CD8 in Distinguishing Antigen Quality

How T cells translate T cell receptor (TCR) recognition of almost identical pMHC ligands into distinct biological responses has remained enigmatic. Although differences in affinity or off rate are important, they offer at best an incomplete explanation. By using Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), we have visualized the ligand-induced interaction between OT-I TCR and CD8. We found that both recruitment of TCR to the immunological synapse and the TCR-CD8 interaction induced by weak agonists (positive-selecting ligands) was delayed but not necessarily weaker than strong agonists (negative selectors). A delayed and perhaps longer lasting CD8-TCR interaction results in delayed phospho-ERK recruitment to the synapse. The kinetics of the TCR-CD8 interaction can reconcile previously anomalous data, where biological activity did not correlate with TCR-pMHC binding kinetics for certain ligands. Our findings indicate that the T cell translates antigen recognition into T cell responses by differential recruitment of CD8 to the TCR.

Modeling T cell antigen discrimination based on feedback control of digital ERK responses.

T-lymphocyte activation displays a remarkable combination of speed, sensitivity, and discrimination in response to peptide–major histocompatibility complex (pMHC) ligand engagement of clonally distributed antigen receptors (T cell receptors or TCRs). Even a few foreign pMHCs on the surface of an antigen-presenting cell trigger effective signaling within seconds, whereas 1 × 105–1 × 106 self-pMHC ligands that may differ from the foreign stimulus by only a single amino acid fail to elicit this response. No existing model accounts for this nearly absolute distinction between closely related TCR ligands while also preserving the other canonical features of T-cell responses. Here we document the unexpected highly amplified and digital nature of extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) activation in T cells. Based on this observation and evidence that competing positive- and negative-feedback loops contribute to TCR ligand discrimination, we constructed a new mathematical model of proximal TCR-dependent signaling. The model made clear that competition between a digital positive feedback based on ERK activity and an analog negative feedback involving SH2 domain-containing tyrosine phosphatase (SHP-1) was critical for defining a sharp ligand-discrimination threshold while preserving a rapid and sensitive response. Several nontrivial predictions of this model, including the notion that this threshold is highly sensitive to small changes in SHP-1 expression levels during cellular differentiation, were confirmed by experiment. These results combining computation and experiment reveal that ligand discrimination by T cells is controlled by the dynamics of competing feedback loops that regulate a high-gain digital amplifier, which is itself modulated during differentiation by alterations in the intracellular concentrations of key enzymes. The organization of the signaling network that we model here may be a prototypic solution to the problem of achieving ligand selectivity, low noise, and high sensitivity in biological responses.

RNA Transfer by Electroporation into Mature Dendritic Cells Leading to Reactivation of Effector-Memory Cytotoxic T Lymphocytes: A Quantitative Analysis

Previous studies have analyzed transfer of RNA-encoded tumor-associated antigens (TAAs) into immature dendritic cells (DCs) because of their exceptional ability to internalize antigens. Concerns have been raised regarding the use of immature DCs in clinical studies because of their capacity to tolerize T cells. Therefore, we focused on optimizing RNA transfer into mature DCs using the method of electroporation and obtained high protein expression in 90% of mature DCs. Particular emphasis was placed on quantifying RNA transfer. Reconstitution of peptide–MHC (pMHC) ligands on RNA-pulsed DCs was measured with the help of effector-memory cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) specific for the melanoma-associated antigens tyrosinase and mutated cyclin-dependent kinase 4. In contrast to single-species RNA, transfer of native tumor-derived RNA or amplified tumor RNA into DCs resulted in very low or no capacity to reactivate these CTLs. A correlation was found between TAA message levels in tumor-derived RNA and pMHC ligand reconstitution on DCs. These results demonstrate that even TAAs with highly immunogenic mutated epitopes are not necessarily transferred when tumor-derived RNA is transfected into the DCs, thereby resulting in a lack of DC capacity to reactivate some preexisting effector-memory CTLs.

T cell receptor binding kinetics required for T cell activation depend on the density of cognate ligand on the antigen-presenting cell

CD8(+) T cells recognize peptides of eight to nine amino acid residues long in the context of MHC class I molecules on the surface of antigen-presenting cells (APCs). This recognition event is highly sensitive, as evidenced by the fact that T cells can be activated by cognate peptide/MHC complex (pMHC) at extremely low densities (1-50 molecules). High sensitivity is particularly valuable for detection of antigens at low density, such as those derived from tumor cells and intracellular pathogens, which can down-modulate cognate pMHCs from the surface of APCs to evade recognition by the adaptive immune system. T cell activation is only triggered in response to interactions between the T cell receptor (TCR) and the pMHC ligand that reach a specific half-life threshold. However, interactions with excessively long half-lives result in impaired T cell activation. Thus, efficient T cell activation by pMHC on the surface of APCs requires an optimal dwell time of TCR-pMHC interaction. Here, we show that, although this is a requirement at low cognate pMHC density on the APC surface, at high epitope density there is no impairment of T cell activation by extended TCR-pMHC dwell times. This observation was predicted by mathematical simulations for T cell activation by pMHC at different densities and supported by experiments performed on APCs selected for varied expression of cognate pMHC. According to these results, effective T cell activation depends on a complex interplay between inherent TCR-pMHC binding kinetics and the epitope density on the APC.

T cell receptor engagement by peptide–MHC ligands induces a conformational change in the CD3 complex of thymocytes

The T cell receptor (TCR) can recognize a variety of cognate peptide/major histocompatibility complex (pMHC) ligands and translate their affinity into distinct cellular responses. To achieve this, the nonsignaling αβ heterodimer communicates ligand recognition to the CD3 signaling subunits by an unknown mechanism. In thymocytes, we found that both positive- and negative-selecting pMHC ligands expose a cryptic epitope in the CD3 complex upon TCR engagement. This conformational change is induced in vivo and requires the expression of cognate MHC. We conclude that TCR engagement with a cognate pMHC ligand induces a conformational change in the CD3 complex of thymocytes and propose that this marks an initial event during thymic selection that signals the recognition of self-antigen.

Antibody Specific for the Peptide·Major Histocompatibility Complex: IS IT T CELL RECEPTOR-LIKE?

Antibodies recognizing peptide bound to a major histocompatibility complex (MHC) protein usually have a higher affinity for the composite peptide.MHC (pMHC) ligand than T cell receptors (TCR) with the same specificity. Because the solvent-accessible peptide area constitutes only a small portion of the contacting pMHC surface, we hypothesized that the contribution of the MHC moiety to the TCR-pMHC complex stability is limited, ensuring a small increment of the binding energy delivered by the peptide to be distinguishable by the TCR or the peptide-specific antibody. This suggests that the gain in affinity of the antibody-pMHC interaction can be achieved through an increase in the on-rate without a significant change in the off-rate of the interaction. To test the hypothesis, we have analyzed the binding of an ovalbumin peptide (pOV8) and its variants associated with soluble H-2Kb protein to the 25-D1.16 monoclonal antibody and compared it with the binding of the same pMHC complexes to the OT-1 TCR. This comparison revealed a substantially higher on-rate of the antibody-pMHC interaction compared with the TCR-pMHC interaction. In contrast, both the antibody and the TCR-pMHC complexes exhibited comparably fast off-rates. Sequencing of the 25-D1.16 VH and VL genes showed that they have very few somatic mutations and those occur mainly in framework regions. We propose that the above features constitute a signature of the recognition of MHC-bound peptide antigens by TCR and TCR-like antibodies, which could explain why the latter are rarely produced in vivo.

Degenerate recognition of T cell epitopes: impact of T cell receptor reserve and stability of peptide:MHC complexes

The concept of molecular mimicry suggests that microbial pathogens might activate antigen-specific T cells that then cross-react with endogenous antigens and result in the generation of autoimmunity. Here we discuss several under-represented factors impacting the ability of TCRs to recognize a wide spectrum of related peptide:MHC (pMHC) ligands. Two of these factors include the affinity of the peptide for MHC and the level of TCR expression. Thymocytes that recognize peptides with low affinity for MHC avoid negative selection, but mature T cells, by virtue of increased TCR expression, will proliferate in response to these same unstable pMHC complexes. While the expression of a reserve of antigen receptors expands the potential number of epitopes for which a T cell can cross-react, phosphatase activity provides a tuning mechanism to increase the threshold level of activation. Thus, degenerate recognition of T cell epitopes involves the stability of the peptide:MHC complex, the number of TCR expressed, and the level of phosphatase activity.

Linking molecular and cellular events in T-cell activation and synapse formation

The complex sequence of events in which T cells recognize foreign entities on other cells is not well understood. However, the development of new techniques and approaches in both the molecular and cellular aspects of this problem have provided significant insights into the mechanisms of T-cell recognition and synapse formation. In particular, we have a clearer picture of T-cell sensitivity, the role of co-stimulation in formation of the immunological synapse, and how TCR signaling acts to maintain synapse structure and potentiate the T cells over many hours of engagement. We also are aware of new complexities in the way T-cell receptor molecules bind peptide-MHC (pMHC) ligands and what that may mean for TCR scanning, cross-reactivity, and activation. Ultimately, we want to integrate these cellular aspects of T-cell recognition with key features of the molecular interactions that drive specific events.

Sensory adaptation in naive peripheral CD4 T cells.

T cell receptor interactions with peptide/major histocompatibility complex (pMHC) ligands control the selection of T cells in the thymus as well as their homeostasis in peripheral lymphoid organs. Here we show that pMHC contact modulates the expression of CD5 by naive CD4 T cells in a process that requires the continued expression of p56(lck). Reduced CD5 levels in T cells deprived of pMHC contact are predictive of elevated Ca(2)+ responses to subsequent TCR engagement by anti-CD3 or nominal antigen. Adaptation to peripheral pMHC contact may be important for regulating naive CD4 T cell responsiveness.

Directed evolution of a stable scaffold for T-cell receptor engineering.

Here we have constructed a single-chain T-cell receptor (scTCR) scaffold with high stability and soluble expression efficiency by directed evolution and yeast surface display. We evolved scTCRs in parallel for either enhanced resistance to thermal denaturation at 46 degrees C, or improved intracellular processing at 37 degrees C, with essentially equivalent results. This indicates that the efficiency of the consecutive kinetic processes of membrane translocation, protein folding, quality control, and vesicular transport can be well predicted by the single thermodynamic parameter of thermal stability. Selected mutations were recombined to create an scTCR scaffold that was stable for over an hour at 65 degrees C, had solubility of over 4 mg ml(-1), and shake-flask expression levels of 7.5 mg l(-1), while retaining specific ligand binding to peptide-major histocompatibility complexes (pMHCs) and bacterial superantigen. These properties are comparable to those for stable single-chain antibodies, but are markedly improved over existing scTCR constructs. Availability of this scaffold allows engineering of high-affinity soluble scTCRs as antigen-specific antagonists of cell-mediated immunity. Moreover, yeast displaying the scTCR formed specific conjugates with antigen-presenting cells (APCs), which could allow development of novel cell-to-cell selection strategies for evolving scTCRs with improved binding to various pMHC ligands in situ.

The crystal structure of a T cell receptor in complex with peptide and MHC class II.

The crystal structure of a complex involving the D10 T cell receptor (TCR), 16-residue foreign peptide antigen, and the I-Ak self major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecule is reported at 3.2 angstrom resolution. The D10 TCR is oriented in an orthogonal mode relative to its peptide-MHC (pMHC) ligand, necessitated by the amino-terminal extension of peptide residues projecting from the MHC class II antigen-binding groove as part of a mini beta sheet. Consequently, the disposition of D10 complementarity-determining region loops is altered relative to that of most pMHCI-specific TCRs; the latter TCRs assume a diagonal orientation, although with substantial variability. Peptide recognition, which involves P-1 to P8 residues, is dominated by the Valpha domain, which also binds to the class II MHC beta1 helix. That docking is limited to one segment of MHC-bound peptide offers an explanation for epitope recognition and altered peptide ligand effects, suggests a structural basis for alloreactivity, and illustrates how bacterial superantigens can span the TCR-pMHCII surface.

Structural basis of T cell recognition.

Exciting breakthroughs in the last two years have begun to elucidate the structural basis of cellular immune recognition. Crystal structures have been determined for full-length and truncated forms of alpha beta T cell receptor (TCR) heterodimers, both alone and in complex with their peptide-MHC (pMHC) ligands or with anti-TCR antibodies. In addition, a truncated CD8 coreceptor has been visualized with a pMHC. Aided in large part by the substantial body of knowledge accumulated over the last 25 years on antibody structure, a number of general conclusions about TCR structure and its recognition of antigen can already be derived from the relatively few TCR structures that have been determined. Small, but important, variations between TCR and antibody structures bear on their functional differences as well as on their specific antigen recognition requirements. As observed in antibodies, canonical CDR loop structures are already emerging for some of the TCR CDR loops. Highly similar docking orientations of the TCR V alpha domains in the TCR/pMHC complex appear to play a primary role in dictating orientation, but the V beta positions diverge widely. Similar TCR contact positions, but whose exact amino acid content can vary, coupled with relatively poor interface shape complementarity, may explain the flexibility and short half-lives of many TCR interactions with pMHC. Here we summarize the current state of this field, and suggest that the knowledge gap between the three-dimensional structure and the signaling function of the TCR can be bridged through a synthesis of molecular biological and biophysical techniques.

Effects of complementarity determining region mutations on the affinity of an alpha/beta T cell receptor: measuring the energy associated with CD4/CD8 repertoire skewing.

It has been proposed that the generally low affinities of T cell receptors (TCRs) for their peptide-major histocompatibility complex (pMHC) ligands (Kd approximately 10(-4) to 10(-7) M) are the result of biological selection rather than an intrinsic affinity limitation imposed by the TCR framework. Using a soluble version of the 2C TCR, we have used complementarity determining region (CDR)-directed mutagenesis to investigate whether the affinity of this receptor for its allogeneic pMHC ligand can be improved upon. We report that several mutants at positions lying within CDR3alpha and CDR2beta showed increased affinities for pMHC compared with the wild-type receptor. Additionally, we have investigated whether Valpha mutations that have been implicated in the phenomenon of CD8(+) repertoire skewing achieve this skewing by means of generalized increases in affinity for MHC-I molecules. Two mutants (S27F and S51P), which each promote skewing toward a CD8(+) phenotype, exhibited significantly reduced affinity for pMHC-I, consistent with a quantitative-instructional model of CD4/CD8 lineage commitment. This model predicts that CD8 is downregulated on thymocytes that have TCR-ligand interactions above a minimal energy threshold. Together, the results (a) demonstrate that engineering higher affinity TCRs is feasible, and (b) provide TCR-pMHC energy values associated with CD4/CD8 repertoire skewing.

Alphabeta T cell receptor interactions with syngeneic and allogeneic ligands: affinity measurements and crystallization.

Cellular immunity is mediated by the interaction of an alphabeta T cell receptor (TCR) with a peptide presented within the context of a major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule. Alloreactive T cells have alphabeta TCRs that can recognize both self- and foreign peptide-MHC (pMHC) complexes, implying that the TCR has significant complementarity with different pMHC. To characterize the molecular basis for alloreactive TCR recognition of pMHC, we have produced a soluble, recombinant form of an alloreactive alphabeta T cell receptor in Drosophila melanogaster cells. This recombinant TCR, 2C, is expressed as a correctly paired alphabeta heterodimer, with the chains covalently connected via a disulfide bond in the C-terminal region. The native conformation of the 2C TCR was probed by surface plasmon resonance (SPR) analysis by using conformation-specific monoclonal antibodies, as well as syngeneic and allogeneic pMHC ligands. The 2C interaction with H-2Kb-dEV8, H-2Kbm3-dEV8, H-2Kb-SIYR, and H-2Ld-p2Ca spans a range of affinities from Kd = 10(-4) to 10(-6)M for the syngeneic (H-2Kb) and allogeneic (H-2Kbm3, H-2Ld) ligands. In general, the syngeneic ligands bind with weaker affinities than the allogeneic ligands, consistent with current threshold models of thymic selection and T cell activation. Crystallization of the 2C TCR required proteolytic trimming of the C-terminal residues of the alpha and beta chains. X-ray quality crystals of complexes of 2C with H-2Kb-dEV8, H-2Kbm3-dEV8 and H-2Kb-SIYR have been grown.

T-cell receptor structure and TCR complexes

The first crystal structures of intact T-cell receptors (TCRs) and their complexes with MHC peptide antigens (pMHC) were reported during the past year, along with those of a single-chain TCR Fv fragment and a β-chain complexed with two different bacterial superantigens. These structures have shown the similarities and differences in the architecture of the antigen-binding regions of TCRs and antibodies, and how the TCR interacts with pMHC ligands as well as with superantigens

Calendar

Thymocytes are thought to be selected on the basis of antigen specificity between TCR and peptide-MHC (pMHC) ligands. The specificity depends primarily on extensive diversities of complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3), whose specificity is considered to be determined through thymocyte selection. We examined the CDR3 length profiles with 20 BV segments in thymocyte subpopulations from C57BL/6 (H-2b), C.B10 (Balb/c congenic, H-2b) and Balb/c (H-2d) mice. The CDR3 length was shorter in both CD4 single positive (SP) and CD8SP than in double positive (DP), but not altered among DP, double negative (DN) 4 and DN3 subpopulations. The CDR3 shortened more prominently in CD4SP than in CD8SP for C57BL/6 and C.B10, but the shortening was only slight for Balb/c. Although the shortening varied considerably among different BV segments, the greater shortening was observed in most BV segments for CD4SP and in several for CD8SP, in particular, the extent was the greatest in BV1, BV2, BV15, BV16, BV23 and BV26 for CD4SP, and in BV13-1 and BV29 for CD8SP. Moreover, the extent and the pattern of CDR3 shortening were basically the same among highly homologous BV segments (e.g. BV12-1 and 12-2; BV13-1, 13-2 and 13-3). These results taken together indicate that (1) the CDR3 shortening occurred between the DP to the SP stages but never earlier, that (2) there would be the MHC class preference for the CDR3 shortening, that (3) it was in part influenced by MHC haplotype, and finally that (4) the primary structure of particular BV segments would possibly affect the CDR3 length in selected thymocytes. It could be deduced from these results that the CDR3 shortening might play roles in ensuring geometrical disposition of CDRs unique to each BV segment and consequently allow CDRs to intimately interact with pMHC ligands.