In this study, finite element analysis (FEA) has been conducted for an improved grouted corrugated duct (GCD) connection design with a reserved recess in bridge footing. This study aims to understand the damage progression mechanism and to evaluate the contribution of each component in the improved GCD connection design. Numerical model based on the experimental results are first created, validated and calibrated. It is found that the confining effect (support and friction force) provided by recess sidewall keeps the connection in good integrity. It also prevents early deformation and early development of transverse cracks along the connection interface, which further avoids the damage concentration at connection joint, transfers the plastic hinge region. Parametric study is then carried out by considering different recess depths, cushion thicknesses, recess diameters, and mortar strengths. The effect of recess details on mechanical behavior is thus studied. Recess depth can be designed as 6–20% of the column section size to ensure a higher upper limit of overall strength and ductility, and it also influences the stress distribution area of the joint local. The stiffness and strength of recess control the local damage, while has limited impact on the overall performance. In addition, preliminary suggestions on the GCD design of recess depth, thickness of mortar cushion, recess diameter, the strength of mortar are proposed.