Alumina-filled epoxies are composites having constituents with highly dissimilar mechanical properties, resulting in complex behavior during shock compression and release. A previous study examined the shock properties of a particular composition in some detail. In the current study, the effects of compositional variations on shock properties were examined. Planar-impact experiments producing states of nearly equal strain were conducted to investigate the effects of changes in the size and shape of alumina particles, and in the total volume fraction of alumina. Laser interferometry and wave timing were used to obtain transmitted wave profiles, Hugoniot states, and release wave velocities. In addition, wave profiles and velocities were obtained in “thin-pulse” experiments that examined the combined effects of compression and release properties in different compositions. Changes in the size and shape of alumina particles were found to have little effect except in the viscous spreading of wave profiles during shock compression. Increasing the volume fraction of alumina resulted in steadily increasing Hugoniot states, wave rise times, and release wave velocities. An important observation was that differences between release wave and shock wave velocities increased significantly as the alumina loading was increased. Consequences of this effect were evident in the thin-pulse experiments, which showed that increased alumina loading resulted in stronger wave attenuation.