ObjectivesOcclusal based virtual surgical planning (VSP) prioritises placement of endosseous dental implants, over replicating native bone contour. This may compromise facial aesthetics. This study aims to compare function and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) following maxillomandibular reconstruction according to ability to replicate preoperative soft-tissue contour and virtual plan. Materials and methodsPatients who had undergone occlusal based VSP osseous free flap reconstruction of the maxilla or mandible, with high-resolution pre- and postoperative facial computerised tomography imaging, and completion of FACE-Q questionnaire were retrospectively identified. Accuracy of reconstruction compared to preoperative soft tissue contour and virtual plan, was measured using 3DSlicer® and CloudCompare® in three dimensions. Random effects modelling determined associations between bony and soft tissue accuracy and HRQOL/functional domains. ResultsTwenty-two patients met the inclusion criteria. For mandibular and maxillary reconstructions, better soft tissue accuracy was associated with improved appearance (p = 0.048) and appearance distress (p = 0.034). For mandibular reconstructions, better soft tissue accuracy was associated with improved smile (p=0.039) and smile distress (p=0.031). For maxillary reconstructions, better bony accuracy was associated with improved appearance (p=0.023) and drooling distress (p=0.001). Unexpectedly, better bony accuracy was associated with worse eating and drinking (p=0.015), oral competence (p=0.005) and eating distress (p=0.013) in mandibular reconstructions. ConclusionWhilst soft tissue accuracy was associated with better functional and HRQOL outcomes, bone accuracy was associated with worse oral function/distress in mandibular reconstruction. These results need validation but should be considered when performing occlusal-based VSP, which prioritises dental rehabilitation over replicating facial bony contour.
Read full abstract