Abstract Burn severity, commonly assessed as the amount of fuel consumed during fire, is an indicator of postfire sediment yield and erosion. This study examined the effect of burn severity on sediment and nutrient response in three different fire-adapted forest types of the Southeast. Soil and litter samples were experimentally burned to achieve increasing levels of fuel consumption. Simulated rainfall was applied to burned litter samples collected from pine, hardwood, and mixed hardwood-pine forests in the Clemson Experimental Forest. Runoff and leachate samples were collected and analyzed for sediment yield (kilograms per hectare) and total suspended solids (grams per liter); both runoff and leachate samples were analyzed for ammonium (NH4–), nitrate (NO3–), and orthophosphate (PO43–). Sediment yield and total suspended solids increased at only the highest burn severity treatment in all three forest types, with pine litter samples yielding significantly greater sediment in surface runoff than both mixed and hardwood samples. Burn treatment did not readily affect soluble nutrient concentrations in either runoff or leachate, but the data suggest that high-severity burning increases the availability of PO43– bound to sediment. This study suggests that high-severity burn patches function as sediment sources, but overall sediment and nutrient response to burning was minimal. Study Implications This study suggests that low-to-moderate burn severity, in terms of litter removal, is not an important indicator of sediment and nutrient exports from southeastern forests; precipitation in the immediate aftermath of fire (<48 hours) is not an effective transport mechanism for biologically available macronutrients; and that even at the highest burn severity treatment, sediment yield was relatively low.