Evolutionary pathways to the larval eyes of insects. Higher Dipteran stemmata and the evolutionary development of Bolwig's organ 1. A cornrehensive morphological study of the photoreceptors in the so-called hemi — Institut fur Biologie I (Zoologie) der Albert-Ludwigs-Universitat, Albertstr. 21a, D-7800 Freiburg i. Brsg., FRGand acephalic lrvae of Brachycera was undertaken. In Brachyceran larvae the head casule originally is more or less retracted into the thorax. The larval hotoreceptor in Musca and Drosophila, here called Bolwig's organ, is situated on the outer side of the cephalopharyngeal apparatus, well below the surface. The aim of this study is to elucidate the homology of Bolwig's organ, i. e. whether Bolwig's organ originated from typical stemmata during the evolution of Cyclor-rhaphan larval organlsation or whether it represents a unique type of hotoreceptor. Larval photoreceptors and the anatomy of the head capsules of representative Erachycerans were examined by means of light and electron microscopy. In particular, the site and the structure of the photofecetors of Stratiomys (Stratiomyidae, Solva (Solvidae), Atherix ibis (Athericidae), Rhagio (Rhagionidae), Thereva (derevidae), Lonchoptera (Lonchoteridae), Epistrohe balteata, Volu-cella bombylans, Eristalis tenax (Syrphidae), Drosophila (f;rosophilidae), jannia and Musca domestica (Muscidae) were investigated. 2. Brachyceran stemmata are either situated on the ocular plates of the free remnant of the head (Stratiomyidae, Therevidae), or on the inner wall of an epidermal invaination, which includes epithelia of the head as well as of the thorax (Tabaniformia). In adfition, they can be found on the outer side of the tentorial phragmata (Cyclorrhapha). In all taxa studied, stemmata keep contact directly with the epithelium or through short processes of eithelial cells. 3. Ancestral Brachycera have fused stemmata that correspond with typical larval eyes of other holometabolan insects. 4. A cornea is found solely in Stratiomyidae and Xylophagidae, in contrast to all other taxa, where no dioptric apparatus is found. 5. In “Orthorrapha” and in “Aschiza”, rhabdomeric photoreceptors occur, forming a fused, star-shaped or Ktticed rhabdom. In Schizophoran larvae, retinular cells are distinguished by a different type of surface enlargement of the photoreceptor cell membrane. Here, the membrane forms flat ramella. The latter originate from transformed and/or rudimentary rhabdomeric microvilli. 6. In the primitive “Orthorrhapha”, pigment cups can be found, that are composed of retinular pirnent, whereas in derived Brachycera, pigment grains are absent. In Cyclorrhapha, tentorial piramata and their optic deressions operate as external and functional piment cups 7. In Therevidae and in Syrphidae, a tracheal tapetum lucidum can be founfi which la, been evolved independently in both families. The tapetum is always found together with inversely orientated retinular cells. 8. The homology of Brachceran stemmata is shown by a transformation series of stem-mata's site and fine structure. The homology is corroborated by the identical innervation in primitive and derived taxa, the identical site within Cyclorrhaha, and structural similarities of “Orthorrhaphan” and primitive Cylorrhaphan stemmata. Although transformations of the fine structure appear as a sequence or reductions, particular adaptations such as multilication of retinular celfs (Epistrophe), or deepening of the pigment cup (Musca) have evolved separately. Despite the fact that in Brachyceran larvae the head has been reorganized, the eyes still keep contact with the epithelium of the frontal sacks and/or tentorial phragmata. 9. The transformation series given shows that Bolwig's organ represents a highly modified stemma.
Read full abstract