Photosynthetic Charge Separation Research Articles

Rational design of photosynthetic reaction center protein maquettes.

New technologies for efficient solar-to-fuel energy conversion will help facilitate a global shift from dependence on fossil fuels to renewable energy. Nature uses photosynthetic reaction centers to convert photon energy into a cascade of electron-transfer reactions that eventually produce chemical fuel. The design of new reaction centers de novo deepens our understanding of photosynthetic charge separation and may one day allow production of biofuels with higher thermodynamic efficiency than natural photosystems. Recently, we described the multi-step electron-transfer activity of a designed reaction center maquette protein (the RC maquette), which can assemble metal ions, tyrosine, a Zn tetrapyrrole, and heme into an electron-transport chain. Here, we detail our modular strategy for rational protein design and show that the intended RC maquette design agrees with crystal structures in various states of assembly. A flexible, dynamic apo-state collapses by design into a more ordered holo-state upon cofactor binding. Crystal structures illustrate the structural transitions upon binding of different cofactors. Spectroscopic assays demonstrate that the RC maquette binds various electron donors, pigments, and electron acceptors with high affinity. We close with a critique of the present RC maquette design and use electron-tunneling theory to envision a path toward a designed RC with a substantially higher thermodynamic efficiency than natural photosystems.

Excitonic structure and charge separation in the heliobacterial reaction center probed by multispectral multidimensional spectroscopy

Photochemical reaction centers are the engines that drive photosynthesis. The reaction center from heliobacteria (HbRC) has been proposed to most closely resemble the common ancestor of photosynthetic reaction centers, motivating a detailed understanding of its structure-function relationship. The recent elucidation of the HbRC crystal structure motivates advanced spectroscopic studies of its excitonic structure and charge separation mechanism. We perform multispectral two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy of the HbRC and corresponding numerical simulations, resolving the electronic structure and testing and refining recent excitonic models. Through extensive examination of the kinetic data by lifetime density analysis and global target analysis, we reveal that charge separation proceeds via a single pathway in which the distinct A0 chlorophyll a pigment is the primary electron acceptor. In addition, we find strong delocalization of the charge separation intermediate. Our findings have general implications for the understanding of photosynthetic charge separation mechanisms, and how they might be tuned to achieve different functional goals.

Accurate Computation of the Absorption Spectrum of Chlorophyll a with Pair Natural Orbital Coupled Cluster Methods.

The ability to accurately compute low-energy excited states of chlorophylls is critically important for understanding the vital roles they play in light harvesting, energy transfer, and photosynthetic charge separation. The challenge for quantum chemical methods arises both from the intrinsic complexity of the electronic structure problem and, in the case of biological models, from the need to account for protein–pigment interactions. In this work, we report electronic structure calculations of unprecedented accuracy for the low-energy excited states in the Q and B bands of chlorophyll a. This is achieved by using the newly developed domain-based local pair natural orbital (DLPNO) implementation of the similarity transformed equation of motion coupled cluster theory with single and double excitations (STEOM-CCSD) in combination with sufficiently large and flexible basis sets. The results of our DLPNO–STEOM-CCSD calculations are compared with more approximate approaches. The results demonstrate that, in contrast to time-dependent density functional theory, the DLPNO–STEOM-CCSD method provides a balanced performance for both absorption bands. In addition to vertical excitation energies, we have calculated the vibronic spectrum for the Q and B bands through a combination of DLPNO–STEOM-CCSD and ground-state density functional theory frequency calculations. These results serve as a basis for comparison with gas-phase experiments.

Double-crossed polarization transient grating for distinction and characterization of coherences.

Coherent phenomena have been widely suggested to play a role in efficient photosynthetic light harvesting and charge separation processes. To substantiate these ideas, separation of intramolecular vibrational coherences from purely electronic or mixed vibronic coherences is essential. To this end, polarization-controlled two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy has been shown to provide an effective selectivity. We show that analogous discrimination can be achieved in a transient grating experiment by employing the double-crossed polarization scheme. This is demonstrated in a study of bacterial reaction centers. Significantly faster acquisition times of these experiments make longer population time scans feasible, thereby achieving improved frequency resolution and allowing for accurate extraction of coherence frequencies and dephasing times. These parameters are crucial for the discussion on relevance of the measured coherences to energy or electron transfer phenomena.

Primary processes in the bacterial reaction center probed by two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy

In the initial steps of photosynthesis, reaction centers convert solar energy to stable charge-separated states with near-unity quantum efficiency. The reaction center from purple bacteria remains an important model system for probing the structure-function relationship and understanding mechanisms of photosynthetic charge separation. Here we perform 2D electronic spectroscopy (2DES) on bacterial reaction centers (BRCs) from two mutants of the purple bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus, spanning the Q y absorption bands of the BRC. We analyze the 2DES data using a multiexcitation global-fitting approach that employs a common set of basis spectra for all excitation frequencies, incorporating inputs from the linear absorption spectrum and the BRC structure. We extract the exciton energies, resolving the previously hidden upper exciton state of the special pair. We show that the time-dependent 2DES data are well-represented by a two-step sequential reaction scheme in which charge separation proceeds from the excited state of the special pair (P*) to P+HA- via the intermediate P+BA- When inhomogeneous broadening and Stark shifts of the B* band are taken into account we can adequately describe the 2DES data without the need to introduce a second charge-separation pathway originating from the excited state of the monomeric bacteriochlorophyll BA*.

Quantum \u2013 coherent dynamics in photosynthetic charge separation revealed by wavelet analysis

Experimental/theoretical evidence for sustained vibration-assisted electronic (vibronic) coherence in the Photosystem II Reaction Center (PSII RC) indicates that photosynthetic solar-energy conversion might be optimized through the interplay of electronic and vibrational quantum dynamics. This evidence has been obtained by investigating the primary charge separation process in the PSII RC by two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2DES) and Redfield modeling of the experimental data. However, while conventional Fourier transform analysis of the 2DES data allows oscillatory signatures of vibronic coherence to be identified in the frequency domain in the form of static 2D frequency maps, the real-time evolution of the coherences is lost. Here we apply for the first time wavelet analysis to the PSII RC 2DES data to obtain time-resolved 2D frequency maps. These maps allow us to demonstrate that (i) coherence between the excitons initiating the two different charge separation pathways is active for more than 500 fs, and (ii) coherence between exciton and charge-transfer states, the reactant and product of the charge separation reaction, respectively; is active for at least 1 ps. These findings imply that the PSII RC employs coherence (i) to sample competing electron transfer pathways, and ii) to perform directed, ultrafast and efficient electron transfer.

Invitro reconstitution of co-translational D1 insertion reveals a role of the cpSec-Alb3 translocase and Vipp1in photosystem II biogenesis.

Photosystem II (PS II) is a multi-subunit complex localized in the thylakoid membrane that performs the light-dependent photosynthetic charge separation. The PS II reaction centre comprises, among others, the D1 protein. De novo synthesis and repair of PS II require efficient mechanisms for transport and insertion of plastid encoded D1 into the thylakoid membrane. To elucidate the process of D1 insertion, we used an invitro translation system derived from pea chloroplasts to reconstitute the D1 insertion. Thereby, truncated D1 encoding psbA mRNAs lacking a stop codon were translated in the presence of thylakoid membranes and the translation was stalled by addition of chloramphenicol. The generated ribosome nascent chain complexes (RNCs) were tightly associated with the thylakoids. Subsequently, these D1 insertion intermediates were enriched from solubilized thylakoids by sucrose cushion centrifugation. Immunological analyses demonstrated the presence of the cpSec translocase, Alb3, cpFtsY, cpSRP54 and Vipp1 (vesicle-inducing protein in plastids 1) in the enriched D1 insertion intermediates. A complex formation between cpSecY, Alb3, cpFtsY and Vipp1in thylakoid membranes was shown by gel filtration chromatography, BN (Blue Native)/SDS-PAGE and co-immunoprecipitation experiments. Furthermore, a stimulating effect of recombinant Vipp1 on the formation of a D1 insertion intermediate was observed invitro. These results suggest a co-operative function of these proteins in D1 insertion.

Connecting photosynthetic light harvesting and charge separation at higher detail.

Connecting photosynthetic light harvesting and charge separation at higher detail.

Expression, purification, crystallization and preliminary X-ray structure analysis of wild-type and L(M196)H-mutantRhodobacter sphaeroidesreaction centres

The electron and proton transport mediated by protein-bound cofactors in photosynthesis have been investigated by various methods in order to determine the energetics, the dynamics and the pathway of this process. In purple bacteria, primary photosynthetic charge separation and the build-up of a proton gradient across the periplasmic membrane are catalyzed by the photosynthetic reaction centre (RC). Here, the purification, crystallization and preliminary X-ray analysis of wild-type and L(M196)H-mutant RCs of Rhodobacter sphaeroides are presented, enabling study of the influence of the protein environment of the primary electron donor on the spectral properties and photochemical activity of the RC.

Quantum effects in photosynthesis

In photosynthesis light is absorbed by the light-harvesting antenna and within several tens of picoseconds transferred to the photosynthetic reaction center (RC) where an ultrafast charge separation is initiated. Photosynthetic purple bacteria employ a single reaction center. In contrast, in photosynthesis of plants, algae and cyanobacteria, two reaction centers, Photosystem II (PSII) and Photosystem I (PSI), operate in series. PSII uses light to extract electrons from water (to produce oxygen); PSI uses light to reduce NADP+to NADPH. The electron transfer from PSII to PSI is coupled to the build-up of a proton motive force (pmf) that is used to form ATP. NADPH and ATP are required in the Calvin-Benson cycle to produce a reduced sugar. In the following we will discuss photosynthetic charge separation and photosynthetic light-harvesting with an emphasis on the role of quantum mechanics.

ChemInform Abstract: Fullerenes as Novel Acceptors in Photosynthetic Electron Transfer

We propose a novel strategy using fullerenes for the construction of solar energy conversion systems that mimic the primary electron transfer events in photosynthesis. Redox-active fullerenes such as C60 and C70 were covalently bound to a porphyrin and the photophysical properties of the resulting compounds were investigated. Regardless of solvent and linkage, the charge-separated state is produced efficiently in zincporphyrin–fullerene dyads, showing that fullerenes are good electron acceptors. The most intriguing characteristic of fullerenes in electron transfer is that they accelerate photoinduced charge separation as well as charge shift and slow down charge recombination, properties that are in sharp contrast with those of conventional two-dimensional aromatic acceptors such as quinones and imides. The peculiar electron transfer properties of fullerenes can be explained by the small reorganization energies, which make it possible to optimize artificial photosynthetic multistep charge separation. A combination of the two strategies, multistep electron transfer and small reorganization energy of fullerenes, has been applied to light energy conversion systems as well as the more complex molecular systems such as triads. Highly efficient photosynthetic multistep electron transfer has been realized at gold electrodes modified with self-assembled monolayers of fullerene-containing molecules. These results will provide new principles and concepts to develop artificial photosynthetic materials as well as molecular devices.

Entropic Changes Control the Charge Separation Process in Triads Mimicking Photosynthetic Charge Separation

Laser-induced optoacoustic spectroscopy (LIOAS) measurements with carotene-porphyrin-acceptor "supermolecular" triads (C-P-A, with A = C60, a naphthoquinone NQ, and a naphthoquinone derivative, Q) were carried out with the purpose of analyzing the thermodynamic parameters for the formation and decay of the respective long-lived charge separated state C*+-P-A*-. The novel procedure of inclusion of the benzonitrile solutions of the triads in Triton X-100 micelle nanoreactors suspended in water permitted the separation of the enthalpic and structural volume change contributions to the LIOAS signals, by performing the measurements in the range 4-20 degrees C. Contractions of 4.2, 5.7, and 4.2 mL mol-1 are concomitant with the formation of C*+-P-A*- for A = C60, Q and NQ, respectively. These contractions are mostly attributed to solvent movements and possible conformational changes upon photoinduced electron transfer, due to the attraction of the oppositely charged ends, as a consequence of the giant dipole moment developed in these compounds upon charge separation ( approximately 110 D). The estimations combining the calculated free energies and the LIOAS-derived enthalpy changes indicate that entropy changes, attributed to solvent movements, control the process of electron transfer for the three triads, especially for C-P-C60 and C-P-Q. The heat released during the decay of 1 mol of charge separated state (CS) is much smaller than the respective enthalpy content obtained from the LIOAS measurements for the CS formation. This is attributed to the production of long-lived energy storing species upon CS decay.

Low-Temperature Pulsed EPR Study at 34 GHz of the Triplet States of the Primary Electron Donor P865and the Carotenoid in Native and Mutant Bacterial Reaction Centers ofRhodobacter sphaeroides

The photosynthetic charge separation in bacterial reaction centers occurs predominantly along one of two nearly symmetric branches of cofactors. Low-temperature EPR spectra of the triplet states of the chlorophyll and carotenoid pigments in the reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26.1, 2.4.1 and two double-mutants GD(M203)/AW(M260) and LH(M214)/AW(M260) have been recorded at 34 GHz to investigate the relative activities of the "A" and "B" branches. The triplet states are found to derive from radical pair and intersystem crossing mechanisms, and the rates of formation are anisotropic. The former mechanism is operative for Rb. sphaeroides R-26.1, 2.4.1, and mutant GD(M203)/AW(M260) and indicates that A-branch charge separation proceeds at temperatures down to 10 K. The latter mechanism, derived from the spin polarization and operative for mutant LH(M214)/AW(M260), indicates that no long-lived radical pairs are formed upon direct excitation of the primary donor and that virtually no charge separation at the B-branch occurs at low temperatures. When the temperature is raised above 30 K, B-branch charge separation is observed, which is at most 1% of A-branch charge separation. B-branch radical pair formation can be induced at 10 K with low yield by direct excitation of the bacteriopheophytin of the B-branch at 590 nm. The formation of a carotenoid triplet state is observed. The rate of formation depends on the orientation of the reaction center in the magnetic field and is caused by a magnetic field dependence of the oscillation frequency by which the singlet and triplet radical pair precursor states interchange. Combination of these findings with literature data provides strong evidence that the thermally activated transfer step on the B-branch occurs between the primary donor, P865, and the accessory bacteriochlorophyll, whereas this step is barrierless down to 10 K along the A-branch.

Mutation of Arginine 357 of the CP43 Protein of Photosystem II Severely Impairs the Catalytic S-State Cycle of the H2O Oxidation Complex

Basic amino acid side chains situated in active sites may mediate critical proton transfers during an enzymatic catalytic cycle. In the case of photosynthetic water oxidation, a strong base is postulated to facilitate the deprotonation of the active site Mn4-Ca cluster, thereby allowing the otherwise thermodynamically constrained transfer of an electron away from the Mn4-Ca cluster to the oxidized redox active tyrosine radical, YZ*, generated by photosynthetic charge separation. Arginine 357 of the CP43 polypeptide may be located in the second coordination shell of the O2-evolving Mn4-Ca cluster of photosystem II (PSII) according to current structural models. An ostensibly conservative substitution mutation, CP43-357K, was investigated using polarographic and fluorescence techniques in evaluating its potential impact on S-state cycling. Cells containing the CP43-357K mutation lost their capacity for autotrophic growth and exhibited a drastic reduction in O2 evolving activity ( approximately 15% of that of the wild type) despite the fact that mutant cells contained more than 80% of the concentration of charge-separating PSII reaction centers and more than half of these contained photooxidizable Mn. Fluorescence kinetics indicated that acceptor side electron transfer, dominated by the transfer of electrons from QA- to QB, was unaffected, but the fraction of centers containing Mn clusters capable of forming the S2 state was reduced to approximately 40% of that of the wild type. Analysis of O2 yields using a bare platinum electrode indicated a severe defect in the S-state cycling properties of the mutant H2O oxidation complexes. Although O2 evolution was delayed to the third flash during a train of single-turnover saturating flashes, the pattern of O2 emission did not exhibit a discernible periodicity indicating a very high miss factor, which was estimated to be approximately 45% compared to the wild-type value of approximately 10%. On the other hand, the multiflash fluorescence measurements indicate that the yield of formation of the S2 state from S1 is diminished by approximately 20%, although this latter estimate is complicated by the presence of damaged PSII centers. Taken together, the experiments indicate that the high miss factor observed during S-state cycling is likely due to a defect in the higher S-state transitions. These results are discussed in relation to the idea that CP43-R357 may serve as a ligand to bicarbonate or as the catalytic base proposed to mediate proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) in the higher S states of the catalytic cycle of H2O oxidation.

Protein Dynamics Control the Kinetics of Initial Electron Transfer in Photosynthesis

The initial electron transfer dynamics during photosynthesis have been studied in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers from wild type and 14 mutants in which the driving force and the kinetics of charge separation vary over a broad range. Surprisingly, the protein relaxation kinetics, as measured by tryptophan absorbance changes, are invariant in these mutants. By applying a reaction-diffusion model, we can fit the complex electron transfer kinetics of each mutant quantitatively, varying only the driving force. These results indicate that initial photosynthetic charge separation is limited by protein dynamics rather than by a static electron transfer barrier.

FTIR spectroscopy shows structural similarities between photosystems II from cyanobacteria and spinach.

Photosystem II (PSII), an essential component of oxygenic photosynthesis, is a membrane-bound pigment protein complex found in green plants and cyanobacteria. Whereas the molecular structure of cyanobacterial PSII has been resolved with at least medium resolution [Zouni, A., Witt, H.-T., Kern, J., Fromme, P., Krauss, N., Saenger, W. & Orth, P. (2001) Nature (London) 409, 739-743; Kamiya, N. & Shen, J.R. (2003) Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 100, 98-103], the structure of higher plant PSII is only known at low resolution. Therefore Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy was used to compare PSII from both Thermosynechococcus elongatus and Synechocystis PCC6803 core complexes with PSII-enriched membranes from spinach (BBY). FTIR difference spectra of T. elongatus core complexes are presented for several different intermediates. As the FTIR difference spectra show close similarities among the three species, the structural arrangement of cofactors in PSII and their interactions with the protein microenvironment during photosynthetic charge separation must be very similar in higher plant PSII and cyanobacterial PSII. A structural model of higher plant PSII can therefore be predicted from the structure of cyanobacterial PSII.

Controlling the Pathway of Photosynthetic Charge Separation in Bacterial Reaction Centers

For at least 2 billion years, the structure of the photosynthetic reaction center has maintained an approximate rotational symmetry, in both plants and bacteria, consisting of a heterodimeric core ...

Chlorophyll thermoluminescence of leaf discs: simple instruments and progress in signal interpretation open the way to new ecophysiological indicators.

Luminescence from photosynthetic material observed in darkness following illumination is a delayed fluorescence produced by a recombination of charge pairs stored in photosystem II, i.e. the back-reaction of photosynthetic charge separation. Thermoluminescence (TL) is a technique consisting of a rapid cooling followed by the progressive warming of a preilluminated sample to reveal the different types of charge pairs as successive emission bands, which are resolved better than the corresponding decay phases recorded at constant temperatures. Progress in thermoelectric Peltier elements and in compact light detectors made the development of simple, affordable and transportable instruments possible. These instruments take advantage of multifurcated light guides for combined TL, fluorescence and absorbance/reflectance measurements. Meanwhile, experiments on unfrozen leaf discs, with excitation by single turn-over flashes or far red light and infiltration by specific inhibitors/uncouplers, have led to a better understanding of in vivo TL signals. Much like chlorophyll fluorescence and in a complementary way, TL in the 0-60 degrees C temperature range not only informs on the state of photosystem II in leaf tissues and its possible alterations, but also gives a broader insight into the energetic state inside the chloroplast by probing (1) the light-induced or dark-stable thylakoid proton gradient through the protonation of the Mn oxygen-evolving complex, (2) the induction of cyclic/chlororespiratory electron flow towards the plastoquinone pool, (3) the [NADPH+ATP] assimilatory potential. By a different mechanism, warming above 60 degrees C without preillumination reveals chemiluminescence high temperature thermoluminescence (HTL) bands due to the radiative thermolysis of peroxides, which are indicators of oxidative stress in leaves.

Photo-electrochemical control of photosystem II chlorophyll fluorescence in vivo

The effect of electric field on chlorophyll fluorescence is considered on the basis of the reversible radical pair model. The hypothesis is presented that the electric fields generated by photosynthetic charge separation in reaction centers and propagated laterally through the thylakoid lumen are associated with changes in chlorophyll fluorescence yield.

Selective perturbation of the second electron transfer step in mutant bacterial reaction centers

In order to specifically perturb the primary electron acceptor B A — a monomeric bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) a — involved in bacterial photosynthetic charge separation (CS), the protein environment of B A in the reaction center (RC) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides was modified by site-directed mutagenesis. Isolated RCs were characterized by redox titrations, low temperature optical spectroscopy, ENDOR/TRIPLE resonance spectroscopy and femtosecond time-resolved spectroscopy. Two mutations were studied: In the GS(M203) mutant a serine is introduced near the ring E keto group of B A, while in FY(L146) a phenylalanine near the ring A acetyl group of B A is replaced by tyrosine. In all mutations the oxidation potential of the primary electron donor P as well as the electronic structure of both the P + radical cation and the radical anion of the secondary electron acceptor, H A − , are not significantly altered compared to the wild type (WT), while changes of the optical absorption spectra at 77 K in the BChl Q X and Q Y regions are observed. The GS(M203) mutation only leads to a minor retardation of the CS reactions at room temperature, whereas for FY(L146) significant deviations from the native electron transfer (ET) rates could be detected: In addition to a faster first (2.9 ps) and a slower second (1 ps) ET step, a new 8-ps time constant was found in the FY(L146) mutant, which can be ascribed to a fraction of RCs with slowed down secondary ET. The results allow us to address the functional role of the acetyl group of B A and question the role of the free energy changes as the main determining factor of ET rates in RCs. It is concluded that structural rearrangements alter the electronic coupling between the pigments and thereby influence the rate of fast CS.