The development of lignin-derived functional additives for rubber composites has gained growing importance in light of biomass valorization. This work aims at preparing phenolic novolak resin with lignin as one building block for reinforcing natural rubber. A one-pot two-step synthetic approach involving phenolation and copolymerization was developed to prepare lignin-phenol-formaldehyde resins (LPF), wherein 30 wt% of phenol was substituted by lignin. With increasing the ratio of formaldehyde/phenol functionality (F/P), resins show increased molecular weight, elevated glass transition temperature and declined curing activity. The resin with F/P of 0.68/1 exhibits a higher stiffening effect compared to the control without lignin. This enhancement is attributed to lignin's ability to form a hyperbranched structure with multiple phenolic arms as implied by GPC results, acting as a crosslinking hub and facilitating the formation of an effective network. Furthermore, we introduced cardanol with a flexible alkene chain to prepare cardanol-lignin-phenol-formaldehyde resins (CLPF). The CLPF15 resin with cardanol/lignin/phenol of 15/30/55 wt% achieves the maximum stiffening effect due to improved compatibility with natural rubber. This study provides insights into the design and optimization of lignin-copolymerized resins for enhancing the mechanical properties of rubber composites.