Exposure at conception to phenytoin (PHT), phenobarbital (PB), and carbamazepine (CBZ) has been associated with several different effects on the fetus, including hypoplasia of the distal phalanges, dysmorphic facial features, and structural abnormalities such as oral clefts and neural tube defects. One question is whether each of these antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) has the same effects or just similar effects. A systematic examination of the fingers of children exposed at conception to PHT, PB, or CBZ, as monotherapy, has been used to address this question. The findings in the examinations of the fingers of 115 AED-exposed children (40, PHT; 34, PB; 41, CBZ) and their parents were compared to the findings in 111 age- and sex-matched children and their parents. The evaluations used were both subjective assessments and objective measurements. Shortening and narrowing of the fifth fingernail and an increased frequency of arch patterns in the dermal ridges were more common in PHT-exposed children. A significant decrease in the length of the nail, but not width, occurred in the PB-exposed children. Stiffness of the interphalangeal joints was more common in the CBZ-exposed children. The findings in children exposed to PHT, PB, or CBZ, as monotherapy, showed that all three exposures in early pregnancy affected the fingers, but the effects were not the same. The most striking effects were present in PHT-exposed children.